TWG CLXXV: Survivor Newfoundland - GAME THREAD

[Vendetta21]

Originally Posted by reuben_tate

I think it was funny too

I feel the same. I am curious if the names are literally gonna be posted one at a time in the thread though...would definitely add some nice flavor to the game.


This bare-bones reads list was a bit off-putting to me. I haven't been up-to-date with the tribe chat, and it seems you're more active there, so I'm guessing you have some reasoning in there.


I mean, I felt awkward with that message because I had to essentially explain a joke. In the spirit of not ruining the joke, I explained it in a joking manner. By any chance, did you find the original joke out of place as well?


I feel like I've only played wolf games the past million times in a row. I must have forgotten how to play town Dx


I am willing to make profile pictures for those folk in paint just so I have a visual image I can identify with each of them >.<


Is there a particular interaction that struck you as odd? I felt like his reaction to my explaining of my joke to wv (praising him for his detective work) was a bit weird.


But can you do the can'tcan't?


I feel like I'm colorblind...I was having such a hard time differentiating between "orange" and "dark orange" Dx

No there wasn't a particular thing he said that I think was odd I'm very much making snap judgments on gestalt impressions relating to vague memories from over a year and a half ago

I don't mean to continue to whine about private voting but I have to fundamentally retool my day 1 play without it, still mulling this over

And it's never particular events that make someone wolfy unless they spew, it's the way their disposition meanders through the thread

Dbp just felt a little vacillating in focus or tone but atm my only lean is jrodd, his dark greens look like people he'd like to have favor with tbh

[Vendetta21]

I mean I get them I guess, dunno it's like when you pull the milk out of the fridge and whiff it and it's a little bit spunky but you still would use

[Charu]

Do you have any idea why he put you in that category, V? Or is it classified info?

[star-crossed]

Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee

and in response to this, (i'm gonna ignore the discord timing tells cause lol that)

My main thought was that, your talk with Haku prompting you to think tribe chat is important and want to join, made somewhat more sense to me if you would have if you are a town (so less informationL. I have made mistakes before with assuming what people talk about in wolf chats though so I wanted to walk through my thought process and see if anybody thought it was a good way to get an idea on you. It is up to you what you want to discuss but I do not get saying "lol that."

Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee

i would personally describe the way i and give my reads as deliberate and purposeful rather than 'cagey' or 'hesitant' but whatever floats your boat.

and also i think a lot of my posting style tends to be more based on driving interactions and driving conversation (this is from my other site, since it is more real time interactions) and so i have a bad habit of explaining my reads after giving them, because i want people's initial reactions to my push, and to see who is curious why i'm pushing them.

thesunfan read not being explained is purposeful, but /shrug, its honestly probably not important at all, and i explained why in the tribe chat (that you're in) so if you're really curious you can look at it.

I feel that you really are missing my point with calling you cagey, in particular. From bringing up that you felt awkward about not knowing others when somebody was joking toward you, and giving few leans, you seemed hesitant to me. But what I mean by calling you cagey, is because of the deliberate difference of how you talked about your leans on Sun fan and Shado where they could see directly and how you talked about them where they could not. I think it is probably more of a town behavior to be paranoid of how they could react to seeing all your thoughts in general, as well as to test others kind of. But because of that kind of, I don't get why you explained so much about sun in tribe chat, if it was important enough that you didn't want it to affect his behaviour if he is a mafia? Was that something you addressed already and I was missing? Because it seems inconsistent to me.

Actually, maybe that is something you explained now in your second paragraph, that it is that you were curious in our tribe's thoughts. You are right that I should look at it again I suppose, to see if that makes more sense now.

[j-rodd123]

Originally Posted by Charu

Do you have any idea why he put you in that category, V? Or is it classified info?

are u asking about my read on V?

