Old 02-3-2011, 08:39 PM   #81
reuben_tate
Kawaii Desu Ne?
Sectional ModeratorFFR Veteran
 
reuben_tate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: The Kawaiian Island~
Age: 27
Posts: 4,130
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

Quote:
Originally Posted by Reincarnate View Post
I would argue against that and say that sometimes a child doesn't know what's best for themselves. If my kid wanted to be an artist, I would have trouble encouraging that when I know full well how most artists turn out and what challenges they face down the road -- challenges a kid really won't care about until the shit hits the fan. It is tempting to equate "Child displaying a desire to do X" with "Child is therefore happy if he is allowed to pursue X," but I think that children are sometimes ill-equipped to properly assess what will make them happiest down the road.

There are certain realities to various lifestyles that many people don't realize until they're there. Even in a particular pathway would result in a very happy life down the road as a result of hard work, a child might kick and scream along the way. As Chua argues, nothing is fun until you're good at it.
I still don't think you understand the point that us others are trying to get across. I'm not saying that if child X wants to pursue Y, then the parent of child X should allow them to be free to do whatever they want. We are saying that child X's parents should try to guide them toward a general road (nothing too specific) by using mild suggestion, hinting, and explanations given to the child that list's the pro's and con's of the situation. Parent's should use the power of reason and persuasion to get their child "on course" as opposed to using the power of authority. When one (this can be for any situation) is limited down to only choice, they feel trapped and tend to respond in rebellion. Why? Because in our society, we associate the mitigation of speech with levels of respect. A direct command is more "mean" and disrespectful as opposed to a suggestion or hint. So, assuming disrespect is grounds for rebellion, one is more likely to rebel against a command as opposed to a suggestion.

By the way, a lot of my points, and the thing about mitigated speech vs respect, is from the book "Outliers" by Malcolm Gladwell.
__________________
AMA: http://ask.fm/benguino

Not happening now! Don't click to join!



Quote:
Originally Posted by Spenner View Post
(^)> peck peck says the heels
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xx{Midnight}xX
And god made ben, and realized he was doomed to miss. And said it was good.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zakvvv666
awww :< crushing my dreams; was looking foward to you attempting to shoot yourself point blank and missing
reuben_tate is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-3-2011, 09:06 PM   #82
Reincarnate
x'); DROP TABLE FFR;--
Sectional ModeratorFFR Veteran
 
Reincarnate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Posts: 6,334
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

Quote:
Originally Posted by reuben_tate View Post
I still don't think you understand the point that us others are trying to get across. I'm not saying that if child X wants to pursue Y, then the parent of child X should allow them to be free to do whatever they want. We are saying that child X's parents should try to guide them toward a general road (nothing too specific) by using mild suggestion, hinting, and explanations given to the child that list's the pro's and con's of the situation. Parent's should use the power of reason and persuasion to get their child "on course" as opposed to using the power of authority. When one (this can be for any situation) is limited down to only choice, they feel trapped and tend to respond in rebellion. Why? Because in our society, we associate the mitigation of speech with levels of respect. A direct command is more "mean" and disrespectful as opposed to a suggestion or hint. So, assuming disrespect is grounds for rebellion, one is more likely to rebel against a command as opposed to a suggestion.

By the way, a lot of my points, and the thing about mitigated speech vs respect, is from the book "Outliers" by Malcolm Gladwell.
I am saying that sometimes you may have to make tough choices for your kid that are best for them -- and that child may rebel anyway. However, rebellion isn't always an unhealthy thing. Sometimes "mild suggestion and hinting" is simply not enough. Like Chua mentions, many Chinese assume strength. Many Westerners assume fragility.

You can list pros and cons to a child all you want -- but that doesn't mean a child will really understand and heed the advice. Like I said, a child doesn't *know* any differently and therefore it's much harder to empathize with someone who's been through it all already.

Consider your lobster example, but let's make it something more in line with my point -- say, veggies:

1. "You are going to try the veggie platter"
2. "Would you be interested in trying our veggie platter today?"

It'd be great if we could "suggest" these things with the listed advantages and hope that more people choose #2 on their own accord. But the problem is that many kids won't care. They don't *want* the veggie platter, no matter how good you tell them it is. You know the platter is extremely nutritious and would help establish a really healthy system early on that would lead to exponential benefits later. And yet, that kid may fight. Sometimes you simply have to get your kid to eat the veggies, and sometimes persuasion alone won't do the trick. You may have to be a bit of a hard-ass from time to time.

