Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

**Wafles** · 07-6-2013, 05:11 PM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

The Big To-Do List
Now that we're at 50+ files its time to get serious and start putting everything together for release. This is going to be my big list of things that remain to be done. I will update this frequently (hopefully daily) until the release happens.

Graphics
Files Needing Graphics Yet: 0

Preview Music Set
Files Needing Preview Music Set: 0

Difficulties Set
Files Needing Final Difficulty Determined: 0

Fix Fluctuating BPMs
Files Verified Fixed: 51
There are some files that could not be fixed.

Raw NPS:

Reviews:

Reviews are up to date as of August 13th

Wafles' file reviews:

Skwid's file reviews:

Originally posted by Skwid1

(MrTea) Mindless Self Indulgence - Bitches (�-ZIQ Remix)
Accepted
Not a huge fan of the song choice, but the file is very solid. It's accurate and fun to play. I see no major issues with it other than the file being slightly offsync even after the changes, but that's an easy fix.

(XelNya) Konori (Ft. Megurine Luka) - Wings of Demise
Conditional
The opening JS pattern is undercharted. The jumps you've placed aren't consistent with the instrument you seem to be charting. This same pattern occurs multiple times throughout the song and there are instances where you've charted the same part slightly differently.
The drum pattern at around 82.5 seconds is slightly mischarted and I think there are other instances of the same pattern throughout the song.
Even in its current state though, I really enjoy playing this chart and I like your minijack placement a lot. Amazing song choice as well. Sync is fine.

(XelNya) HujuniseikouyuuP (Ft. Hatsune Miku) - With a Dance Number
Accepted
Incredibly fun file. No sync issues. No major issues with how it's charted at all.

Originally posted by Skwid1

(ORMIX) Imagine Dragons - Radioactive
Accepted
Pretty fun, standard dump file. It's onsync and I have no major issues with how it's charted. The beginning is kind of boring and lasts a bit long for my taste, but that's an issue with the song and not the chart.

Originally posted by Skwid1

(MrTea) Nvoise - Lazy Susan
Accepted
This is a pretty sick chart. Not the catchiest song in the world or anything imo, but the chart more than makes up for it. It's really damn fun.

(MrTea) Emotional Joystick - untitled gabber song
Rejected
I almost didn't even play this file because of the fact that there are a couple pretty good (and well known) charts for this song already.

While the weird swing shit in a lot of the streams in this song is almost certainly technically correct, this is a case where I'd argue you should chart the song incorrectly if it means that it will flow better and be more fun to play. I just don't see a reason that someone would pick this specific chart of this song over any of the others.

(MrTea) MrTea - Creative Flow
Rejected
The actual chart for this song is fine, but due to the length of the song and the song itself, I really can't imagine this having much replay value, tbh.

(James May) hally - Bgrusko Meow
Accepted
Amazing song choice and chart with lots of variety. There seems to be a note missing at beat 212 but that's the only criticism I can think of.

(James May) Parun - monocyclefromhell
Accepted
Pretty unique-sounding song. Chart is really fun and I like the difficulty progression.

(James May) Mowtendo - Nichismoke
Accepted
This might be my new favorite parody song/MAD chart. Awesome song and chart. Not much else to say.

(James May) Alias Conrad Coldwood - Pepper Steak
Rejected
I think the chart on this one is accurate and well done overall, but it's a bit too easy for my taste. That alone isn't really reason to reject something, but I don't even think this would be a really fun MA file or anything due to the song choice. It just feels really slow and repetitive and I can't see this having much replay value.

Originally posted by Skwid1

Been falling behind on reviewing shit. Like Wafles, I'm not going to do a re-review of XelNya's already accepted file, but it's nice to see a direct improvement to a file I was already pretty happy with playing.

(rCaliberGX) Rushjet1 - Exam Cram
Accepted
This chart is a lot more fun than the hsmp5 one IMO because of the cooler 32nd patterns and the less awkward jack sections. They're pretty similar otherwise, but this chart is different enough to justify having it around. I also think people will appreciate the fact that there are 2 difficulties on this.

(XelNya) Konori (Ft. Megurine Luka) - Wings of Demise
Conditional
I thought the previous iteration of this chart was pretty damn fun. Now it's even better (more minijacks <3), although I still feel like there are a couple of parts you could improve.
Why aren't there jumps at beats 10 and 10.5? It seems weird with how you chart the rest of this part. This part shows up multiple times throughout the song.
At beat 458.5, you charted an 8th jump when the jump should have been on the following 16th. It's wrong and inconsistent with how you charted the exact same part at the beginning.
Starting at beat 748, you chart this whole section in a completely different way from how you charted it earlier in the song, even though it sounds the same (jumps only on snare hits).
The drum part during the long left freeze starting at beat 240 is charted incorrectly. This same part shows up a couple more times.
If these things are addressed, I'd definitely accept this file. There aren't many problems with it, but I think the few that are present really break the flow of the file for me because they're so blatant.

(MrTea) Venetian Snares - Marty's Tardis
Accepted
Fantastic chart. Song is okay. Not much else to say.

(MrTea) Venetian Snares - Winnipeg As Mandatory Scat Feed
Accepted
Jesus this song feels like it goes on forever. The chart is great, filled with fun patterns and a good amount of variety.

(MrTea) Die Antwoord - DIZ IS WHY IM HOT (MrTea Remix)
Rejected
Eeehhhhhh. Unlike the files that I've accepted, this chart isn't fun enough to make up for the song not being very appealing to me.
I'm just barely in "accept" range with a lot of the files you've submitted, MrTea. I feel like a lot of your song choices make for great charts, but they just aren't catchy enough or don't vary enough in sound to make me want to play it again after the first time through.
It could definitely just be me though. Wafles could convince me otherwise.

