Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Desert_Eagle
    FFR Player
    • Dec 2003
    • 98

    #1

    Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

    *I'm not sure if this is the appropriate place to put this thread in this section.

    Earlier this year, in February, our school took some mandatory tests and essays for the district and state, and now we received our scores. My teacher had read and graded my essay according to standards (1 being crappy; 2, passable; 3, good; 4, touching perfection). The prompt was, "Write a composition about a shocking moment that happened in your life." My topic I chose happened to be when Aeris died in Final Fantasy VII. Now, mind you, these teachers probably haven't played video games before. And I only had an hour or so to make an essay (after the multiple choice section). The judges had given me a 3, 2, and 3. My teacher didn't know if to grade it a 3 or a 4 because she never read a topic on video games. Give your opinion of it, and add any suggestions. Also note, the essay was aimed at a broader audience, people who did and didn't play FFVII, so most of this stuff you probably know already.

    Tapping into knowledge of a world unknown, I had the urge to find her, the only person able to save the world from total annihaliation. Why does she run away? I caught up to her and found a desolate, empty village, her homeland. Walking down the steps toward an ethereal place, I saw her kneeling, praying. I said to myself, “Aeris,” only to see a man swoop down in one of the finest, exciting, and most shocking moments in not only my history, but to the entire video gaming world.
    Final Fantasy VII, as it was called, was a mega-blockbuster hit across the world, but why? Why is it so great? The man swooping down, Sephiroth, stabs Aeris through the chest with a six-foot long blade, with Cloud, the main character, standing helpless. Calling Sephiroth a “man” is pretty modest, especially when he went through genetic and radioactive mutations before his birth. And Aeris is a last surviving member of her race, the ancients, the only one able to counter Sephiroth’s evil intentions. That explains the vacancy of her hometown. But all of this doesn’t explain how this event is so significant. Death occurs often: in plays, novels, and movies. So how does the game reach the pinnacle of success? Go ask the obsessive fans.
    A classic from 1997, the Playstation hit from SquareSoft (now SquareEnix, after a merger) had a multimillion dollar budget and an unprecedented three CDs of video game. That’s 60+ hours of playing time! With ground-breaking graphics, musical score, and storyline, the game was set to become a success. Without the public raving about the said moment, though, the game would have diminished of its fame. I read stories and letters in today’s gaming magazines that still have fans trying to find to revive or save Aeris from death. After over eight years, crazed people still ask the inevitable question. One parent sent a letter of their child playing FFVII. She said her son burst into tears when meeting this part of the game. Dying in the first CD of the game doesn’t help the cause against evil, but it sure does rack up lots of profit.
    “Cloud, I know how you feel.” My childhood friend comforts me on the back. “She has gone to a better place.” I realize now I must complete my task, my fate. I must avenge Aeris’s death; I see a hope, and a will to push on to save the Planet. Two more CDs to go, an adventure awaits me.

    I'm trying to make a revised copy of it already so it would be much more fluid and make more sense for my teacher. I'll post it up later when I get it done.
    Last edited by Desert_Eagle; 03-27-2006, 09:12 PM.

    -------
    http://gh.ffshrine.org?r=36515
    -MOST AWESOME SITE EVAR-
    -video game and anime soundtracks-
    *********help me by going here!*********
  • Squeek
    let it snow~
    • Jan 2004
    • 14444

    #2
    Re: Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

    I think you would have received higher scores if you continued to post from a first-person point of view instead of doing a sales pitch for a video game.

    Someone wrote a paper on Half Life's storyline from Gordon's point of view and got an A. Google it and see if you find it.

    Also, moved to Literature.

    ~Squeek

    Comment

    • Desert_Eagle
      FFR Player
      • Dec 2003
      • 98

      #3
      Re: Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

      That would've been a great idea, but some people look at the prompt at different ways. It was aimed at my life, not at Cloud's life, so I might be risking getting an excellent "4" or a bad "0" for not following the prompt.

      ---Desert_Eagle

      -------
      http://gh.ffshrine.org?r=36515
      -MOST AWESOME SITE EVAR-
      -video game and anime soundtracks-
      *********help me by going here!*********

      Comment

      • jewpinthethird
        (The Fat's Sabobah)
        FFR Music Producer
        • Nov 2002
        • 11711

        #4
        Re: Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

        No offense, but you chose a bad topic. You have to understand who your audience is. In this case, they were teachers who had not played FFVII, let alone video games. A story about a video game is not something that most teachers are looking for.

        However, if you are going to try something different you have to go balls out, no holding back. Personally, it would have been better if you had stuck with Cloud's point of view up until the end when you reveal that you were, in fact, playing a video game. You could always make the argument that FFVII is a Role Playing Game where you actually become the character and feel what the character feels.

        Comment

        • Omeganitros
          auauauau
          • Jun 2003
          • 8897

          #5
          Re: Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

          >=O

          Now I can't mock him because of you guys.

          Comment

          • Squeek
            let it snow~
            • Jan 2004
            • 14444

            #6
            Re: Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

            Originally posted by jewpinthethird
            However, if you are going to try something different you have to go balls out, no holding back. Personally, it would have been better if you had stuck with Cloud's point of view up until the end when you reveal that you were, in fact, playing a video game. You could always make the argument that FFVII is a Role Playing Game where you actually become the character and feel what the character feels.
            "...the horrifying battle with my archrival was over.

            I laid the controller on the table and went to go get dinner."

            ~Squeek

            Comment

            • SqNtz_xoombotvx
              FFR Player
              • Jan 2006
              • 220

              #7
              Re: Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

              roflz way to go on that essay. Here's how to fix it up: introduce stuff like the characters, plot, and all that. You can't expect the audience to know about FF7 before reading this. You could certainly make it a serious essay if the reader knows what you're talking about. And work on putting a thesis in there. Maybe even another topic would help since it's hard to write an academic essay on one broad topic.

              Comment

              • esupin
                FFR Player
                • Nov 2003
                • 1756

                #8
                Re: Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

                You should never ask questions in an essay like this...
                Final Fantasy VII, as it was called, was a mega-blockbuster hit across the world, but why? Why is it so great?
                ..and then answer your own question. Just state why(because it was cool, I dunno).

                http://www.youtube.com/esupin

                Comment

                • Desert_Eagle
                  FFR Player
                  • Dec 2003
                  • 98

                  #9
                  Re: Critique An 8th Grader's Essay!

                  I wanted to see how doing such a topic (video games) would do with the judges and see how it would fare with other story ideas. Our Pre-AP teacher encouraged taking some risks when writing these essays, so FFVII came up to my mind first. Plus, I had just finished the game by then, so I had a solid topic to write about. Not necessarily the best, but I passed it; that's what counts there, and that's why I need suggestions.

                  -------
                  http://gh.ffshrine.org?r=36515
                  -MOST AWESOME SITE EVAR-
                  -video game and anime soundtracks-
                  *********help me by going here!*********

                  Comment

                  Working...