Guitar 24 (Deamerai) [7/10]

PERMS OK
SYNC OK

11.079: Why this guitar note and not 13.745 for example (and many others). The volume is close enough to make it unclear why only the sliightly louder ones are layered.

32.579 & 33.912 & etc: Ughhh, while the approximation of these is understandable for the difficulty, it's also a clear example of "maybe this chart isn't the most suitable for this difficulty". These guitar notes hit a full 64th before, which at that low BPM is a non-negligible 42ms. Check 42.523 where it's also a 64th (not a 12th), and you didn't approximate it to the 16th.

For its difficulty, this chart provides some interesting rhythms and variety. The layering and sync aren't ideal and would most likely be much more suitable for a slightly more difficult chart that syncs the guitar properly and doesn't omit audible notes for the sake of "undercharting". That being said, it's not Too confusing as is and still has enough good elements to make it worth accepting.

Judge Score: 7.00 - Change Recommended

Guitar 24 (Deamerai) [6.5/10]
> Permission check good.
> Sync looks good (No changes necessary).
> No issues found within simfile properties.
> No issues found within submission folder contents.

- 0:05.412 is the long intro really necessary? We dont live in the past where 2 seconds of empty chart are required for each song. The notes just kind of come in randomly. There isn't really a change in the music or anything.

- 0:12.412 This is the start of a long list of missing notes. Nearly all of the 8th guitar notes are just missing. You chart 0:11.079 but then go on to ignore 0:16.412. Its just a bit random and inconsistent.

- 0:32.079 These jumps feel out of place and dont really seem to be following any pattern. Many sections exist that could or should have a jump but dont. I think it might be best to not have any jumps at all here. Having jumps, a skillset players of this level struggle with, at the peak difficulty of the chart certainly is a choice.

- 0:38.912 another missing note for the high pitched guitar.

- 0:42.523 This note stands out for being the only one manually synced to be more inline with the actual sounds. 0:43.245 being a good example of a note that is offsync from its sound.

- 1:03.079 This missing note stands out since its one of the few 8th guitar notes you actually chart

Consistency issues is a theme with this chart. Tons of 8th notes are just randomly omitted. I think that would be fine if it were more consistent, but at the same time, omitted 8ths in a chart with a few tricky 16th patterns is also a bit questionable. You have this A section of the song, which is scared to chart 8ths, and when it does, its a very rolly pattern, followed by the B section with 16ths and 8th minijacks. I think this chart just needs a bit more of a cohesive direction.

Judge Score: 6.50 - Rejected