Babylon :: FFR Batch Submission
Feb/March 2021
PublicEvents
Rejected
Simfile Folder Name
Babylon (WirryWoo)
Note Count
978
Chart Length
2:01
Average NPS
8.6016
Estimated Difficulty
64.3
First Note
0:08
Ending Note Delay
0:04
Hand Bias
Framers
0 - 0
1 - 0
2 - 0
3 - 0
4 - 37
Jumps
Hands
Quads
Color Jumps
Color Hands
Color Quads
Most notes in:
1/3 of a Second
8 - 24.00 nps
0.5 Seconds
11 - 22.00 nps
1 Second
19 - 19.00 nps
2 Seconds
33 - 16.50 nps
5 Seconds
71 - 14.20 nps
10 Seconds
135 - 13.50 nps
30 Seconds
328 - 10.93 nps
1 Minute
585 - 9.75 nps
Color Count
Largest Note Gaps
3.8s0.63s0.63s0.63s0.63s0.5s0.5s0.5s
Posted at 7:56pm on October 3rd, 2021
Babylon
-------
- Permissions, metadata good.
** 8.047: Should be a 32nd earlier (i.e. on the 16th). Similarly 18.152, etc.
- 9.863: Missing note. Similarly 19.968, etc.
- 23.284, 24.389: The anchoring here is unusally heavy compared to the rest of this section, with no percussion justifying it. Consider reducing anchoring.
- 34.968: Really like the patterning in this little 16th run.
- 41.442: A touch lower than 40.652, suggest [13] jump.
- 48.369: Missing jump to melody, similar to 53.442. Single at 51.073 should also be a jump.
- 59.205, 59.363, 61.257, 63.310, 65.205, 65.363: Missing notes.
** 88.652: The chart goes about a frame offsync here--you should put a subbeat in at 88.336 (it's still synced properly up to there) and move this beat to 88.684, at which point it resumes at 190bpm. Timestamps beyond this point given with this change made.
- 89.947-end: There are a lot of missing piano notes here, I can't tell whether omitting them is a stylistic decision (since some are notably quieter than others) or a mistake. However, there are a decent amount that are just as prominent as ones you do follow that should probably be included regardless, such as 92.789, 93.026, 95.711, etc.
- 99.421: Don't agree with this being a 3-note jumpjack, the piano is fairly distinct in all three.
- 103.132: Missing note.
A lot of the 16th patterning is really well done, and the PR is pretty attentive whenever there's room to make it so, nice job. Unfortunately, there are a couple of pretty significant sync issues (the **'d notes) which must be fixed before this is game-ready. There are also many missing notes, some of which may be stylistic choices, but others being a bit puzzling as they are very similar in impact and intensity to those you do follow, which I suggest you look over. [7/10]
Posted at 8:46am on January 5th, 2022
Thanks for the reviews.
A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 967 => 978
AVG NPS changed: 8.50484 => 8.60158
Hand Bias changed: 1 => 6
Posted at 6:31pm on January 25th, 2022
Sync for the file is still off beyond 88.652 (01:28.652) as of the current fix.
As a result, most notes past this section are still roughly a 32nd off-sync.
Also, 32nds as pointed out from note 8.047 (00:08.047) are not on 16ths (they should be where the mine is).
Same with 00:18.152 going to 00:18.073, etc.
Posted at 7:54pm on March 3rd, 2022
Commenting to double-check and see where things are at with this. It's been over a month since the last post and not much communication about it. If there's no response in 2-ish weeks, then I will assume that it can get submitted for a different batch in the future when fixes are applied.
Posted at 5:27pm on March 27th, 2022
Moving this to rejected so that it doesn't get lost/stuck in CQ. When you get the chance to cover fixes, please re-submit this song & chart to an active batch.