Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • footbull3196
    Banned
    • Oct 2007
    • 514

    #1

    Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

    When you play quarterback, unless you have Peyton Manning-like accuracy, you need another threat. Therefore, running is the easiest way to catch people off guard. Whether it's pure quickness or the ability to make tacklers miss, these quarterbacks can do it with both their arm and their legs. Here are my top 10 mobile quarterbacks of all time:

    10. Brett Favre (don't let his lack of statistics fool you, he is one of the greatest improvisers ever, and can scramble away from pressure, and throw while being tackled, although he throws many interceptions)
    9. Mark Brunell (better in his younger days, but more of a threat to throw than run, although he could do both)
    8. Doug Flutie (although only selected for the Pro Bowl once, and his lack of size, he's fast, and can unleash a long throw at any time)
    7. Bobby Douglass (never seen him play, but he did hold the record for most rushing yards by a quarterback until Michael Vick broke it)
    6. Michael Vick (would be higher if wasn't for his arrest and lack of ability to throw the ball consistently)
    5. John Elway (big, strong, and could run for long gains, also, did you see his amazing 8-yard run in Super Bowl 32? He is willing to take a hit (remember, mobility isn't always quickness, but ability to evade tacklers and scramble for necessary first downs)
    4. Steve McNair (just by looking at him, you know he's tough, and he's fast too, and he has a strong arm)
    3. Kordell Stewart (by far the most underrated quarterback on the list, he holds the NFL Record for longest run by a quarterback, an 80-yard TD run. He just didn't last long because of one bad performance in the 2001 AFC Championship Game against the Patriots, which he threw 2 interceptions in the last 5 minutes to ruin a comeback opportunity for the Steelers)
    2. Randall Cunningham (he has pure elusiveness, he can throw, run, and evade tacklers, watch him if you don't believe me)
    1. Steve Young (obvious choice for first place, if you've seen this guy play, you know what im talking about. He can do everything, and if you've seen his 60-yard TD run against Minnesota in the 1988 Playoffs, that pretty much defines him right there)

    Although you may not agree about the placement of a player or lack of placement of a player on this list (and please tell me if you do), you have to agree about this: these quarterbacks are definitely some of the best mobile quarterbacks to ever play the position, and define the term "mobile".

    I spent a long time making this (about 20 minutes) and I'm proud of it.
    Last edited by footbull3196; 08-23-2008, 05:03 PM.
  • footbull3196
    Banned
    • Oct 2007
    • 514

    #2
    Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

    Seriously, i spent time on this, and I'm not wanting a thread bump, I just dont want this thread to die after a few minutes.

    And dont complain about double posting, b/c this technically isn't double posting. It's me making a thread and then posting a reply. Under replies, there is 1 reply, so thats technically only 1 true post, with a description of the thread.

    Comment

    • foilman8805
      smoke wheat hail satin
      FFR Simfile Author
      • Sep 2006
      • 5704

      #3
      Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

      Originally posted by footbull3196
      Seriously, i spent time on this, and I'm not wanting a thread bump, I just dont want this thread to die after a few minutes.

      And dont complain about double posting, b/c this technically isn't double posting. It's me making a thread and then posting a reply. Under replies, there is 1 reply, so thats technically only 1 true post, with a description of the thread.
      No, this is double posting. Don't try to bend the rules with 'technicalities' to make it seem like you're not breaking them.

      This isn't exactly the kind of thread that generates a whole lot of discussion other than people saying that they disagree or agree with your opinion. Perhaps you want to work on the quality of your threads, and post things that make people want to engage in conversation.

      If this thread was interesting to someone, they would post in it. Just be patient.

      And I don't care how much you hate me and think I'm retarded - I'm just telling you the truth.

      Another thing to consider is the aesthetics of your post. It is literally a big, fat block of text. Try to make it more appealing for people to look at and read.
      Last edited by foilman8805; 08-18-2008, 10:18 PM.

      Comment

      • ruferddude
        FFR Veteran
        • Oct 2004
        • 165

        #4
        Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

        Do you have the NFL Network? Because they have a show called "Top 10". They make a list of the top ten anything. Top ten single season performances, Superbowl performances, best players not in the hall of fame etc. They actually had one about the top 10 mobile quarterbacks. Their list was :
        10 - Donovan McNabb
        9 - Doug Flutie
        8 - Jim Zorn
        7 - Dan Marino
        6 - Roger Staubach
        5 - Bobby Douglass
        4 - Michael Vick
        3 - Randall Cunningham
        2 - Steve Young
        1 - Fran Tarkenton
        You can go to www.nfl.com -> videos -> NFL network -> NFL top 10. You have to change the year from 2008 to 2007 to see their older episodes. They have a bunch more lists that seem interesting.
        Last edited by ruferddude; 08-19-2008, 02:17 PM.
        Originally posted by darkshark
        Speedmods are for losers.
        Originally posted by Tasselfoot
        all the cool kids use 1x.

