Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu!

Re: Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu!

I stepped a song from that cd as well


I then later killed myself

Re: Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu!

Aww, you meanie

Re: Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu!

also, you shouldn't publicly release files that you send to packs

Re: Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu!

Yep, I know this. However, I see no reason why this would apply to files rejected from packs. I only released it after FFR4EVA_00 had posted his judgment which happened to reject the file from the pack. I later realised I didn't wait for your judgment before releasing it, but I had the impression a file would have to be accepted by both of you before making it in - thus the file being a no-go.

Sorry if I caused any inconvenience. As I said in another topic, I'm releasing these just for the chance that someone might even have fun playing the files - and of course there's the chance of getting feedback. MF tells me this was DL'd 10 times so you never know if one of those things might have happened.

Re: Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu!

The idea of rejecting a chart from a pack isn't to say "no your chart sucks" it's to say "Your chart doesn't meet the standards yet"

When you have a chart that gets rejected, if the judges weren't clear, ask for notes through a PM and if they have the time they'll more than likely sit down and jolt you a list of changes they'd like to see. If the pack judge won't do it try to find someone else who knows what they're doing to give you some tips and notes.

But pretty much if you want future charts into a pack, you probably should try to work a little more with the judges and not just release it like Kommi said.

Btw I played the chart and honestly, it did need a bit more work. :3 Seems slightly better than the one before it, which is good.

Re: Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu!

Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to say that the file is AWSUM and should be included, nor am I whining about it being rejected. I'm ready to admit the chart wasn't good enough and just move on to stepping another one in the future when I have some spare time and find a fun song.

I do get your point, though. The best way to improve would probably be just what you said: getting it down with somebody - what was good, what was bad. Then try and fix the bad. And I actually posted some questions regarding the reviews in the pack thread. But if I have no idea how to make it better, I'll just let it be. Unfortunately the reviews didn't tell me much

And I don't want to be a nuisance, demanding time-consuming analysis of the chart from the judges and wasting their time. I figure that if they wanna comment more in detail, they would do it.

So releasing it basically means I don't have the time/patience/motivation to go through it again.

Re: Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu!

Re: Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu!

lmfao