town
sunfan (I'm town I promise)

shadow god (I doubt I'm wrong; he feels very different, very happy to solve, if this was the potential that raeko left untapped by not really being in wolfchat to coach him, then that's a true tragedy.)

storn (man, I hope to god storn is a wolf this game. He's just posting SO FUCKING WELL and its not at all the storn we saw from his last game where he low-posted in danganronpa. if I see more solviness and more genuine-sounding posts, I might just lock him in as town for the rest of the game because its approaching a level where I don't want to look back)

H&H (obvious)

gold stinger (I guess that I will say for ffa's benefit that I have gold stinger as the lowest town in this tier. I think his wolf range is kind of high; I remember being wolf with him in a game where literally 0 people ever suspected him. The case that he has on antori making the wolfkill is /probably/ something he didn't make up as a wolf imo. The solviness is there to the level that I expect it. If I somehow knew that there was 1 wolf in my top-tier list of townreads I'd immediately be like "oh, its gold stinger then")

fg (she isn't posting like this as a wolf I don't think, the read is basically as simple as that.)

kinda town
devonin (this is more on DBP but DBP was playing exactly the same as in AN. Devonin is also kind of approaching the game in a similar manner to how I would expect from him based on some of our conversations about the game beforehand. My hesitation here extends from the full read of the thread that he did having opinions that I didn't really think were narrowing down who the wolves could be.)

roundbox (nothing clearing; his d0 pass is up. The way that he voted for Cocoa kinda gives me the heebie jeebies, but every now and then I read one of his posts and its like "yeah that was pretty good, good post roundbox")

soundwave (kinda unfair to not have him in the higher tier. His posts are good he clearly cares about the game it would take very, very little for me to bump him up to the top tier.)

funnier (I decline to elaborate.)

meh
Daikyi (i've never been anywhere near good at reading him. His opinions are his own this game, which I guess is like a single point in his favor but that's really it. First it was FF14, now its something else, just feel like he's never going to get around to contributing what I would expect from him)

Gradiant (i've also never been anywhere near good at reading him. A bit lower than Daikyi just because I don't really have anything positive from him that I can point to as being a lot more likely to come from town!gradiant)

Xel (the epitome of meh)

dafty (I like yaoi too my friend. Can I get some thoughts on the game tho)

would kill
ffa (I don't agree with the gs case at all; nothing redeeming outside of that)

antori (obvious lynch for today; probably the serial killer)

WV (He had a push that I really didn't like; don't remember what it was)

Hakulyte (SPICY READ but I think Cocoa was trying to signal to one of the wolves and I don't think it was Shadow God. I don't like Haku's shenanigans with Soundwave either. There's not quite the game solviness that I would expect either. I feel surprisingly ok with this read)