[mellon_collie]

Originally Posted by the sun fan

really!!!

normally, I am overwhelmed by how townie she is, and this hasn't happened at all this game

I am trying to discount that at least somewhat, she definitely isn't my top scumread (I'm voting them)

and yes, I know that this is at least somewhat how I'm trying not to play

but there have been like 3 instances where things swung the other way, where I've been like "hmmm" or "uhhh" to her posts rather than "wow, that's a great thought, that's so townie and well developed that I am impressed and inspired"

which I know is a high bar, but that's essentially where her town game has been for me in previous interactions in previous games

but like
ain't no way she should be a universal townread, she'd probably agree with that herself

I feel the same way. And there were some times when she was asking questions where I did not feel the genuine inquisitiveness which I would expected to feel from Star. Kinda more like paranoid vibes or grasping at every/anything to see what sticks