comment on college essay please?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • zhul4nder
    FFR Player
    • Jun 2006
    • 231

    #1

    comment on college essay please?

    essay changed for editing~!

    the prompt was to write about a meaningful experience that helped me become the person that i am today...so i did just that

    here's the essay
    With a death of a loved one, the coloration of life’s beauty greys. Things that mattered before become pedestrian. Memories cherished become memories that only bring about regret that we didn’t enjoy those moments more. Bullying on the other-hand creates memories that we’d wish we never had. It makes us regret to have those moments that we wished we were invisible. However, both types of memories created a person that no teacher or parent could cultivate; they created a person that lives without prejudice.

    My piano teacher’s death marked the end of good times. Inspirer of my persistence in music, Every week with him, I would learn something new, whether it was as trivial as shooting a rubber band or something as essential as how to show respect to elders. Time with him was shortened however. He was diagnosed with liver cancer and died during the middle of my sophomore year.

    Finding a companion to lean on became a priority over everything else; at least that’s what it felt like at the time. With such focus on my own sorrow, I only saw his loneliness and unhappiness, a flaw that would teach me that an open mind is infinitely more beneficial than closed mind. Similar to the Hutus in the Rwandan genocide, my scope only included one identity element. However, what differed was that the Hutu’s despised the Tutsis for their identity while I tried to fabricate a connection with mine. This focus ultimately led to misfortune in both situations; the Hutus massacred the Tutsis and for myself, the bully mocked me at every chance he could.

    Prejudice can take many forms. It could be simply mistaking a detail based on someone’s appearance or much more menacing such as pure racism. Prejudice can even be intertwined into abstract things that we don’t realize could even become biased. The intense affliction after my piano teacher’s death narrowed my window to see the entirety of the person which allowed my weaknesses to be exposed. Time and time again while the consequences have differed from mine, history has proven that prejudice and assumptions like these merely fog up people’s interpretations of each other. The Slave Trade, Women’s rights, and the Nazi regime, all concrete examples from history, have proven prejudice can do nothing but corrupt nearly everything from country alliances to love between brothers.

    I feel I have been blessed for my unfortunate experience to have given me such a powerful insight on the workings of society. However lucky that I may feel, countless many still are blinded by asserted assumptions. There are News flashes everyday about the war on terrorism, the war on sex slaves, and pretty much wars on any social injustices there are. So many wars are fought, but truly only one war need be waged; that war is the war against prejudice.


    make as many comments as you'd like
    Last edited by zhul4nder; 11-29-2008, 02:18 AM.

    [url=http://www.narutoflow.com/character-quiz/]Take the Naruto Character

    for brawlers: 2836-1905-4019
    I don't know how well it'll work, but give me a add , or pm me so i can add you.
  • Afrobean
    Admiral in the Red Army
    • Dec 2003
    • 13262

    #2
    Re: comment on college essay please?

    I didn't even read it, but I'd say it's way too short. I don't care if it's longer than the minimum you were given, that is short as hell.

    Comment

    • dore
      caveman pornstar
      FFR Simfile Author
      FFR Music Producer
      • Feb 2006
      • 6317

      #3
      Re: comment on college essay please?

      500 word essays are short lol

      It looks fine for the most part, a couple grammar things that stood out:

      "With those evils, came an unannounced confidence that uppercut me flat on my back."
      -Lose the comma, it's unnecessary.

      "There will always be bumps on the way, bullies, friends, and family."
      -The first comma should be a colon (There will always be bumps on the way; bullies, friends, and family.)

      I didn't thoroughly proofread, those were two I caught on the initial read. It's not a bad essay, just keep revising.
      http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IREnpHco9mw

      Comment

      • zhul4nder
        FFR Player
        • Jun 2006
        • 231

        #4
        Re: comment on college essay please?

        @ bean,

        my original essay was 700 words. So i had actually took 10 mins to cut out 200 freaking words.

        [url=http://www.narutoflow.com/character-quiz/]Take the Naruto Character

        for brawlers: 2836-1905-4019
        I don't know how well it'll work, but give me a add , or pm me so i can add you.

        Comment

        • rzr
          TWG Veteran
          • Oct 2007
          • 7608

          #5
          Re: comment on college essay please?

          I wouldn't submit it just yet. Your smilies and metaphors could use some work. The grammar mistakes were already pointed out. It feels like you're laying things on a bit thick. I mean, if I were reading it and using that to judge if you got in, I would bluntly see it as a pity plea. If it's your true experience, I'm sorry, and I know the feelings. Just tryin' to help, hope that wasn't harsh.

