[igotrhythm]

The problem with your counterexample is that what Bob's author is doing (assuming a hit) is a common form of bunnying. The judge would be responsible for warning and possibly DQing those who think they can get away with that kind of bull crap.

If anyone cares to disagree with me on this, I would like to request that we settle our differences via a battle thread set in a typical fantasy setting, so that I can demonstrate that it works. If possible, I would like Lightknight to judge the battle.