FFR Community Pack 3

[gnr61]

yo judges
hows it goin

[AsphyxZero]

Yo let me judge for this since I'm not a flake lmao.

gnr, wanna collab on that song I posted?

[gnr61]

lol well, it's not really my cup of tea stepping-wise, plus i don't think i could do it without spamming x-mod shenanigans and that would be a lot of work D:

[AsphyxZero]

Yeah I want to throw x-mods all over the place but last time I went overboard and made Befriend a Child Killer Remix lmao.

[Korygon]

I'm not a flake. It's just tough **** at work right now. A lot of our new hires are ****, I just got promoted so I'm doing a ton more, and on my one day off I get pestered to do things.

Pack is kinda on hold till kommi gets internet back anyways.

[t-rogdor]

Originally Posted by AsphyxZero

Yeah I want to throw x-mods all over the place

Motherf- that song and xmods.

[gnr61]

i 4give u korygon. grats on the promotion
if anyone would have given me the files or even just the pack email info though i'm able to judge pretty consistently for the next few weeks =.=

[AsphyxZero]

I don't want to be a *** but I can judge consistently as well.

[Korygon]

sorry bro. Dimentio is the sole judge and executioner of this pack says kommi. =(

[Profraine]

I'm sure if you tried hard enough, you could be Dimentio too.

[Dimentio]

No more people inside of me.


DIMENTIO HAS SPOKEN

[gnr61]

get outa here

yes/no's based on random sampling of accepted files, obviously more in depth notes pending i'm just inarush


(Silvuh) A Place in Time - no =\
(Scylaax) A Showcage
(Gundam-Dude) Amaryllis
(Icyworld) Artificial Intelligence Bomb
(Xayphon) Clione
(Rogdor) Cocaine Voltron
(Kommisar) Computer Music
(Gundam-Dude) Crescendo - yes
(moches) Croqel part.2 - very yes
(Detrimentalist + 0) Disconnected HaZaRD - very no
(AsphyxZero) Do Back Burn - no
(bmah) EXTREMA PT.2 - god yes
(Xayphon) Fast Asleep
(Scylaax) Hiyayaka ICE
(Xayphon) In Love With You
(wc) Intermission
(Icyworld) Liberi Fatali
(Dimentio) Lunatic Gaze - no
(Rin-Dude) MENTAL MELTDOWN
(Yotipo91 vs Detrimentalist) My Crutch - bad song
(Kommisar) Nix-Tek
(Scylaax) Only my Railgun
(ddrace) rAAw Battery
(Wineandbread) Rambling Feather - PENDING
(haru-ko) Sequentia
(Gundam-Dude) Shoreline - yes cool song
(Scylaax) Snakeman Stage
(Rogdor) Song for Dead Malls
(Kommisar) Steel Bomber
(Wyde) The Black Monster
(Gpop) The Darkness Within Bits
(Scylaax) Tornadoman Stage - no
(Rebound) Witchcraft - yes (want fixes but fun)
(Dimentio) The Ultimate Show (vs. Super Dimentio)

i hv spoken

[danny53x]

Any deadline? I might try to make another.

[Silvuh]

Originally Posted by gnr61

(Silvuh) A Place in Time - no =\

Yeah, I asked for A Place in Time to be ignored ... I think they just wanted an easy file or something ... ? But yeah, I'm gon'na try to get something worth playing in sent before ... ... Okay, I really don't think I will be able to. I'll just make my own "Poopy attempts at SM files" thread when I can actually get some stuff done without worrying about a deadline...

Ederp: Okay, so I lied. I'm going to send my A Wolf In Sheep's Clothing solo file. If y'all like it, I'll do some graphics for it.

[Gundam-Dude]

Originally Posted by danny53x

Any deadline? I might try to make another.

Pending on Kommi whenever he gets internet (which will be by this weekend probably). Gotta discuss which files to pull out because that first post is nowhere near accurate. Pack seems about close to finishing though, just missing gfx and difficulty scale tweaking.

[sakura080789]

if you guys need graphics i can do that

[Korygon]

cool. raine is doing piktures for the pack too so just make sure ya dont do the same ones k

[t-rogdor]

Sent in 2 more files. Watch out for that rainbow trill

[gnr61]

first expanded notes

Lunatic Gays -
-pr is kinda gay but you might as well Get It Right with slow broken 8th notes (m8 etc. 3,23 not 3,12).
-medium-length piano holds seem utterly unnecessary throughout; propper patterning should accentuate these melody notes i think.
-192nds sometimes seem aidsy/unneeded.
-RANDOMLY PATTERNED SNARE FILLS DETECTED; in a file with long 16th jumpstreams it seems important to emphasize 16th fills as separate, try some jacks or right hand jump patterns.
-more bass plz
-not a bad file at all just sort of generic and the song might have more potential

Disconnected Hazard -
-review probably isn't very necessary but most generic/boring song choice possible and randomly patterned fast-percussion jumpstreams with 8th jacks no thanks

Amaryllis V2 -
-really cool file
-without headphones feels vaguely like a lot of invisible arrows but it comes together very nicely if you listen close
-nice bass 8)
-layering is mostly effective but maybe consider deviating for some accentuation snare jumps etc, chains of rainbow single notes going to different instruments is disorienting and can be inexpressive
-m21 seems like missing bass drum note, percussion is pretty prominent here
-fill around m24 i'm not sure i'm feeling; jack theory applies for those minijacks you have but both melody and percussion changes there so idk maybe mix it up/add some jumps or something
-m28 seems like those super soft chords just stopped being layered for a couple bars not sure if intentional
-everything past that is quite awesome imo

im going to move on to completely unjudged submissions before i go any further with the 'accepted' files since apparently those are going through an overhaul anyway

[Detrimentalist]

Originally Posted by gnr61

Disconnected Hazard -
-review probably isn't very necessary but most generic/boring song choice possible and randomly patterned fast-percussion jumpstreams with 8th jacks no thanks

Torrent chose song so blame him xd, P.S. it's a collab nice job telling me which chart you reviewed.