          Originally posted by darkshark
          Everyone sucks at this game. The second you think you're good is the second you stop trying to get better.
          Originally posted by aperson
          i had a mri the other day it was the best song i heard in years

          Originally posted by Sprite-
          More of a joke than the time I deleted all the credits on the site.
          Originally posted by MinaciousGrace
          yeah my goldfish think im a riot they do this thing where they turn upside down and float to the top of the tank

          i guess their alcohol tolerance isnt as high as mine

          Comment

          • zhul4nder
            FFR Player
            • Jun 2006
            • 231

            #6
            Re: comment on college essay please?

            Then what should i fix it with? explain how it's made me see things differently? This is just my first draft anyways.

            [url=http://www.narutoflow.com/character-quiz/]Take the Naruto Character

            for brawlers: 2836-1905-4019
            I don't know how well it'll work, but give me a add , or pm me so i can add you.

            Comment

            • rzr
              TWG Veteran
              • Oct 2007
              • 7608

              #7
              Re: comment on college essay please?

              Well, is the experience true?

              Originally posted by darkshark
              Everyone sucks at this game. The second you think you're good is the second you stop trying to get better.
              Originally posted by aperson
              i had a mri the other day it was the best song i heard in years

              Originally posted by Sprite-
              More of a joke than the time I deleted all the credits on the site.
              Originally posted by MinaciousGrace
              yeah my goldfish think im a riot they do this thing where they turn upside down and float to the top of the tank

              i guess their alcohol tolerance isnt as high as mine

              Comment

              • gnr61
                FFR Simfile Author
                FFR Simfile Author
                • Oct 2005
                • 7251

                #8
                Re: comment on college essay please?

                Originally posted by zhul4nder
                During my high school career, there have been times when life as a student at Foothill High school (red.) seemed unbearable. I was trapped with no place to run or hide. At school, there were bullies that hated me for my identity, and my family who--omit, your family was not at your school rejected my identity as well.

                It was then I felt that I had to find someone. Someone who had had the same experiences as me: being bullied, being detached from family as much as I was--probably add something else to this list for fluency. I found Danny, depressed in a/the corner. I felt that if the world had given birth to two damned children, he would have been my twin. He was always a trouble-maker and because of it, teachers and students alike would treat him as a hopeless cause. Everyday I’d try talking with him, share--talking, sharing. gerund inconsistencies are a no no my pain with him. However, every time we--hard to converse by yourself were at the brink of conversing, I felt that--omit/fluency it was impossible that he would respond to me. It wasn’t until the middle of junior year that the dichotomy between talking and not talking with him was blurred for a split second and the words flowed out of my mouth. They weren’t deep questions, simply general questions about his life. Unaware of the hell that I would go through after this conversation, I continued to pursue friendship with Danny.

                It was as though I unlocked some kind of door and--doors don't unleash evil horrors unleashed the evil horrors that were hidden behind that boyish face with that initial conversation move to right after the word door. With those evils,--omit came an unannounced confidence that uppercut me flat on my back--yuck. I was only trying to be a friend, yet in his eyes, I deserved as much punishment as if I had mocked him for years. Apparently, he had alliances with those bullies that picked on me and through Danny, came on stronger than ever. The name-calling constantly frustrated me because I was not--contractions are a no no one who expressed my pain. It was not until it escalated to unorthodox hand signals to me in front of my parents--lmao that I had--omit/tense tipped over the edge.

                After a nearly hour-long conversation with my parents, I decided that the only thing for me to do was to stop it--omit the bullying; I had to talk with his parents about his behavior myself. I was at his doorstep when the same massive anxiety attack camewhat anxiety attack was this the same as. What if his parents took his side of the story, what if I open my heart as I tried to months ago during my first conversation with Danny?split into separate questions and add another for fluency My heart was bruised enough the/from the last time I tried sharing my feelings; would it be the same this time? On that doorstep, I had an epiphany. Life will always be painful; every pain is a gain. There will always be bumps on the way, bullies, friends, and family. Every bump that I pass--"pass" is hardly the best word for your bump-hitting metaphor, plus this is just a shitty-sounding sentence anyway will make me smarter in avoiding the next bumps. With this mentality, I rang the doorbell and talked swiftly and elegantly with Danny’s mother. It was as though magic dust was sprinkled on my life--no; the bullying ceased and my life were one less hassle.--oh god no
                those are strictly quick grammatical/syntactical fixes that don't touch the subject matter which is pretty bland to begin with.

                negative encounter: you were picked on and name-called in high school
                your response: you went to the kid's parents
                how it affected you: the kid's parents made him stop

                engaaaaaging stuff i can see how that might separate you from the masses

                /2 AM post
                Last edited by gnr61; 10-26-2008, 12:00 AM.
                squirrel--it's whats for dinner.

