[ilikexd]

Originally Posted by MarioNintendo

he's better technically than about 60% of the people I reviewed files for. That's something to be proud of..

or is it

Originally Posted by MarioNintendo

What I really, honestly think after playing the file, is that "it's a generic easy file". The only thing we could blame Middie of doing, except for trying to be stylish with 64ths (and to that I say, nice effort, even though it didn't have a good effect on me), is that his song choice was arguably playing it too safe. That's about as much as I have to write on the subject as a simfile judge

how is it generic? what other files are alike to shade besides alice's garden? not many, pretty much none, and certainly not enough to call it generic
a "generic" easy file is fine, it's not like beginners want to play technically complex stuff when they struggle to be accurate on single notes... feels like people are really missing the point of easy files