Flash Flash Revolution: Community Forums

Flash Flash Revolution: Community Forums (http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/vbz/index.php)
-   Critical Thinking (http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/vbz/forumdisplay.php?f=33)
-   -   No free will? A deterministic universe? (http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/vbz/showthread.php?t=9002)

Specforces 04-7-2004 07:45 PM

No free will? A deterministic universe?
 
An ongoing discussion among scientists is if the universe is deterministic, meaning that everything that happens is predetermined, from the creation of men right down to every letter I am typing right now. Stephen Hawking once spoke of the cover of this month's Vogue possibly already determined 15 billion years ago when our universe (supposedly) begun.

Let me start by saying that as a human being I refuse to accept that everything is pre-determined, or rather can be calculated in advance. But there are some disturbing facts that may confuse someone that believes this. When you use today's known science as a guide, something RANDOM doesn't really exist. It seems likely to say that throwing a die has a random outcome, which can't be predicted. However disturbing it may seem this really isn't true. What number is shown on the die is dependent on the start position of the die, hand and how the person's hand moves when he throws it. Even today it wouldn't be impossible to let a computer calculate what the outcome of the throw would be if the speed of the moving hand would be recorded and measured. This may be difficult but not impossible.

When you place a pencil on your desk with the point down, surely there is no way to tell which way it would fall? For a human not, but on a moleculair level it is just a logical process, a result of how you release the pencil and at which side the point is the thickest on the smallest level.

Computers themselves can calculate random numbers. Random? No not really, they just do a trick with the computerclock which works with milliseconds, impossible to be detected by a human, but still possible to calculate in advance. Which, in essence, is exactly what the computer does.

So is it possible to have something completely random, which can't be calculated in advance? I can't think of any example. The weather is too complicated to be calculated exactly by computers these days, but it is still a result of environmental processes.

If you ask yourself to think of a random number, surely that is random and can't be predicted? Well, somone else can't predict it, but the number you choose is still just a result of chemical processes in your brain. Which, if properly understood and computers would be a billion times more powerful, could theoratically be predicted. Assuming that God doesn't exist means that a human being is nothing more than a computer that we will be able to build ourselves in a thousand years. Our brains work with the same electrical principles as computers do, just way more complicated.

So how does an idea form in a human brain? Chemical and electrical processes determine which braincells are activated, of course in a different way for every single person because everyone's brain is different due to genetical and environmental forming of the brain. But still governed by basic physical rules.

Let's get down to the atomic level. How an electron jumps from one atom to another (electricity). When does the electron jump? Who decides when and how he jumps? Again, following today's science, that could all be calculated.

Today's research is fascinating, brainscans and the growing understanding of our brain, which is esentially run by chemical processes and electrons. Would mean that if we ever figure out how the brain works, that in a sense an electron would have figured out about itself how it works, because the researchers are human being with brains run by electrons themselves!

Assuming that the universe started with a big bang, the formation in the beginning was dictated by atoms and electrons and protons and smaller etc. moving to random places. Random? Well not really, because every particale has a reason to move somwhere, because it is attracted by an opposite charge or because it is given a certain speed. Immensly complex, because there are uncountable many particles, but still deterministic, because it COULD be calculated in advance, if given enough time and a powerful enough computer.

How an atomic particle moves is dictated by physics surely? What else? How does a particle decide to move which way? If it isn't dictated by initial speed or charges/gravity forces of surrounding particles, it would have to have a mind of its own or require divine intervention.

That is where the problem starts I think, to be able to calculate what happens next in the universe, which essentially should be possible, you wouldn't just need a behemoth of a computer. Computers themselves are part of and have influence on the universe as well, also run by electrons. I believe that the only "formula" or computer that could ever predict the universe, would have to be the universe itself. Because EVERY variable would have to be taken in account This would be infinitely complicated and could never be done if the particles that are involved aren't part of this supercomputer itself. This would fit well with the theory that if a global unifying all-explaining theory or formula would exist it would have to predict its own existence as well. The universe itself would have to be its own computer that could possibly predict, or rather run, itself.

Of course I have to mention quantum-mechanics, which says that certain thinmgs are only determined if you measure them. For instance you can only measure either the place OR the speed of a particle. To accept this you have to consider the possibily of paralell universums. There are experiments which show that some split particles have influence on each other, when you measure one of them, this influence seems to be intanteneous, which actually means faster than the speed of light. There are formulas that work, but still aren't understood. This is equally disturbing as a deterministic universe. Who determines the speed of the particle before it is measured? Actually another discussion, but connected to this one.

Well, this is all rather disturbing, because again, assuming God doesn't exist, that would mean that everthing is predetermined and we would be void of free will....

Specforces

perfect_fat 04-7-2004 10:54 PM

But if everything is predetermined, there is no way to know. Everything that you do is by your own free will in your mind, and that is all that matters. If you let an idea like this consume you and say, end up as a crazy homeless bum, but perhaps that was the will of the universe. It's a catch 22.

lightdarkness 04-7-2004 11:00 PM

Specforces, you continue to aww and amaze me.

How do you think of this stuff, you must have a killer IQ.

Ok, back on subject. I agree with what everything you say, but i dont belive that everything is pre-determined. Every particle would have to know what everyother particle is doing to know how its going to react in the future. I dont know if that made sence when I typed it, but it makes sence in my mind, can anyone else kinda elaborate on what im trying to say?

Well.. i know one thing for sure, i will never use the word radom in the same way, infact, ill try not to use it at all :)

RenmazuoGK 04-7-2004 11:08 PM

what stimulates the electrical and chemical processes which makes our brains think?

perfect_fat 04-7-2004 11:08 PM

You said it perfectly fine. But that's not really predetermination, that would be active processing. Predetermination implies our entire universe, every proton and neutron, is following a preassigned path. There may be no correlation between the actions of the protons and neutrons in the grand scheme of things, but that does not mean that the universe is not predetermined. This brings up the Pi question again. There is seemingly no method to Pi, but it does serve a purpose.

Anonymous 04-9-2004 05:40 PM

First of all, how does that bring up the pi question again? Second, Pi is merely a ratio of the diameter of circle to the circumference. You're making it sound like pi was just made up by some scientist or something when in reality, polygons with so many sides they look round were used to figure the ratio of diameter to perimeter (or in the case of a circle, circumference).

Sorry for getting off-topic, but perfect fat did bring it up first...

Afrobean 04-9-2004 05:47 PM

sorry peeps that guest there is mine. my stupid comp has a habit of logging me out without me noticing.

perfect_fat 04-10-2004 05:23 AM

PI IS THE ANSWER TO THE UNIVERSE!!!!!!

Specforces 04-10-2004 05:11 PM

Have you heard of PHI? That, is the answer to the universe. 1.618

Specforces

alainbryden 04-10-2004 05:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lightdarkness
Specforces, you continue to aww and amaze me.

awww..... :P it's awe

Spec that's some great stuff up there. I appreciate your consideration for the concept of God in the matter. Good and objective. As much as I beleive in free will, as in not being controlled by others, for me that doesn't deny the possibility that we are controlled by determinism. Really, really good topic. Your best yet I think.

And tell more about ths PHI stuff. So much more interesting than the old answer 42.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:32 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright FlashFlashRevolution