Terra Liberty (Storn42) [8/10]
>Permission good (Blanket)
>Folder contents, metadata good
>Sync good

Playtest Impression, 1.0x Rate - Sure, check guitar steps

Start - ~5.807 - (subjective, can ignore) For consistency with the rest of the file you'll probably want to include the slid-up notes here (between 0.449 / 0.752, 1.963 / 2.372, 3.607 / 3.987, 5.305 / 5.593)
1:26.344 - .747, 1:32.787 - 1:33.190 - can get away with 16ths here - 24ths are a pretty clear misrhythm

No real complaints here, pretty solid stuff all around. Another banger.

Terra Liberty (Storn42) [8.5/10]

PERMS OK
SYNC OK

7.821: Maybe consider slightly abstract 32nds trills with these color accents? Would really help giving some energy to this section.

45.270-56.546: This layering of the hands is odd for two reasons: it's pretty sudden after the long easy intro and there are many other sections where there are simultaneous instruments on the 4ths/8ths, a quick example would be 1:27.150, or 1:56.143. Would either add layering here and there, or remove the hands in that section.

1:43.257: Really just preference here, but I would suggest changing this part to columns 2 and 3. Not only would it match the first trilly part, it would also use a different jump (3 23(12) 323 23(12)...). As is, the column one feels like it's slightly dragging from 1:41.646 all the way to the end of the section.

2:26.747: Maybe quads? Heavier reverb. Just an idea.

Pretty solid and consistent chart. Layering a bit odd, but really good execution overall, lovely done.

A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 1405 => 1407
AVG NPS changed: 9.57084 => 9.58447

@Tru

Start - ~5.807 - (subjective, can ignore) For consistency with the rest of the file you'll probably want to include the slid-up notes here (between 0.449 / 0.752, 1.963 / 2.372, 3.607 / 3.987, 5.305 / 5.593)
- I acknowledge these being oddly inconsistent and chose not to include notes there as it is barely audible, and with the sync would create some odd patterns. Additionally there is a nice 8th cymbal that lands in all of these places making it magically not inconsistent anymore. Notes like 0:12.653 are charted where there is no guitar.

1:26.344 - .747, 1:32.787 - 1:33.190 - can get away with 16ths here - 24ths are a pretty clear misrhythm
- This is quite hard, because the notes aren't quite 16ths either. I'll put in 20ths instead as that is significantly closer to the actual rhythm.

@OP

7.821: Maybe consider slightly abstract 32nds trills with these color accents? Would really help giving some energy to this section.
- I can understand why you would suggest this, but this isn't really that kind of file.

45.270-56.546: This layering of the hands is odd for two reasons: it's pretty sudden after the long easy intro and there are many other sections where there are simultaneous instruments on the 4ths/8ths, a quick example would be 1:27.150, or 1:56.143. Would either add layering here and there, or remove the hands in that section.
- The plan was actually to have hands at 1:49.700 however I really wanted to have cool patterning to match the guitar and hands made it difficult to have that patterning really shine like it currently does. It didn't meaningfully increase the difficulty so i decided a lighter section was better. 1:27.150 also isn't really the same type of sound and is already being represented by the jumps. IT is a bit of a jump in difficulty but thats somewhat the point.

1:43.257: Really just preference here, but I would suggest changing this part to columns 2 and 3. Not only would it match the first trilly part, it would also use a different jump (3 23(12) 323 23(12)...). As is, the column one feels like it's slightly dragging from 1:41.646 all the way to the end of the section.
- you DARE ask me to remove 14 from my chart?!?! yea actually thats a pretty good point i'll move some notes around.

2:26.747: Maybe quads? Heavier reverb. Just an idea.
- sure that sounds like a good idea