Last edited by Reincarnate; 02-3-2011 at 09:24 PM..
Reincarnate is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-3-2011, 10:00 PM   #83
Izzy
Frau Bow
FFR Simfile AuthorFFR Veteran
 
Izzy's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Kansas
Age: 30
Posts: 9,200
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

I would argue that there's more to life then just being successful. I guess if thats all you think is important then they are good parents.
__________________
Join SMO IRC. irc.rizon.net#smo
Izzy is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-4-2011, 12:53 AM   #84
Rubin0
FFR Player
 
Rubin0's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: New York
Age: 32
Posts: 1,279
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

My approach to parenthood, or at least the approach I hope to take when I am a parent is to encourage my children to pursue what they love while also staying realistic. I hope that my child is a musician and an artist and a poet. However, I would never encourage these as day jobs. Everyone should pursue their passions while being able to provide for not only themselves but also their possible future family. I would encourage my child to take pottery classes, even minor in some form of art, but I would NOT encourage him or her to major in art unless he or she had hopes of someday being an art teacher. I hope that my child, after years of teaching him or her common sense, would realize that under any other circumstance, spending money on a degree in art is unreasonable because becoming a famous artist is highly unlikely. Art and poetry is for the weekends and evening hours. The day hours are for work and education. From my own experiences in college, the students that pursued degrees in areas like art or philosophy or English were often the result of over indulgent parents, whether wealthy or not. These people do not understand the value of the dollar or how their parents got to where they are. Majoring in art because you are good at drawing? Their parents must be the exact opposite of the "tiger" parents. Honestly I would like to find the healthy median because I don't want kids that are terrified of my disapproval or wishy washy kids that think spray painting a wall is a career.
__________________
The weight of what I say depends on how you feel.

Last edited by Rubin0; 02-4-2011 at 01:03 AM..
Rubin0 is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-4-2011, 08:51 AM   #85
Reincarnate
x'); DROP TABLE FFR;--
Sectional ModeratorFFR Veteran
 
Reincarnate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Posts: 6,334
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

Quote:
Originally Posted by Rubin0 View Post
My approach to parenthood, or at least the approach I hope to take when I am a parent is to encourage my children to pursue what they love while also staying realistic. I hope that my child is a musician and an artist and a poet. However, I would never encourage these as day jobs. Everyone should pursue their passions while being able to provide for not only themselves but also their possible future family. I would encourage my child to take pottery classes, even minor in some form of art, but I would NOT encourage him or her to major in art unless he or she had hopes of someday being an art teacher. I hope that my child, after years of teaching him or her common sense, would realize that under any other circumstance, spending money on a degree in art is unreasonable because becoming a famous artist is highly unlikely. Art and poetry is for the weekends and evening hours. The day hours are for work and education. From my own experiences in college, the students that pursued degrees in areas like art or philosophy or English were often the result of over indulgent parents, whether wealthy or not. These people do not understand the value of the dollar or how their parents got to where they are. Majoring in art because you are good at drawing? Their parents must be the exact opposite of the "tiger" parents. Honestly I would like to find the healthy median because I don't want kids that are terrified of my disapproval or wishy washy kids that think spray painting a wall is a career.
100% agreed

I think at the end of the way, the best thing is to simply encourage intellectual curiosity. When you have that, you *want* to learn. You *want* to indulge in as much as you can. You don't see books as "books I have to read" but books you *want to read* because they will give you interesting information that'll help you get closer to your dreams/goals.

I can't remember the exact quote, but it was something like this:

"You can either tell a group of men to help build you a ship, or you can get them to dream about what lies beyond the horizon."

Last edited by Reincarnate; 02-4-2011 at 08:55 AM..
Reincarnate is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-4-2011, 11:18 AM   #86
rushyrulz
Digital Dancing!
Multiplayer ModeratorEvent StaffFFR Simfile AuthorFFR Music ProducerD7 Elite KeysmasherFFR Veteran
 
rushyrulz's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: 72 billion club, NE
Age: 28
Posts: 12,517
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

Quote:
Originally Posted by reuben_tate View Post
A direct command is more "mean" and disrespectful as opposed to a suggestion or hint. So, assuming disrespect is grounds for rebellion, one is more likely to rebel against a command as opposed to a suggestion.
American English is a mean language. When's the last time you used the subjunctive in regular conversation?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Reincarnate View Post
Consider your lobster example, but let's make it something more in line with my point -- say, veggies:

1. "You are going to try the veggie platter"
2. "Would you be interested in trying our veggie platter today?"

It'd be great if we could "suggest" these things with the listed advantages and hope that more people choose #2 on their own accord.
Precisely. (lol context)
__________________


Last edited by rushyrulz; 02-4-2011 at 11:24 AM..
rushyrulz is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-5-2011, 02:29 AM   #87
reuben_tate
Kawaii Desu Ne?
Sectional ModeratorFFR Veteran
 
reuben_tate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: The Kawaiian Island~
Age: 27
Posts: 4,130
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

Ok, you two (Reincarnate & rushyrulz), you got a point there. I'm not a stubborn person so I am willing to change me original thesis based on these new insights. Would it be right to say that suggestion and hinting be used initially, with direct commands being used sparingly as a last resort?
__________________
AMA: http://ask.fm/benguino

Not happening now! Don't click to join!



