[roundbox]

all of ben's reasoning to me seems fair minus plop

while plop's proposal is information-forward, I don't think it goes more than roughly above null
-if plop is wolf, he would more than likely know the true composition of game 0. if he knows all are town from this POV, it doesn't matter what he asks them to do. the flip is always the same result.
-if plop isn't wolfing, then it's just a risk. it's not a game-ending risk. it was understood to hopefully give us information at the time, but I don't think town!plop would have ever seen that happening. more information does help town, but the point still stands he could reasonably make this from either alignment.

(got stuck on a phone call)