Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[bmah]

jx needs to determine the cutoff still (and therefore point reqs) - as I said, there were ridiculous variances in opinions in this batch.

Just give some time.

So three +. depends. If the forth score was [+?] or lower, jx would have to determine the overall validity of the difference. That person may have had a good reason for that grade, or he might've just said it was "boring", which is nondescript and often not a valid statement on its own.

[ichliebekase]

I got + +. +? +? so I'm thinking that's 14 points?

And I really question the sync on my song because for me it's perfect and for rare others it isn't. So I never know what to do with that.

[kjwkjw]

Originally Posted by ichliebekase

I got + +. +? +? so I'm thinking that's 14 points?

+/+./+?/+?
5 + 4 + 3 + 3 = 15 points

[TC_Cyrenics]

Gene Gadget's in.

Lemme guess, I don't get Simfile Author's credit for a collab. X.X

[Coolboyrulez0]

Originally Posted by TC_Cyrenics

Gene Gadget's in.

Lemme guess, I don't get Simfile Author's credit for a collab. X.X

correct

[ichliebekase]

Originally Posted by kjwkjw

+/+./+?/+?
5 + 4 + 3 + 3 = 15 points

SUP <3 I'm sitting here like "dammit I dunno whether to count that + as 4 or 5" so I undercut myself :] thanks thar kjw :3

That one little point gave me that much more joy XD

[TC_Halogen]

By the way, something I feel like I should point out:

Are [++] rated files going to still receive that +1 bonus if they don't get accepted?

EDIT:
Oh, one more thing: because I don't have the two seconds of silence in my file, does that mean that I have to resubmit it in the following batch? Or can I add the two seconds and then just hand it to JX/bmah -- the only changes I made in the file were changing the 5 note bursts of drums to three notes/two notes (respectively), and of course the addition of 2 seconds of silence.

[dore]

lots of varied opinions

++ +? +? +. and + +? +? + for my two files lol

[customstuff]

Originally Posted by kjwkjw

+/+./+?/+?
5 + 4 + 3 + 3 = 15 points

So for me it's 5 + 5 + 3 + 3 = 16...

Is the cutoff...17? ASOIDUGASVPFIUGVASF
My file tends to have issues with personal preference.
I find that +. is used VERY rarely. Most judges just tend to throw out +? instead.
I'm not complaining though.

Oh, btw, most of my day was shitty.

But:

Arch0wl:

Phalanx (FFR cut) [+]

I liked the descending jackhammer / 48th-note motifs you used here. For sure, I'm going to remember your file because of that. It didn't feel like a generic spread file, which is great.


This seriously made my day. <3

[ichliebekase]

CS, you'll likely be accepted since the cutoff is 16/17 depending on your notes. Plus, they're discussing the point system being too subjective this time around so you may get an accept.

And nice comment there :] hope it gets in so I can play it.

[championanwar]

When I wake up tomorrow, I'll submit my files.

[nois-or-e]

Originally Posted by MrPopadopalis25

Word. I got a [+] and a [?] on the same file.

lol [ + / +? / ? / - ]


I really thought I was going to get grilled for my JS patterns not the intro section . . .

[Ziergdsx18]

Originally Posted by nois-or-e

lol [ + / +? / ? / - ]


I really thought I was going to get grilled for my JS patterns not the intro section . . .

Same with mine. Quitting the arrows, bye FFR.















Haha lol jk, actually I kinda had the feeling my file would get rejected and mostly for one of the things almost all the notes had a similarity at: "Technical Errors" lol. But, like I said before, this motivates me even more to keep stepping and hopefully I'll get this chart in by next batch.

[leonid]

Just sent minor fixes for AcidAce-Alliance and Ark

AcidAce-Alliance should have 859 notes, and Ark should have 747 notes.

PLEASE USE THE FIXED VERSIONS INSTEAD OF THE ONES I SENT BEFORE.

[leonid]

Originally Posted by leonid

Just sent minor fixes for AcidAce-Alliance and Ark

AcidAce-Alliance should have 859 notes, and Ark should have 747 notes.

