[4K] BLACK or WHITE?

[XelNya]

^ Download ^

Etterna Scale:
Hard: 21 (rounded)
Challenge: 22
Edit: 23

Contains:

Minijacks
Jacks
Stream
-------
Stream
Handstream
Jump Jacks
32nd rolls
-------
Stream
Handstream
Jump Jacks
Handjacks
32nd rolls

I want to lead off with the fact that I will be updating this file over the week if anything glaring comes up. I'm not as good as I was, so I can hardly play this to test it, so all the feedback into how it plays is greatly appreciated.

I know gpop already did a pad file for this, and since song search is down I dunno if it's been done, but I did it anyways.

Notes:

Hard:

This is the main chart. It's the one oriented to possibly being ratable and the one I invested the most time into making.

Challenge / Edit

Think of these as "what if" and they're not to be taken as seriously as the Hard chart. I think Challenge should still be relatively fun but Edit is probably a bit ass.

Would again appreciate all the feedback you can all contribute. I'm working on a minipack of stuff, and feedback would also help me in gauging how I want to make those files.

PS: If someone wants to do updated graphics for this, that'd be pretty sick. I just slapped some kinda not that great ones together so I could release it.

[choof]

racism didn't download

[blindreper1179]

Originally Posted by choof

racism didn't download

same

[XelNya]

**RACISM INTENSIFIES**

[Celirra]

I always appreciate files of sdvx music, there's so many more potential good charts that just aren't yet

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by Celirra

I always appreciate files of sdvx music, there's so many more potential good charts that just aren't yet

I have another one done and ready, it's just a matter of X-moding it how I want to.

[Crazer]

if it aint white it aint right

[Leo137]

cool song never heard it before

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by Celirra

I always appreciate files of sdvx music, there's so many more potential good charts that just aren't yet

Agreed. I wouldn't even know about this shit if it weren't for kommi posting Flugel in the xoon pack.

[Toby1018]

arent there 2 files for this in yolo 3 already

[Celirra]

Originally Posted by XelNya

Agreed. I wouldn't even know about this shit if it weren't for kommi posting Flugel in the xoon pack.

I can hit you up with a bunch of good sdvx songs if you want, hmu on discord

[-Tim-]

Originally Posted by choof

racism didn't download

racis

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by Toby1018

arent there 2 files for this in yolo 3 already

I wouldn't know. I've skipped all the yolo packs I don't have files in, and the song search is down.

But yeah more songs from this game would be fun. But yeah.

Has anyone actually played it XD

[SKG_Scintill]

Heavy Chart:

---

Despite the notes being different, minijacks are fine in most places
Except at longer parts like 16.267 - 16.753 where the difference in pitch between every note is very noticable, it's a bit iffy to play these as minijacks

21.456 - 21.699:
But these are clearly jacks to the ear, even 2 sets of minijacks would make more sense

31.186 - 32.483:
This part makes way more sense as minijacks than what came before this point, but aight.

32.483 - 41.564:
32.483 is supposed to be a set of grace notes, but ok there's a quad there so to each their own
But 33.132, 33.465, 34.429, 34.753, 35.726, 36.375, 37.024, 37.348 and 38.970 (!), 39.618 there are no grace notes in the music
39.943 is sort of a grace note, but not that soon, the second note is slightly before the 8th rather than after the 4th
If you used the grace notes to give off the vibe of a celesta, then you're missing a whole lot of grace notes

53.645: missing a 16th here
same goes for 56.240, 58.835, 61.429 and 64.024

67.753: hand goes here, not on the 4th after
67.997: hand goes here
68.240: hand goes here, not on the 4th before

68.808: don't just change to minijacks, the music isn't doing that
72.375: *especially* when you do use regular stream here
73.348: these are valid minijacks

74.645 and 75.943: maybe it's hard to hear because of the effect, but there's a note here
the same one as 77.240 and onwards

96.294: the jump of the melody is here, not on the 8th before and the 4th after
97.105: missing 16th (jump?)

97.348: again, clearly no minijacks in the music

106.916: at 105.618 you used a minijacks, but here you use a jumpstream pattern, inconsistent

107.726 - 110.321: was surprised not to see any minijacks here


Oni Chart:

---

Many of the same issues of the heavy chart, except for more warranty for some of the minijacks

111.132 - 111.618: waoh nice anchor, pls no


Edit Chart:

---

Obviously still same issues of the heavy chart
Gonna be slightly more demanding of this chart since it's supposed to be the hardest

11.402: no 32nd roll but there is one in the oni chart?

44.862 - 48.051: got underwhelmed by the layering here, the snares do much more than just the 4ths
to me 43.997, 44.970, arguably 45.781 and 46.591 all sound like snares

73.348: no 32nd roll for the piano?

99.618: where's the polyrhythm

114.862: no 24th trills?

[XelNya]

Took me a while to sit down and get to it, but thanks scin for those.

Also, I am an immense sucker for polys and those trills are fucking evil on the edit chart. I thought 175 bpm 24ths was nasty, but that's just gross. XD

[SKG_Scintill]

miku's gross