                Comment

                • zhul4nder
                  FFR Player
                  • Jun 2006
                  • 231

                  #9
                  Re: comment on college essay please?

                  well then what kind of topic would suit the prompt?

                  [url=http://www.narutoflow.com/character-quiz/]Take the Naruto Character

                  for brawlers: 2836-1905-4019
                  I don't know how well it'll work, but give me a add , or pm me so i can add you.

                  Comment

                  • QED Stepfiles
                    FFR Player
                    • Jul 2008
                    • 130

                    #10
                    Re: comment on college essay please?

                    So, to me the essay seems to be a bit of a melodramatic story about dealing with a bully. This is probably fine given the prompt, but at the same time I don't feel that this essay is really telling the admissions board too much about your character. There should be more content after the fact and about how the experience changed you, and less about the actual encounter yourself. Colleges are not really interested in hearing how you overcame a bully, but rather how facing such a challenge had a major impact on your life. Indeed, I'm sure they'll get plenty of essays dealing with cliche topics like bullies, and without any added personality the essay will probably receive a "Oh, another one of these?" reaction from them. I'm sure your English teachers in high school have told you to avoid plot summary in your essays... I'm pretty much telling you the same thing here.

                    I think you tried to inject some of this "personality/significance" into your final paragraph, but it came across as forced (and I think it was). Rather than spending so much time making your encounter with this bully seem so fluffy and dramatic, spend at LEAST half the essay talking about how this event changed you, and perhaps listing specifics on how your outlook on life was affected for the future. Perhaps you could relate a story of another event after this one, where your experiences during this event helped influence your actions in this other event. This is the kind of stuff colleges like to see. They don't want to see a generic (albeit dramatic) bullying essay - as I said, in reality, too many people can write this type of essay that it really doesn't have a "personal" ring to it, which sort of defeats the purpose of writing a "personal" essay.

                    Otherwise, the language of the essay is just way too flowery (and thus awkward) given the subject matter - however, you really should first fix some of the ideas before even going into stylistic considerations. If you want to make this essay stand out you'll have to do something different with this topic, since it really is just such a trite topic. Of course, if you have otherwise good academic records, in the end the essay doesn't have too much weight relative to other things in your application, so you'd probably be safe just leaving it as is (well, correcting it a bit for style and fluidity but leaving the ideas as is).

                    It's just my opinion, but I went through the college admissions process just two years ago, and I still remember how I chose to write my essays in a way that best represented myself.




                    Comment

                    • zhul4nder
                      FFR Player
                      • Jun 2006
                      • 231

                      #11
                      Re: comment on college essay please?

                      the essay has been changed! please comment!
                      Last edited by zhul4nder; 11-29-2008, 02:19 AM. Reason: because i wanted to again?

                      [url=http://www.narutoflow.com/character-quiz/]Take the Naruto Character

                      for brawlers: 2836-1905-4019
                      I don't know how well it'll work, but give me a add , or pm me so i can add you.

                      Comment

                      • zhul4nder
                        FFR Player
                        • Jun 2006
                        • 231

                        #12
                        Re: comment on college essay please?

                        no one seemed to have done anything...so i'll bump it?

                        [url=http://www.narutoflow.com/character-quiz/]Take the Naruto Character

                        for brawlers: 2836-1905-4019
                        I don't know how well it'll work, but give me a add , or pm me so i can add you.

                        Comment

                        • Commandersa1
                          FFR Player
                          • Mar 2006
                          • 2344

                          #13
                          Re: comment on college essay please?

                          "Didn't" becomes "did not."
                          "Don't" becomes "do not."

                          "There are News flashes everyday about the war on terrorism, the war on sex slaves, and pretty much wars on any social injustices"

                          News stations flash stories every day about the war on terrorism, the war, or any other social injustice in the world.

                          That sentence is probably bad too, but I'm tired. :/

                          Comment

                          • super kid
                            FFR Player
                            • Nov 2006
                            • 1359

                            #14
                            Re: comment on college essay please?

                            Try to avoid any type of contractions.
                            Originally posted by KgZ
                            next time instead of trying to talk to the girl acting like a sketchball just whip your dick and stick it in her mouth; dont even say anything

                            Comment

                            Working...