Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[TC_Halogen]

@ bmah towards Move It Groove It:

- 53.33s,55.47s,etc.: is there really a distinguishment between these bursts? I can't imagine KaW deciding to vary between 32nds and a small polyrhythm; I'm fairly sure he'd make them consistent.

Haha, they actually are different! I checked multiple times myself because I'm a huge stickler about proper rhythms.

Also: towards Undiscovered Colors:

- 136.17s: doesn't sound emphasized enough for a hand

It's not really a huge emphasis on the particular sound itself because it isn't loud, but it's an echoed sound that is also the last piece of percussion in the song.

[bmah]

Ok, all notes, except passed and skipped files, have been posted.

phew

[TC_Halogen]

Undiscovered Colors: 9/9/8/8
Move it Groove it [Heavy]: 8/8/8/9
Into Your Eyes: 7/8/7/[x]

...waiting anxiously about that last one.

Also, Kayla and I didn't coordinate our charts; we just knew that one another were stepping the same song and knew that my chart was going to be considerably harder (don't quite agree with the note about the charts being too similar to be in game, because my chart is considerably harder).

[bmah]

Oh I know that you were working separately. I just wanted to justify why I gave one a 9 and the other an 8.

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by bmah

Oh I know that you were working separately. I just wanted to justify why I gave one a 9 and the other an 8.

Oh, I was referring to Sara's note, haha. It's not a big deal at all, to be honest.

[ichliebekase]

My issue with the two is that their core structures are identical. The only difference is the layering in heavy is obviously more difficult. It's something that happened in MLPFiM Heavy and Standard.

Ultimately, whether they both go in or not isn't my decision, was only my opinion, and I did judge them separately to keep it fair.

[Elite Ninja]

Blue Marine - [9,7,7,7] - 7.5
Ridorii - [4,5,7,5] - 5.25

No one complained about the length of Ridorii before I sent it in so I thought it would be fine =(

Any suggestions on the cut for Ridorii (talking to Carlos, Kayla, or Jeff)?

[megamon88]

Call Upon the Seaponies: 8 / 8 / 8 / 8
gPrOeWaEtRaFnUdL (Dave! Remix): 7 / 8 / 9 / 8
Lunatic: 8 / 8 / 7 / 9
Mozart on Crack: 7 / 6 / 7 / 9
Still Shy VIP Instrumental: 8 / 8 / 8 / 9

Pretty good batch for me :P

If anyone has any issues with my judging feel free to pm me about it. Looks like the spacing got a bit messed up though :/

[woker-X]

Yay at Zombie Killing accepted

*hi5 bmah*

[MarioNintendo]

wow I posted expecting someone to post my sig but apparently you guys are really too busy looking at the notes

D:

[FissionMailed1]

Originally Posted by megamon88

Call Upon the Seaponies: 8 / 8 / 8 / 8

Oh lawd wut is dis

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by ichliebekase

My issue with the two is that their core structures are identical. The only difference is the layering in heavy is obviously more difficult. It's something that happened in MLPFiM Heavy and Standard.

Entirely understandable - I personally don't have an issue with you saying that because it was something that Kayla was concerned about when we both started making our different charts, haha.

[.Gazelle.]

oh wow, did not realize how many jumps were missing

[YoshL]

electrolosys - 7.75
stuck - 7.5
oops - 7.25
tetris - 7

lol at the progression

[SKG_Scintill]

5, 6, 7, 8, how meta can you get a rate? go file!

[kommisar]

macau underground 9 7 8 6 [7.5]
twinkle of the stars 6 8 9 8 [7.75]
the big crunch 6 7 8 8 [7.25]
arsonist 8 8 8 8 [8]
infinity 9 7 9 7 [8]
leg tap 7 8 7 6 [7]


HAHA HOW DID LEG TAP MAKE IT IN


also arsonist had NOTHING changed and it got accepted this time with flying colors.


consistent judging hehu

[XelNya]

Pardon me, but I had sent a revised version of "La Tristesse Durera Toujours" into the e-mail shortly after I'd sent in my original submissions. The attachment to this post is a screen shot of the e-mail. I'm unaware of how a "fix" of this mistake would be handled, but I'd like to know if it could be done.

If you need me to resend the chart to the judges, I will happily do so.
Thank you for you time.

[ichliebekase]

Poundcake! - 6/6/6/7 - 6.25
Garden Party - 5/7/7/8 - 6.75

I definitely appreciate the notes on Garden Party especially, hopefully if it gets a borderline pass then I will fix it up. Poundcake I'm not surprised about, but I'm glad the song got a laugh or two. x] I was definitely going for notes this time since I'm trying to get back into the groove after taking a break for a few months. Thanks to all judges. :]

[.Gazelle.]

- attention to rhythm at 36.325 is really nice
- From s36.32 to s37.18 is all very wrong. Listen to it on a rate of 0.3 or lower.
?_?

[Razor]

8/8/6/6 on devilz staircase, haters............


also there were lots of good files this batch, pleasantly surprised. keep up the good work ^_^