TWG XCV Postgame

[Syhto]

haha you guys did good

[Syhto]

also freaky rules

[Vendetta21]

Someone host another C9++

[James May]

Originally Posted by Tps222

Mike and James May should each be banned a game for their inactivity, if we're going to remain consistent.

Perhaps not Mike, but come on man don't volunteer to replace someone and then fail to contribute, regardless of personal circumstances.

I take full responsibility for it. Personally though, I requested fojar to replace me because someone in my family is going through a health crisis atm and I had to attend to him along with my family, which is why I couldn't be active here :c

But, if I had to be banned for my inactivity, go on I take full responsibility for it.

[dAnceguy117]

Originally Posted by James May

But, if I had to be banned for my inactivity, go on I take full responsibility for it.

it would only be 1 game. could be a good opportunity for you to take care of everything without any distractions. really sorry to hear about your family member's emergency

on the other hand, if you yourself asked to be replaced, then I don't know if any action ought to be taken.

Originally Posted by Vendetta21

all in all, this was even better than the last game and one of the most active and impressive games of TWG we have played as a community. it was heartening to see new players step up to the plate, and old players renew their faith in the game.

agreed! I had a ton of fun both playing in and watching this game. well done, all.

[FoJaR]

Originally Posted by Tps222

Mike and James May should each be banned a game for their inactivity, if we're going to remain consistent.

Perhaps not Mike, but come on man don't volunteer to replace someone and then fail to contribute, regardless of personal circumstances.

in mike's defense he did have hundreds and hundreds of posts to read and analyze

[FoJaR]

yeah james PMed me that he had a family crisis and asked to be replaced, so i dont think any bans this game.

unfortunate timing but not a lot that can be done about that.

[FoJaR]

Originally Posted by Vendetta21

Someone host another C9++

i'm up for hosting again, or playing.

or hosting a custom.

[James May]

Originally Posted by FoJaR

yeah james PMed me that he had a family crisis and asked to be replaced, so i dont think any bans this game.

unfortunate timing but not a lot that can be done about that.

ITT: life gets in the way of most things you want to do zzz
also: great game you played freaky

[AC1speakerbox]

for real though

order of night operations

can we please resolve this?

[Tps222]

I don't think they necessarily deserved to be banned, but it seems awfully unfair to Syhto/Gun to just pick and choose like that.

[cedolad]

Originally Posted by AC1speakerbox

for real though

order of night operations

can we please resolve this?

yeah please?

[Syhto]

i wasn't aware that i was actually banned, but i dont really enjoy the style of these games so I'm good till yall move on to something else

its always kinda arbitrary so i dont mind

[Vendetta21]

Originally Posted by FoJaR

i'm up for hosting again, or playing.

or hosting a custom.

i personally (and manti as well) don't want to stray away from some of the more defining elements of the format
-all activity in thread
-longer phases
-no absolutely certainty of roles

i like setting it up however, i just think those three qualities make for better TWG. the imagery i have used in the past is that it's the difference between Magic: The Gathering and poker. both contain poker-like elements, one is a lot more ruthless and pure. i can see the benefit of both, but i think we are currently getting everyone into this mindset and establishing what makes for good and bad play within this style, which i think is bringing up the quality of the game as whole.

[Syhto]

boring

[Gun92]

Originally Posted by Tps222

I don't think they necessarily deserved to be banned, but it seems awfully unfair to Syhto/Gun to just pick and choose like that.

Figured either it was his personal choice or there was a better option then me. It is what it is. Fun game to watch. I know I am not good at these types of games, but if a some what regular game comes around, I would like to give it another go. Can't seem to stay away.

[FoJaR]

Originally Posted by Tps222

I don't think they necessarily deserved to be banned, but it seems awfully unfair to Syhto/Gun to just pick and choose like that.

so gun missed a night phase, and stuff came up but he never PMed me to ask to be replaced, he just vanished.

syhto missed two night phases.

there's a clear difference.

[FoJaR]

not that i want to rehash all this cause it's done and dealt with as far as i'm concerned.

[FoJaR]

Originally Posted by AC1speakerbox

for real though

order of night operations

can we please resolve this?

next time i'll use natural action resolution.

basically what i did, but kills dont stop doctor from working, which doesnt make sense to me logically but whatever.

[FoJaR]

and also we could do a 12 player nightstart.