[Charu]

Well, I already asked before what V and thesunfan did to make you trust 'em earlier!!!1

[j-rodd123]

well V had a similar entry mindset to me with regards to private voting and stuff although i guess he could fake it

sunfan read i cant really explain at this point

[flashflash account]

1. Cold Kitten biggest question mark to me so far
2. Celirra town
3. star-crossed null
4. Wayward Vagabond town
5. Vendetta21 town
6. Soundwave- wolfy
7. reuben_tate less wolfy than soundwave
8. j-rodd123 human
9. ShadoWolfe human
10. Tokzic human
11. theknightsofneeee human
12. Charu wolf
13. DaBackpack wolf
14. flashflash account human
15. Hakulyte town
16. thesunfan second biggest ???

[Vendetta21]

Originally Posted by Charu

Do you have any idea why he put you in that category, V? Or is it classified info?

I mean yes I have an idea but do you describe a tree as branchy or arboreal or fractally outgrowthing when you get an impression of a tree or does your brain do most of the semantic and emotional work and you just go "tree"

[Charu]

Yes

[Celirra]

Originally Posted by flashflash account

2. Celirra-wolf lean

Originally Posted by flashflash account

2. Celirra town

hi what changed why aren't I fluffy anymore

[flashflash account]

access to the discord log, I like you a lot better in there

[ShadoWolfe]

I'd appreciate it if everyone could list their top 2 shots here.

Vote has to be DDR, but shot can be from either tribe.

I've talked to a good number of you privately already, but I'd appreciate it if you could also post it here for the record.

[star-crossed]

Originally Posted by theknightsofneeee

As for the rest of the big list:

seems a bit premature to have a full ordered tier list, and some of the reasoning I find pretty premature/suspect/possibly fake (i.e. tokzic, vagabond, reuben)

but

yeah i don't even have a full picture on the game yet so i guess i'm just gonna move on until i do and then perhaps revisit that post

I wrote a response to this and then it signed me out and i lost it which is annoying.

I have never been in a werewolf game this big before. Usually it is more comfortable for me to focus on a few people I feel strongly about and who they are unaligned with. But i feel in this one I may just end up wasting my time only focusing on town, so i am kind of trying to get a good balance. I was also alone in the thread this morning so i thought it would be a good opportunity to explain my feelings and hear from others what of it seems reasonable and what does not. So i appreciate that you made some comments, to that end, unlike others who kept memeing

- With tokzic, what stands out to you about him yourself?
- With WV, I get very happy good vibes from how he is playing, and it is hard for me to see him as a mafia. I think it may not be as sensible as some of my other leans, But it is how I feel. It is not merely happy vibes though. I think what I heard of his questioning Celi about me (in response to what I brought up about Celi in ddr chat), seemed like a town genuinely interested in figuring things out. Specifically the mix of silly and investigative behavior, seems like he is bringing his whole self to the game, not just a front. If that makes sense?
- I would pastebin my convo with Reuben if I was not on my phone. One part of it is that I asked him if he was taking notes this game. He said

And I don't have notes. I mostly wrote notes as a wolf last game for my own sake because I was having such a hard time fabricating actual thoughts that I needed to see a bigger picture of what was happening in order to come up with believable reads/beliefs/thoughts/etc

Which I felt pretty good about. I am feeling in general that his self narrative, about being a town for the first time in a while, is more likely genuine.

[j-rodd123]

my shot list is:

DBP
DBP

[flashflash account]

DBP and kitten

[Hakulyte]

DBP and kitten sounds good.

[star-crossed]

Originally Posted by Charu

So the impression I get from this post in your opinion of me is...

The less jovial and random I am, the more I am wolfing.

Will take it to heart the next time I play then.

Uhhh, are you saying that you will be more fun next time we play so that I like you? I do not really know what to do with that. Why are you more concerned about next time than now?

My thought on you is confusion and an absence of trust, more than active distrust based on you seeming less fun.

[Hakulyte]

To the people speculating about if there's 4:0, 3:1, 2:2 wolves in tribes:

If you can't prove it, move on.

[Charu]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

To the people speculating about if there's 4:0, 3:1, 2:2 wolves in tribes:

If you can't prove it, move on.

What if the wolves are actually their own separate tribe and we're actually 20 players?

monkaS