Post ur rejected simfiles thread

[kommisar]

How many times have u had ur fielz rejected from stepmania pack?????

I hav a lot. I'm only giving one example for each pack because I literally had 12 files rejected from smg1 lmao

Rejected from VGMP1 in 2006

Rejected from KBMP 1.5 in 2006

Rejected from SMG1 in 2006

Rejected from SMG2 in 2007, went on to be stepped by Kneegrow

Rejected from ODI2 in 2007, was originally accepted but glove took it out cuz it was too boring

I'm pretty sure I had a few rejected from vgmp2 as well but I can't remember which ones

[lurker]

second heaven (smgpack2) is forever missing, necros made a file that was loosely based on it
i may have gotten one other file rejected from a pack

[Celirra]

I'm planning to just submit a minipack of my rejected files in a few months once I have time to make them less suck ^^

[Buta-san]

a rejected songs pack where everyone submits files of songs rejected by other rhythm games would be cool.

[Arntonach]

[James May]

lmfao. I have too many to count...starting from Xoon 5 haha...

[storn42]

Originally Posted by Buta-san

a rejected songs pack where everyone submits files of songs rejected by other rhythm games would be cool.

but then you get that sad moment where your song gets rejected from a pack all about rejected files.

[GammaBlaster]

bunch of meme videos (STOP HATING JUSTIN BIEBER!, Nostalgia Critic Rage etc.) I stepped I lost years ago to a HD crash

and...

a few pop song dumps that got rejected from HSMP12 for not following to the music (one of them was iYiYi, which ended up on Hardpain of Hell and also pretty much the only rejected file I could recover)

[XelNya]

Mine's quicker to just list:

Entrance (Cytus version) (Apparently has ghost notes, but honestly I think the judge wasn't listening for the side beeps and bloops. If anything I actually missed notes.)
Beat Calls (Dump)
Battle of BRS (I subbed this to some anime packs and something else, I forget.)
Catastophie (Some pack that I think rebirth was doing the judging for.)
Opening (Really easy song, I think I sent this to stepping stones?)
Survival (Anime pack, I actually really like this file and play it frequently.)
Broadcast (Recent, it's an expirimental file, so I didn't have SUPER high hopes, but still kinda sad because it was fun to chart. XD)

I've never subbed this but I expect a practically auto-reject for being 7+ minutes long:

Madoka Piano Forte No. 1 (Scin did a LOT in terms of helping me sync this shit. Like, shit. He did an initial like quick sync and then I went back and adjusted it stupid precise.)

I don't sub stuff often because I'm a bit bad, and I have to actually like the file myself or I end up deleting it, and then I also just, can't play as much.

[MixMasterLar]

Like 90% of everything I have ever submitted has been rejected. It would be quicker to name the packs I actually got in


Of all of them I am most pleased I was in the OG Touhou pack. Sakura Sakura was a fun file IMHO. Gpop also did it for one of his years later and it's also really fun

[Arntonach]

Originally Posted by storn42

but then you get that sad moment where your song gets rejected from a pack all about rejected files.

I recall there being a pack as such on r21 freak a long time ago, and nothing was rejected. Didn't turn out badly either.

[dAnceguy117]

Originally Posted by kommisar

Rejected from VGMP1 in 2006

d'you remember if you were given notes for this? (the concept of notes may not have been invented yet)

that seemed to meet my criteria for the pack, which was being onsync and having some sort of consistent style. I may have voted it out due to being salty about the holds b/c I didn't play spread, rofl

[dAnceguy117]

god simfiles were really bad back then............

[blindreper1179]

Yeah, you judged them. Lmao

[blindreper1179]

Unlike back then, mine are always bad lol. Well 98%.

[kommisar]

Originally Posted by dAnceguy117

d'you remember if you were given notes for this? (the concept of notes may not have been invented yet)

that seemed to meet my criteria for the pack, which was being onsync and having some sort of consistent style. I may have voted it out due to being salty about the holds b/c I didn't play spread, rofl

iirc i got a note from macgravel saying "boo hands" so I reworked it to remove hands and then it still didn't get in lmao


i sent a v2 for that exact same file for vgmp2 and it still got rejected D:

[Fantasticone]

Full and unnerfed version of Day To Live rejected from Yolo Dumps for being too hard (That says a lot for what that pack has).

[lofty rhino]

Every technical file I've ever tried to get released has been rejected.

[IamMe90]

Originally Posted by dAnceguy117

god simfiles were really bad back then............

Really? i think there were quite a few goodies from the CKMP/ODI/PPP/VGMP etc series.

of course, back then there was a much larger emphasis on MAable files than speed tests. that's a personal preference that i still prefer, as the latter seems less conducive to an appreciation of the actual music (although, most songs in stepmania are garbage so i can see why a lot of ppl wouldn't care about that anyway).

i can't recall any files of mine specifically being rejected, but i'm sure there were more than one lol.

[hi19hi19]

I've had only a few files rejected from SM packs, pretty much only like five files from VGMP4 and that's it.

Now, rejected FFR files on the other hand...
Could make a "fun" pack out of those lol