The Treachery of Exploration

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • All_That_Chaz
    Supreme Dictator For Life
    • Apr 2004
    • 5874

    #1

    The Treachery of Exploration

    Another poem by me. In all honesty, it's pretty bad. This is a first draft of an idea I have that revolves around the painting "The Treachery of Images" by Rene Magritte. It's made in 14 couplets and based in iambic pentameter, which I play around with for effect.


    The Treachery of Exploration

    A mother takes a day off work to help
    The woeful teacher whose poor lot was dealt.
    Her daughter’s class was going on a trip.
    Excitement spewed from rapid-moving lips.
    The grand production is about to start –
    Enter the famed Museum of Modern Art.

    Each child, first amazed, now seemed jaded, bored.
    This too confusing art was soon abhorred.
    The mother felt a tug and gandered down
    “What does that say?” asked a girl with a frown.
    The caption read, “Ceci n’est pas une pipe.” –
    The Treachery of Images – Magritte.
    She knew her French but failed to understand
    The meaning as much as the questioner had.

    At home she ponders what she saw that day.
    How could Magritte so boldly dare to say
    This pipe is not a pipe? If it is not,
    What word or image was the one he sought?
    Of X-less treasure maps of language, of
    The deaf and blind one feeling ‘round for love.
    Some semblance of familiarity –
    It all escapes her in her sanctity.
    Alone, her frozen wasteland spans for miles.
    The rogues answer eludes her all the while.
    Tearing up earth, she searches for her treatise
    Of writing pen-scratch, screaming gibberish.
    You will not find the answer underground;
    The meaning isn’t looked for – it is found.
    Last edited by All_That_Chaz; 04-23-2007, 08:58 AM.
    Back to "Back to Earth"
    Originally posted by FoJaR
    dammit chaz
    Originally posted by FoJaR
    god dammit chaz
    Originally posted by MalReynolds
    I bet when you live in a glass house, the temptation to throw stones is magnified strictly because you're not supposed to.
  • ShastaTwist
    FFR Veteran
    • Sep 2004
    • 599

    #2
    Re: The Treachery of Exploration

    It is a picture of a pipe. :]

    Wee.

    I think you had a good idea here, but I don't think it was presented as well as it could have been. :/

    Comment

    • All_That_Chaz
      Supreme Dictator For Life
      • Apr 2004
      • 5874

      #3
      Re: The Treachery of Exploration

      I agree. As a reader, what do you think was presented poorly?

      Thanks for reading!
      Back to "Back to Earth"
      Originally posted by FoJaR
      dammit chaz
      Originally posted by FoJaR
      god dammit chaz
      Originally posted by MalReynolds
      I bet when you live in a glass house, the temptation to throw stones is magnified strictly because you're not supposed to.

      Comment

      • ShastaTwist
        FFR Veteran
        • Sep 2004
        • 599

        #4
        Re: The Treachery of Exploration

        I'm not exactly sure, I think the topic is difficult under any circumstance, so it's probably hard to present it anyway.

        Comment

        • All_That_Chaz
          Supreme Dictator For Life
          • Apr 2004
          • 5874

          #5
          Re: The Treachery of Exploration

          Update on this poem. This is my fifth and final draft of this poem. It went through a lot of changes. I dropped the third person perspective because it was just weird. In my 2nd and 3rd drafts, I had also completely dropped the narrative aspect of the poem, but it came off as sounding like a preachy lesson in art history, so in my 4th and 5th drafts I worked it back in. This is the final product. I'm not saying it can't be improved because there's definitely places that could be, but this is what I'm turning in for my poetry class. Again, this poem is about The Treachery of Images by Magritte, I'll include a snapshot of the picture below the poem if you've never heard of it. Thanks for reading!



          The Treachery of Exploration


          The caption read, “Ceci n’est pas une pipe.” –
          The Treachery of Images – Magritte.
          I know my French, it doesn’t help me glean
          The meaning the clever painter once had seen.

          Confused, I ponder what the painting portrays.
          How could Magritte so boldly dare to say
          This pipe is not a pipe? If it is not,
          What word or image was the one he sought?

          These words assigned meaning in heresy –
          They fit together in conspiracy.
          And images as well, as if from air
          Appear in our minds, we expect them there.

          Two instruments of thought, I begin to see –
          Their meanings are unique, they belong to me.
          For who am I to say this pipe is a pipe?
          And why do I trust my words and my sight?