        Comment

        • footbull3196
          Banned
          • Oct 2007
          • 514

          #5
          Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

          Originally posted by foilman8805

          And I don't care how much you hate me and think I'm retarded - I'm just telling you the truth.
          I don't hate you, I just think that maybe you're too critical of me... just my opinion.

          And for the other person who said asked if I have NFL Network, I actually watch that Top 10 show all the time, and I think my favorite was the Top 10 Team Turnarounds.

          I missed this show however, which I think would have been really good as well, so I decided to make my own list, and I think it's pretty good... once again, just my opinion, so... if you think that I left someone off, just tell me.

          Comment

          • ruferddude
            FFR Veteran
            • Oct 2004
            • 165

            #6
            Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

            The only thing I can think of that is really wrong with your list is the lack of Fran Tarkenton anywhere on it. He was the original "scrambler" and he also broke every passing record for his time (others broke his records after him). He also led the Vikings to three Superbowls (even though they lost all of them (against the Dolphins, Steelers, and Raiders)). Also historic players need more respect. People always for get about people that played way back when, but those are the players that I love the most.
            Last edited by ruferddude; 08-23-2008, 08:24 AM.
            Originally posted by darkshark
            Speedmods are for losers.
            Originally posted by Tasselfoot
            all the cool kids use 1x.

            Comment

            • igotrhythm
              Fractals!
              • Sep 2004
              • 6535

              #7
              Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

              No doubt Favre is up there with the greatest improvisers (if you saw the chest pass he made while being taken down in the 1997 NFC title game vs. the Panthers, you know), but he was never much for gaining yards with his feet, which is probably one reason for the relatively low ranking. However, he has his good passing days, too; need I mention the game he had on the Monday night after his dad died? Plus, he also holds the Packer team record of 20 consecutive completions.

              I'd say put Vick above Favre, if not a couple spots higher: I don't think you should let events off the field get in the way of ranking their performance while on the gridiron.
              Originally posted by thesunfan
              I literally spent 10 minutes in the library looking for the TWG forum on Smogon and couldn't find it what the fuck is this witchcraft IGR

              Comment

              • lumphoboextreme
                FFR Veteran
                • Jan 2005
                • 8592

                #8
                Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

                even if vick got arrested, when he did lead the offense... he could make a play on his feet without any blocking or anyone else helping. i dont think many other QB's could do that

                Comment

                • tupacodaman
                  FFR Player
                  • Sep 2006
                  • 635

                  #9
                  Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

                  I'd say vick is either 2 or 3rd, the fact that he got 1000 rushing yards in this modern age where players are huge AND fast, AND also the fact that every single defense feared vick running more than him passing so they made sure to try to shut him down, makes him worthy of number 2, even if he does kill bulldogs and does stupid/wrong/illegal things like that

                  Comment

                  • Tps222
                    FFR Player
                    • Nov 2004
                    • 6168

                    #10
                    Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

                    Anyone remember the first time the Packers ever lost a home game in the playoffs?

                    Remember who beat them?

                    Vick.

                    Comment

                    • footbull3196
                      Banned
                      • Oct 2007
                      • 514

                      #11
                      Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

                      Well, if I move Vick up to, let's say, #6, then who's gonna replace him at 10?

                      Comment

                      • ruferddude
                        FFR Veteran
                        • Oct 2004
                        • 165

                        #12
                        Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

                        I like how everyone is just talking about Vick. This thread needs more historical players. Fran Tarkenton, Roger Staubach (They didn't call him "Roger the Dodger" for nothing), Bobby Douglass were all great scramblers and runners but because we can't watch them today they are forgetten. It's a shame...
                        Originally posted by darkshark
                        Speedmods are for losers.
                        Originally posted by Tasselfoot
                        all the cool kids use 1x.

                        Comment

                        • Mookage
                          FFR Player
                          • Mar 2007
                          • 227

                          #13
                          Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

                          Originally posted by footbull3196
                          Well, if I move Vick up to, let's say, #6, then who's gonna replace him at 10?
                          Uhh if Vick gets moved up to 6 then the individuals who were #6-#9 get bumped back a spot.

                          Farve becomes 10
                          Brunell becomes 9 etc.

                          Comment

                          • Beethovens mask
                            FFR Veteran
                            • Dec 2007
                            • 1569

                            #14
                            Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

                            This is a great thread. Keep up the good work. Also foilman, don't be so harsh.

                            I think Vick is good, and deserves a few more spots up, but I also think he is way too overrated.

                            Although in Madden you basically always win against friends with him.
                            Originally posted by fastfingers65
                            beethoven youre terrible at speaking like a moron

                            Comment

                            • igotrhythm
                              Fractals!
                              • Sep 2004
                              • 6535

                              #15
                              Re: Top 10 Mobile Quarterbacks of All Time

                              I think he was talking about in terms of running yards.

                              Rufer has a point, though: QBs of old seem to have been overlooked to some extent in your Top 10. Next time, maybe do a little research and see what recognized experts have to say on the topic? :/
                              Originally posted by thesunfan
                              I literally spent 10 minutes in the library looking for the TWG forum on Smogon and couldn't find it what the fuck is this witchcraft IGR

                              Comment

                              Working...