TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

[Nighthawk252]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

nawk, your read on jrodd seems to be all over the place. First you say you're not reading him town, then you say probably not the CL, but then you say that you're reading his aggression as town. What's your overall read on him right now/where is he in your lynch pool?

I probably could have written it better, but I was saying that I wasn't reading him town for the reason a lot of other people were. I definitely remember a few people reading J-Rodd human for seeming happy with his role, which I think is a pretty terrible reason. It's easily faked and him being unhappy with his role is something that would be on his mind regardless of whether he was town or scum.

I think he seems town to me because his posts and how he's going after people seem different from last game I played with him, where he was a wolf. This doesn't mean he's not a third party, because a lot of third parties would be similar to town on Day 1. I still don't think he's the CL, but that's because I think if there is a cult it's probably weak, and I think that if J-Rodd was the CL he'd both want Mashi converted and also not want Mashi to lose if Mashi was a wolf.

[Funnygurl555]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

Surprised by Funnygurl's dormancy this game.

you know guys maybe I should've posted reads last night
because I feel like you guys gonna get on my case for waiting to post thoughts on people

I've also realized that regardless of my alignment people always harp on my posting style these days. What am I doing differently?

[AragakiAyase]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

nawk/plop now that you're here what do you think about zenith's argument and my interactions with jrodd?

[Funnygurl555]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

read again, I didn't read jrodd a wolf, I said he's town or third party lol
idk why people are saying I'm reading him a wolf.

also I can see zenith falling into his own confirmation bias/tunnel mode where all he does is yell at his target while providing barely any arguments with substance

oh ok woops I just assumed since you two were going at each other and you were making a case on him

[j-rodd123]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

What's lol about that, zenith is a 3rd party and he made a post with that logic

[Charles Claythorne]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

I probably could have written it better, but I was saying that I wasn't reading him town for the reason a lot of other people were. I definitely remember a few people reading J-Rodd human for seeming happy with his role, which I think is a pretty terrible reason. It's easily faked and him being unhappy with his role is something that would be on his mind regardless of whether he was town or scum.

I think he seems town to me because his posts and how he's going after people seem different from last game I played with him, where he was a wolf. This doesn't mean he's not a third party, because a lot of third parties would be similar to town on Day 1. I still don't think he's the CL, but that's because I think if there is a cult it's probably weak, and I think that if J-Rodd was the CL he'd both want Mashi converted and also not want Mashi to lose if Mashi was a wolf.

If j-rodd is a Wolf again, I would expect his posting to decline as the game progresses, which we can judge later if it comes to it. Do you feel the content of his posts don't seem Human to you? Even someone as amazing as j-rodd gets tired of rolling Wolf so often tbh

you know guys maybe I should've posted reads last night
because I feel like you guys gonna get on my case for waiting to post thoughts on people

I've also realized that regardless of my alignment people always harp on my posting style these days. What am I doing differently?

You're not posting food gifs.

Frustrated as a 3rd party, or frustrated.........as a PR??

I don't know, maybe? I don't feel like he's done anything too suspicious, just behaving oddly is all, which makes me raise an eyebrow. Regardless of explanation, I'm fine with AragakiAyase sticking around still since he's cool. B)

[Nighthawk252]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

go do the numbers on the chance of a 5C roll happening, while it's low it's still not ruling it out

A shade under .4% at the start of the game. If you believe Zenith, halve that. So we probably should rule it out in our attempts to solve the game. I'm kind of confused as to why you're arguing this point at all. Even if you're right and there's technically the possibility of 5Cs and a cultist, that does far less to clear you than attacking the reasons they gave for thinking you as cult.

[AragakiAyase]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

inconsistency

lmfao

[AragakiAyase]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

A shade under .4% at the start of the game. If you believe Zenith, halve that. So we probably should rule it out in our attempts to solve the game. I'm kind of confused as to why you're arguing this point at all. Even if you're right and there's technically the possibility of 5Cs and a cultist, that does far less to clear you than attacking the reasons they gave for thinking you as cult.

it's more of a technicality than anything. I must have missed something because I didn't see any reasons they gave for them thinking I'm the cult, only "if AA's 3rd party he's the cult"

[AragakiAyase]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

AA is in the cult, lock in that read

I found the post where someone thinks I'm cult so my memory was a little off but I was right about the reasons not being clear

[Nighthawk252]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

nawk/plop now that you're here what do you think about zenith's argument and my interactions with jrodd?

Initial reaction is that I think they're being too hard on you, but I'll double back and reread so I can actually argue that instead of just saying it.

[_Zenith_]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

[_Zenith_]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

What is this factual evidence you speak of? For mashi, is it the big quote wall and reads list? Because if it is, don't be fooled by the length/depth of them, he's made fakeposts that elaborate as scum before.

I used statistical data when posting that, and Mashi's megapost only awards town points; because what ultimately matters is what he said, not how much he said in general.

Regardless Jrodd/Mashi should not be lynched for a couple of phases imo.

[_Zenith_]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

also bringing up this post again; you say inconsistency here, yet I don't see any consistency. I theorycrafted about the jester but that doesn't mean that he's even present and it certainly doesn't rule out the 5C roll. Just because it's statistically unlikely doesn't mean it won't happen. if you look at the signup thread I did a random roll just to see what would happen and got 5 Ks. pushing a lynch on me because I'm refusing to rule out the possibility of 5Cs is, to put it in your words, asinine

This post is the epitome of angleshooting holy fuck.

[_Zenith_]

Re: TWG CXXXIX (139) - Intro to Bastard++ [Game Thread]

Also he is definitely wrong about his perceived thoughts about my reasoning to pursue a lynch on him.

In lack of a better term you are shady as fuck and some of the actions you have performed this game (proven actions I should say) outweighs the townlike qualities you may present; however I doubt you are town-aligned because the only thing that really points heavily upon that idea is you searching for the possible nonexistent jester.