          Perhaps this isn’t about pipes at all.
          Along with my thoughts, I begin to fall.
          The air tears at my senses, like the skin
          Of an onion is torn, revealing its sin.

          At last feeling pressure on my soles
          Again my fleeting vision glances at old
          X-less treasure maps of language above.
          Now deaf and blind I feel around for love.

          For some semblance of familiarity –
          It all escapes me in my sanctity.
          From my gemstone palace I make the laws
          And my word is infallible because

          In my own world I am holy king.
          But what false joy can isolation bring?
          My orders on high do not reach an ear
          And my almighty visage does not instill fear!

          Alone, my frozen wasteland spans for miles.
          The rogue answer eludes me all the while.
          Without any minions to do my bidding,
          I must look myself, I resort to digging.

          Tearing up the earth, I search for my treatise
          Of written pen-scratch and screamed gibberish.
          I will not see the answer underground;
          The meaning isn’t looked for – it is found.

          Back to "Back to Earth"
          Originally posted by FoJaR
          dammit chaz
          Originally posted by FoJaR
          god dammit chaz
          Originally posted by MalReynolds
          I bet when you live in a glass house, the temptation to throw stones is magnified strictly because you're not supposed to.

          Comment

          • ShastaTwist
            FFR Veteran
            • Sep 2004
            • 599

            #6
            Re: The Treachery of Exploration

            Beginning at the sixth stanza, the poem kind of wanders away from the main point of the poem. It might just be me, because I'm tired, but it didn't make that much sense.

            Comment

            • Wintergreen
              gamehussy
              • Dec 2006
              • 64

              #7
              Re: The Treachery of Exploration

              One question: What sin is hidden at the center of an onion @.@?
              Life is short. Eat dessert first! - Jacques Torres

              Comment

              • ShastaTwist
                FFR Veteran
                • Sep 2004
                • 599

                #8
                Re: The Treachery of Exploration

                The heart. :l

                AKA No idea.

                Comment

                • All_That_Chaz
                  Supreme Dictator For Life
                  • Apr 2004
                  • 5874

                  #9
                  Re: The Treachery of Exploration

                  The sin of the onion. Ok it's really kind of obscure so I'll explain it to you. I didn't come up with this theory entirely on my own, there's a variation of this at the end of Peer Gynt by Henrik Isben.

                  The onion first and foremost is a symbol for the speaker. The proverbial fall from blissfully ignorant grace tears at the speakers senses because he's falling into a nihilistic world of despair where words and images mean nothing to everyone but him. The removal of the senses from the speaker is related to the removal of the skin from the onion. However, when you peel an onion, you see that underneath the skin is just another layer. You can keep peeling away at the onion and will never reach a center. There is no center or overpowering meaning to the onion just as there is no center or overpowering meaning in man and the meanings behind man's words and images. This nihilistic image sets the stage for the abstract narrative to follow before the concluding existentialist remark of "The meaning isn't looked for - it is found." You have to take an onion (and man, life, words, and images) for what they are. No amount of peeling (or digging in a nihilistic world) will yield any central meaning behind anything. The meaning is simply known to yourself. The meaning of life is to live happily, not to over-analyze until you are left with a pile of rotting peels.

                  That is the sin of the onion. It's really complex and probably doesn't make much sense anyway, but I hope you get what I'm trying to get at.

                  EDIT: oh and in response to shasta's initial comment. this probably could go through a few more drafts. my prof was extremely unhelpful with this poem. she wanted me to abandon it, but i love the idea too much. easing the reader into the abstract was either the most of among the most difficult things to do in this poem, and i don't think i've quite accomplished that yet. maybe some time in the future i'll return to this poem. thanks for reading!
                  Last edited by All_That_Chaz; 06-6-2007, 11:08 PM.
                  Back to "Back to Earth"
                  Originally posted by FoJaR
                  dammit chaz
                  Originally posted by FoJaR
                  god dammit chaz
                  Originally posted by MalReynolds
                  I bet when you live in a glass house, the temptation to throw stones is magnified strictly because you're not supposed to.

                  Comment

                  • AeroFoxMaou
                    FFR Player
                    • May 2007
                    • 2

                    #10
                    Re: The Treachery of Exploration

                    Wow that is really nice. I never would have guessed the symbolism.
                    I am fine at writing my own poems... but when it comes to others.... it kills me
                    Glad that you explained it.
                    Nicely done, Chaz!!!

                    Taking it faster and harder than ever before!!

                    Comment

                    Working...