Quote:
Originally Posted by Spenner View Post
(^)> peck peck says the heels
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xx{Midnight}xX
And god made ben, and realized he was doomed to miss. And said it was good.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zakvvv666
awww :< crushing my dreams; was looking foward to you attempting to shoot yourself point blank and missing
reuben_tate is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 02-7-2011, 12:44 AM   #88
Reincarnate
x'); DROP TABLE FFR;--
Sectional ModeratorFFR Veteran
 
Reincarnate's Avatar
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Posts: 6,334
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

I don't know about "suggesting vs. commanding," but I think there's nothing wrong with commanding as long as the command makes sense and is reasonable.
Reincarnate is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-14-2011, 03:54 PM   #89
Cavernio
sunshine and rainbows
FFR Veteran
 
Join Date: Feb 2006
Age: 38
Posts: 1,987
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

Parents command kids to do things everyday, from brushing their teeth to eating their veggies. But those commands make sense because its for their physical well-being. Its much, much harder to know what is best for their psychological well-being. It depends on the person. The thing about her article that struck me the most (well, at least which hasn't been discussed in length here), is that kids will not try to do anything for themselves, and that they need that external motivation to do things. That's simply not true. Give something the kid kinda likes (which, granted, they won't know until they've tried it), and it'll be obvious. I loved figure skating and dancing, and I hated baseball. All my parents had to do was offer the choice, do it for a season, and they'd ask if I wanted to do it again next season. I never chose to not do anything in my entire life until an adult. I learned a bit of piano from my mom, but definitely by the time I was 10, possibly earlier, I was the person asking her for lessons, not the other way around.

I really think the age of a kid is important for how much you push them too. If you push them at a very young age, they'll get super good at whatever it is you're doing for them, however I have to think that their imagination would suffer a lot. Kids learn a lot more than just skills growing up; they learn who they are, really, they have such a rich internal life. (Or at least I did.) It would be terrible, absolutely terrible, to take that away from a kid. I had a friend, non-asian, whose father pushed her to skills beyond what most people had. Sure, she got all A's, but that didn't make her happy. She pulled all-nighters in friggin' junior high. It also didn't make her any smarter; I helped her with math and physics right up through highschool. Albeit, when I hung out with her the most, my grades went up, not that they were bad. But what did go up didn't matter, because I don't remember dick all about the middle east from grade 9 social studies, even though for the only time in my life I buckled down and memorized things. There's also an age, a pretty young one in my mind, where a child is no longer just a child too. I mean, there's 12 year olds who post here who are perfectly capable of making up their own mind about whether they want to play piano or not.

Last edited by Cavernio; 04-14-2011 at 03:57 PM..
Cavernio is offline   Reply With Quote
Old 04-14-2011, 05:39 PM   #90
Phlegmatism
FFR Player
 
Phlegmatism's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 128
Default Re: Why Chinese Mothers are Superior

I enjoyed this read, thanks for bumping.

My mom is Chinese, and my dad is Caucasian. They divorced while I was in Kindergarten. Gender stereotypes aside, my mother's personality was more orderly, rational, supportive--morally and academically, and helpful. My dad is comical, more of a friend, playful, and supported persistent physical labor. In the article you can see the strains and disagreements between the typical Chinese parenting versus the "Westerner" parenting.

For 12 years I would spend half a week at one house, and half a week at the other having to adjust to different lifestyles on a regular basis.

Flat out I would have to say I prefer Chinese parenting. Rewards are so great when the goals are so high. Not to say Western parenting is inferior, but even in school, when people were satisfied with B's, it would influence me that I too could settle for something low. Honestly, if my dad had no say in my parenting, I believe I could have had better grades, have gotten into a better college, and have much more self-respect and self-discipline. However, with the personal freedom I could have maintained at my dad's, had I stayed there full-time, I'd be much more sociable and willing to interact with others--I'd make more connections, probably have more study buddies, and trust more people.

I feel that I could never hone in on a single lifestyle at this point. It's led me to become more of an open-minded, unbiased entity. But no hard feelings at Western parenting, I just feel that I could never amount to the person I am today without my Chinese mom.
__________________

Last edited by Phlegmatism; 04-14-2011 at 05:41 PM..
Phlegmatism is offline   Reply With Quote
Reply


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off

Forum Jump



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:30 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright FlashFlashRevolution