View Single Post
Old 10-2-2014, 02:57 PM   #8909
choof
Banned
Retired StaffFFR Simfile AuthorD7 Elite KeysmasherFFR Veteran
 
Join Date: Nov 2013
Posts: 8,563
Default Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 [Regular batch: OPEN]

Odd22


Quote:
- I still have issues with those one-handed patterns (example: starting ats 53.866s. Not only the speed and repetitiveness but the fact that it will not convert well on FFR)
You and I both know that the sm chart is way dumber, but I'll take a look at this. Changing this section would require a total overhaul.



Quote:
- Many BPM changes in this sporadic track. 16th sections with tricky bursts.
I want to respond to this by saying that this particular track is from 2005, so it's messy. The BPM changes are correct.

Quote:
- 75.18-110.60: I've noticed this same pattern keeps getting repeated over and over again and it gets annoying after a while. Vary this up more
This pattern keeps getting repeated over and over because that is what the song is doing. I didn't feel like changing the patterns were necessary; generally you could change overall pattern structure if the song changes pitch, but in this case it would have been arbitrary.

Quote:
- Some jumps I could follow, but most jumps were obscure. For a file with this kind of complexity and intensity, layering should be conservative.
Layering changes due to what's going on in the song.
Intro is self explanatory.
Section after the slow down, jumps are accenting louder percussion, and the metallic sounds (the [14]s during the slowdown).
Section that begins at 70.69, jumps are going to the squelchy sound.


Quote:
- 41.64: Note offsetting in this section of the file is unnecessary, these are just 16ths. The offsetting goes to 52.69
It's actually like this rofl (I'll sync to the 16th)


Quote:
- 57.74: This 24th is too late, the 12th before is what you're looking for
Fixed.


Quote:
- 96.32: What's with this speedup? This is going WAY faster than the actual sounds
The speedup is synced to the synth.

Quote:
- 96.68: This color mess is basically entirely wrong. There isn't anything that sounds complex here, there are a lot of ghost notes and wrong BPMs used. I'm still wondering why these BPM changes are here, because they made this section completely wrong.
This and 96.32 are fixed (and way easier to play, sheeeit)


Quote:
- 104.62: This is a 16th, not a 12th
We're both wrong, rip


Quote:
- 104.94: There isn't a 24th burst here, it's just 16ths
Was originally using 24ths to accent the vocals but yeah, 16ths play better. Fixed.

Quote:
- 107.33, 108.03: The 24th gallops being stepped here are really just 16ths
Same deal with 104.62.

Quote:
- 111.07: See 104.94
Double dads

Quote:
- 112.84: This is a 32nd burst, not a 24th burst
NOW THAT'S WHAT I'M TALKING ABOUT


Quote:
- 117.43, 117.48: Ghost notes. There isn't a 32nd burst here.
Same deal with the earlier 24ths for vocals. Fixed.

Quote:
- 118.90: There is an 8th with a 32nd triplet on the 16th after, but no 24ths
I see what you looking at, but I think that's just the tail end of the sound prior to it. I changed it to look like this.

Quote:
- 119.07: Missing note, 119.22 is a ghost note
Fixed along with 118.90.


Quote:
- 119.64: Ghost note. See 107.33


Quote:
- 123.69, 129.99: Like 117.43, there are no 32nd bursts in these parts
- 125.22: See 118.90
- These errors repeat.
As with earlier, accenting the vocals. These were fixed.


wow do I care more about this file than robotomy
what the fuc

Last edited by choof; 10-2-2014 at 03:02 PM..
choof is offline