10-19-2015, 07:34 PM
|
#74
|
|
FFR Player
Join Date: Jul 2013
Posts: 117
|
Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open
Quote:
Originally Posted by misterkister
Bound Pod- "the song choice kind of kills the potential of a file like this having a lot of replayability. Difficulty of the file is also top-loaded, which isn’t necessarily a good thing."
Can you elaborate more on what's wrong with this song? Like is some part of the song need to be cut or is it straight up not acceptable for this pack?
Freedom Dive- You should've ignored that file because it can be compared with Caliber's freedom dive from Fullerene shift, but it was my fault for submitting it anyway.
Last Regrets (Freeform Mix)- Understandable. It's just as boring as Love is War simfile I made earlier.
Miracle 5ympho X- Something tells me I should stop submitting files on the song that's already stepped.
The End of the World (Unlimited Fear Mix)- 2nd revision has been submitted with the ending JS fixed.
|
Wafles might also comment on this, but Bound Pod isn't some sort of awful ear cancer or a bad file, however I don't think most people will find much replayability in it due to the kind of boring song choice, especially because we have another song in that genre already accepted. It's not one particular thing, and it's completely subjective, but that's just how we perceive it.
As for Miracle 5ympho X, I think you should resubmit it if you can take care of some of the more ridiculous difficulty spikes (the hard 32nd patterns in the speed-up are really excessive and could be smoothed out or changed to 24ths, as well as the one-hand trill stuff in the "machine gun" part). I'm not quite sure if it would end up in the pack, but I personally think there's enough interesting stuff in the full version to justify having it if the chart is really good.
|
|
|