View Single Post
Old 10-31-2011, 10:05 PM   #12
hi19hi19
lol happy
Retired StaffFFR Simfile AuthorFFR Veteran
 
hi19hi19's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: DESTINY
Age: 33
Posts: 12,193
Default Re: Classical Music Attribution

There is no common name for Chopin Op. 10 No.9

My only huge gripe with your list is to not put "Molto Vivace" for Transcendental Etude No.2. Out of all the misnamed files that is the worst- it's truly WRONG; it has nothing to do with the name of the song in any context and is not worth preserving IMO. Other people's opinions about this would be nice- I'd say if we have to use a common name, use Fusées/Rockets, but I'd actually prefer just Transcendental Etude No.2.

I'm also leaning towards an abbreviation for the movement rather than the name of the movement, i.e. Mvt. 3 instead of "Presto agitato" for Moonlight Sonata. Again it's less technically correct but more in-line with how a non-music person would name the piece. I think some concessions have to be made for accessibility... though on the other hand it does look a little goofy >_<. It's worth discussing though because I'm not sure why you went with the movement name system.
(p.s. I'm pretty sure the Alla Turca is Mvt.3 so that's what I put but I didn't check lol)

Also went with "Shortened" over "Short version" - it's not technically a "version" of the song, more a "perversion" (lol I'm so funny)
Anyway "shortened" gets the idea across better IMO- why did you use different words?
Also, am I correct in understanding that Mephisto Waltz No.1 is not tagged -Shortened- (even though it most certainly is shorter than the full piece) because it has been marked as "arranged" by Xandertrax?

I'm pretty sure Badinerie is the 7th movement of Suite no.2, is that worth marking? I added it in but I'm not entirely sure it's correct.
Also, I didn't add this in but should we credit SKG_Scintill as the performer of Chopin Etude Op.10, No.9? He said so above...
Shortened Philip Glass to P.Glass too.

Anyway this is what I propose, similar to what you had really. What do you think of the changes?



One Minute Waltz
"Minute" Waltz Op.64, No.1 (F.Chopin)

Minute Waltz v2
"Minute" Waltz Op.64, No.1 v2 (F.Chopin)

Revolutionary Etude
"Revolutionary" Etude Op.10, No.12 (F.Chopin)

Etude in E Major
"Tristesse" Etude Op.10, No.3 -Shortened- (F.Chopin)

Op.10 No.9
Etude Op.10, No.9 (F.Chopin)

Winter Wind Etude
"Winter Wind" Etude Op.25, No.11 (F.Chopin, pf. B.Hisamori)

Black Key Etude
"Black Key" Etude Op.10, No.5 (F.Chopin, pf. B.Krueger)

Prelude No. 7
Prelude Op.28, No.7 (F.Chopin, pf. Xandertrax)

Molto Vivace
Transcendental Etude No.2 (F.Liszt)

La Campanella
"La Campanella" Grand Paganini Etude No.3 (F.Liszt)

Grand Galop Chromatique
Grand Galop Chromatique (F.Liszt, pf. A.Laviano)

Mephisto Waltz
Mephisto Waltz No.1 (F.Liszt, arr.Xandertrax)

Hungarian Dance #7
Hungarian Dance No.7 (J.Brahms, pf. J.Soltau)

Hungarian Dance #5
Hungarian Dance No.5 (J.Brahms, pf. J.Batty)

Turkish March
Marcia Alla Turca Op.113, No.4 (L.v.Beethoven, pf. T.Leen)

Moonlight Sonata
"Moonlight" Sonata No.14-Op.27 No.2 Mvt.1 -Shortened- (L.v.Beethoven)

Sonata Quasi Una Fantasie Mo.3
"Moonlight" Sonata No.14-Op.27 No.2 Mvt.3 (L.v.Beethoven, pf. B.Hisamori)

Humoresque No. 7
Humoresque Op.101, No.7 (A.Dvorak)

Caprice
Caprice No.5 (N.Paganini, pf. S.Mintz)

Flight of the Bumblebee
Flight of the Bumblebee (N.Rimsky-Korsakov)

Rondo Alla Turca
"Rondo Alla Turca" Sonata No.11 K331 Mvt.3 (W.A.Mozart, pf. P.Glass)

Rondo Alla Turca V2
"Rondo Alla Turca" Sonata No.11 K331 Mvt.3 v2 (W.A.Mozart)

Can Can (Piano Version)
"Can Can" Orphee aux enfers -Piano- (J.Offenbach)

Badinerie
"Badinerie" Suite No.2 BWV 1067 Mvt.7 -Piano- (J.S.Bach)

Tambourin Chinois
Tambourin Chinois Op.3 (F.Kreisler)
__________________



Last edited by hi19hi19; 10-31-2011 at 10:26 PM..
hi19hi19 is offline   Reply With Quote