Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
I skimmed and missed that. I'm dumb. -_- thanks
I skimmed and missed that. I'm dumb. -_- thanks
-
Originally posted by thesunfanOriginally posted by choofOriginally posted by choofOriginally posted by Celirra -
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
udingusComment
-
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
Armor-Plated Armadillo (Spitfire with periods and underscores) - Wasn't a huge fan of the intro, but about 40 seconds into the file it gets really good and stay good until the end. Only gripe I have is with the mini-freeze solos. Stop Right There DJ_Ossa. Accept
Flight of the Buttery (McGrumbles) - Old school feel as fuck. Song owns, file feels dated but this will be a pleasant surprise to people who "grew up" on files like this, so to speak. Accept
Prismatic Butterfly (Alioth) - Feels like the BPM drifts ever so slightly, and I personally found the offset to be a bit late. I wouldn't say this file is repetitive, because there's enough that changes from section to section, it's just that these subtle changes aren't enough to make an interesting chart. Didn't enjoy this very much. You should definitely step that song you linked me on skype though! Reject
The Stains of Pizza (Condoct) - Really messy chart. A lot of sections were cool (dare I say... "bitchin"), but the solo near the end was super awkward and convoluted with all those minifreezes. Tone down that section, or minifreeze usage in general, and I can accept this. Also, maybe an easier chart because the song owns. Accepted with revisions
Working Together ( ????? ) - Synced really well, but I have a huge issue with the lack of pitch relevancy, causing the 16th sections to feel totally random. Some of the color notes don't feel right either. I did like that you used minifreezes to accent the lower notes, so layering didn't get too crazy. If you'd like, hit me up on skype or through private messages here so I can help you make this chart perfect. Accepted with revisions
Onett (SpoOkyMagician) - pls no plsComment
-
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
I'm so down for that hahaComment
-
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
stepppinnnnn
Also, obligatory 3 hours tour of the guile's theme side of utubes
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)Comment
-
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
just an observation, but perhaps you guys can be a little more constructive? reading through the reviews so far, it looks like most of them have been very helpful so far - having judged quite a few packs myself I understand that judging can be quite frustrating but I still think it'd be worth taking the extra few minutes to go over how to improve the file
Comment
-
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
For this particular file, the only thing I can really say is to step a different song. The song itself is very amateurish, and the file just is not fun. No layering (I'm not kidding, 0 jumps, 0 hands, 200+ holds) makes this a really uninteresting file. I can't accept this.just an observation, but perhaps you guys can be a little more constructive? reading through the reviews so far, it looks like most of them have been very helpful so far - having judged quite a few packs myself I understand that judging can be quite frustrating but I still think it'd be worth taking the extra few minutes to go over how to improve the fileComment
-
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
i didnt even realize sm supported variable bit rate mp3Comment
-
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
Did you not watch the video of the file? Here it is.just an observation, but perhaps you guys can be a little more constructive? reading through the reviews so far, it looks like most of them have been very helpful so far - having judged quite a few packs myself I understand that judging can be quite frustrating but I still think it'd be worth taking the extra few minutes to go over how to improve the file
Just watching it almost sent me back into retirement.Comment
-
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
fair enough that a simfile might be very far from the standards you're looking for, but I think what moches is getting at is to try to avoid putting someone down over it. a full response (like the one choof gave after being asked) can help new simfilers improve. and going even further, it'd be neat to see vets reach out to people like SpoOkyMagician and offer to go through the basics of how to make an enjoyable simfile in the context of the modern keyboard community.
so basically the opposite of what my influence was during the first pack
Comment
-
Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4!
I thought I provided good feedback on that file despite what others were saying.
I've always explained my reasons or basis on my judgement on files.
PM me if you find the secret.
Comment
Anyhow yea I'm definitely going to do that song...just been taking a bit of a break from SM until Saturday. You should collab with me on that song :O
Comment