PLEASE USE THE FIXED VERSIONS INSTEAD OF THE ONES I SENT BEFORE.

Quoting this just because it's bottom paged

[Silvuh]

La la la. Did this for the group I was in:

Everything Went Numb (who_cares973) - 18 (4/5/5/4)
Electronic Music is a Joke (AlexDest) - 17++ (3/5+/4/5+)
Positively Inclined RMX (DossarLX ODI) - 17 (5/3/4/5)
Gotta Catch 'em All (SKG_Scintill) - 16 (5/4/2/5)
Foam Born (dore) - 16 (5/3/3/5)
Obscene Amount of Steam (iironiic) - 16 (3/5/5/3)
Phalanx (customstuff) - 16 (3/5/3/5)
Contain (dore) - 15+ (5+/3/3/4)
Duck Hunt (Coolboyrulez0) - 15 (4/4/4/3)
No Salt (Silvuh) - 15 (3/3/5/4)
In the Wind (bmah) - 14 (5/3/4/2)
Fast Asleep (Xayphon) - 14 (2/4/4/4)
No Purpose Flour (iironiic & who_cares973) - 14 (4/4/4/2)
Ready to Go (bmah) - 13 (4/4/4/1)
Kirlian Changes (AsphyxZero) - 12 (4/4/1/3)
Dracula (nois-or-e) - 11 (2/3/1/5)
Nighttrain (truemaestro) - 11 (3/4/2/2)
Cheeseburger (TC_Halogen) - 8 (2/2/4) (approx 10.6/20)
Infernoplex (ChessWizard) - 5 (1/1/1/2)

Gene Gadget Zone (bmah & TC_Cyrenics) - 19 (5/4/5/5)
Four Blockes Madness (woker-x) - 18 (4/5/5/4)
honki sentai majirenjaa (bmah) - 17 (5/5/3/4)
Scavenger (Plan_Bsk81127) - 16+ (4/5/2/5+)
Metro (DossarLX ODI) - 16 (5/5/1/5)
-Glorious Morning- (ichleibekase) - 15 (3/3/4/5)
White Walls (dore) - 14 (5/3/5/1)

P.S. (No Salt)
drtrantastic (9:22:01 PM): +. the 32nd burst is a bit much and you couldve used some jumps in the first half of the file


My 20/20s and 19/20s are really awesome, thanks! <3
I'll send any necessary fixes and stuff~

And I'm just woooondering a little bit though about like...
For Above, from Gundam-Dude:

Above (Silvuh)
- Played the 204 step version just as FYI.
- Multiple difficulty error. gg stepmania gg
- Simple, straightforward, easy-to-follow layering. Good for beginners and it's somewhat interesting.
- No real complaints.
[+.]

So if there are no real complaints, I was wondering what the unreal one was... So close to another 20/20 here.

And for {Lazy Summer Days}, from Kayla:

{Lazy Summer Days} (Silvuh)[+.]
Really not much to say again. Straightforward easy file.

I know it's just two more Simfiler points in contest here, and that ain't a big deal, but I reeally want to ask.


And of course, if anyone wants to ask me about my judging, I got the links in my signature... (or ask on AIM.)

[who_cares973]

connect is suppose to be an easy file :dwi:

[customstuff]

Alright. I did fix up a few minor things on my file. For example, a missed jump and removed the jumps for a couple grace notes. I didn't agree with some things changes, since it makes the file a lot less fun and unique, so I kept a few things the same. It may not look 100% accurate but it FEELS accurate. The chart is meant for playing anyway
So, if my file does get in, let me know so I can send the newer version

(bye the way, Silvuh. It was hard to understand what you meant by all the b___. I figureed it out but then it wasn't accurate in my sm editor)

[cry4eternity]

I can't find i love you's notes on my resubmit .
According to his judgecount here it should be a + though, which gives me 17/20 and a first file in the queue .

[i love you]

Oh sorry, forgot to send the notes to that file.

Bmah, would it be okay if i just copy/paste his notes here?