Originally posted by Skwid1

(rCaliberGX) cornandbeans - {The Traveller}
Accepted
This file reminded me that I should probably check Newgrounds for some shit to step lmao. Pretty standard JS file. Nice song choice and good patterns throughout the whole file.

(rCaliberGX) ST2B Recording - Superluminal
Accepted
I expect to 1 great this about 100 times because I can't roll to save my life, but this is another hella fun JS file, with a good amount of variety.
Lots of replay value in both of these, imo.

(mrTea) Fexomat - Schlimme Dinge
Accepted
Welp...I can't really complain about the music this time, because it's pretty decent. On top of that, this file is amazingly fun, with a shitton of interesting and well thought-out patterns that make this file memorable.

(bombastik) Utsu-P feat. Hatsune Miku - MiKUSABBATH
Rejected
Yeah you definitely need to fix the sync on this, but even then, it's an overall easy chart with huge difficulty spikes that also feels undercharted.
There are just a lot of single notes where I think the chart should be more dense, like during the entire intro section (starting at beat 86).
Although honestly, I think even if it's charted a little more densely, it'll still be a mostly easy file with a few spikes of real difficulty, in the form of bursts and one relatively small JS, which makes for a pretty boring experience overall for people that can do the hard parts. I'd definitely re-evaluate it if you were to make changes, but I think it'd almost have to be a JS dump chart to really work.
The song is fucking awesome though.

(.Rarity) Foozogz - Applejack Bucks 400 Apple Trees
Conditional
I don't really have much input on this one besides what Wafles already pointed out, and I assume that'll get worked out. It's an otherwise really fun, solid, short file.

**Jonlovesddr** · 07-6-2013, 06:15 PM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

i''ll throw you a file when i make one

**Buta-san** · 07-6-2013, 10:56 PM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

yoso

**Choofers** · 07-7-2013, 02:02 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

FANTASTIC IDEAcaps

**i love you** · 07-7-2013, 02:18 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

YOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

dat name

**Wafles** · 07-8-2013, 02:46 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

Also if people are interested I may release a mini teaser pack with about 10 files to give a little taste of what we're doing here. If I do this it'll be posted in this thread in a week or so.

#yolo #420bonghitz4jesus yo

**V-Ormix** · 07-8-2013, 02:52 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

I know what to step for this :P

**Wafles** · 07-10-2013, 01:00 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

First wave of file reviews! I want to try and post file reviews as often as possible so that we can give feedback to the step artists who spent a lot of time on the files that got sent in. I will also try and nudge the other judges into posting timely reviews as well.

My reviewing process basically is as follows: I blind sightread it in stepmania, then open it in ddreamstudio to check the sync and accuracy. I figure this lets me determine how fun a file is and then if I missed any inaccuracies I can find them in ddream and point them out if they need revision.

Anyway, without further ado:

(MrTea) Mindless Self Indulgence - Bitches (�-ZIQ Remix)
Accepted after the fixes
The fixes improved the file immensely. The sync is pretty good now, and the inconsistencies are gone. Looks good now.

(XelNya) Konori (Ft. Megurine Luka) - Wings of Demise (UPDATED)
Conditional
Sync is perfect. File is very fun. Overall I really liked it. I love the minijack section in the file. Super fun.

At 12 seconds in you have stepped 16ths where there should be 12ths. This is the only real problem with the file and it didn't really bother me too much on my playtest, but I still feel this should be fixed.

EDIT: After skwid pointed out some inconsistencies I'm going to change my acceptance of this file to conditional. See skwids review coming soon for the exact issues that need attention.

(XelNya) HujuniseikouyuuP (Ft. Hatsune Miku) - With a Dance Number
Accepted
Once again the sync is perfect. Very fun file to me. Reasonable difficulty, not very stamina heavy. Good fun all around.

Just a reminder here, me accepting a file doesn't mean its in the pack, it means I approve it of being in the pack. If Ko7a and Skwid feel otherwise the file wont make it, but I think I'm pretty picky so I wouldn't worry too much.

**DefTeaMachine** · 07-10-2013, 11:32 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

made a couple more changes besides what you have pointed out but yeah sending in a fixed .sm for bitches

**Wafles** · 07-10-2013, 11:29 PM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

Edited my review to reflect your changes. Good job on the fixes, the file is much better now.

**DefTeaMachine** · 07-11-2013, 02:07 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

Gr9

**kommisar** · 07-11-2013, 02:14 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

so dakota is judging eh

**Wafles** · 07-11-2013, 02:27 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

Thats ko7a i assume, lul

I been naggin him to review the few submissions we got, he should get around to it soon

**Skwid1** · 07-11-2013, 04:36 AM

Re: Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

(MrTea) Mindless Self Indulgence - Bitches (�-ZIQ Remix)
Accepted
Not a huge fan of the song choice, but the file is very solid. It's accurate and fun to play. I see no major issues with it other than the file being slightly offsync even after the changes, but that's an easy fix.

(XelNya) Konori (Ft. Megurine Luka) - Wings of Demise
Conditional
The opening JS pattern is undercharted. The jumps you've placed aren't consistent with the instrument you seem to be charting. This same pattern occurs multiple times throughout the song and there are instances where you've charted the same part slightly differently.

The drum pattern at around 82.5 seconds is slightly mischarted and I think there are other instances of the same pattern throughout the song.

Even in its current state though, I really enjoy playing this chart and I like your minijack placement a lot. Amazing song choice as well. Sync is fine.

(XelNya) HujuniseikouyuuP (Ft. Hatsune Miku) - With a Dance Number
Accepted
Incredibly fun file. No sync issues. No major issues with how it's charted at all.

Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

Yolomania Vol 1 - New Difficult KB Pack [Submissions Open]

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment

Comment