Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by Choofers

i'm confused, is this a dossar post or a halogen post

did you hear? roy's staying over at my place and in addition to having an amazing orgy, he's teaching me how to be narcissistic

i'm also becoming very well-versed in stepmanian lingo, drawing alphes, and vibrating fast enough to save a woman $15-$25

in all seriousness though: that was a generalized statement and overly emphasized

[Wayward Vagabond]

Originally Posted by psychoangel691

I said several times the people that JX and bmah chose aka the people that are currently on the team. The people that you don't trust to judge a batch. I don't see how I implied anything else.

"only qualified because there isnt anyone else left to actually fit the qualifications" doesnt mean "fits the qualifications"
this is the reason for my distrust.

[krunkykai22]

This whole thread is just getting ridiculous at this point. It's quite insane that this whole judging team thing is becoming more and more elitist by the MINUTE.

Just because you're on the main team of judging doesn't mean that you can do whatever you want whenever you want. There are DEADLINES. If you can't meet them, give notice or SOMETHING.

I understand if you got sick or hospitalized or a family member death (basically everything MarioNintendo said in his huge post), but when you procrastinate you just show this site and ALL of it's members that you really don't care about anything but yourself.

There are a lot of members that get excited for new releases, and some that get excited for their chart's judging to come in so they can fix what they can or get more excited that they made a great chart. Whatever the case is, as the judging team, you are responsible for the biggest part of this site, the game and it's songs in them.

If you can't show respect to other members by judging and keeping this site continuing on then you shouldn't be here period. Move along.

Procrastination should have a penalty on it. I'm not an experienced judge nor would I want to judge on this site due to what I've seen from "certain" people on here. It's a place that pushes others away because of the elitist attitudes.

And for shits and giggles, Carlos you aren't the god almight judge amongst judges. Enough with the trolling and get serious for at least one damn day.

EDIT: And the back-up judges do NOT need to meet YOUR damn qualifications. They need to meet JX and Bmah's expectations period. They are the game managers and the final word rests with them. If they bring in someone you don't "trust" get over yourself.

[TC_Halogen]

there is no "only qualified because there's no one left"

bmah/JX chose the people to be on the team because they're qualified to judge, and as non-head batch judges, we are all equally qualified REGARDLESS of how much experience we have.

[SKG_Scintill]

I'm Scintill, vote for me

[AlexDest]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

I look at simfiles all the time objectively and have a general idea of what fun factor is - therefore I'm a great FFR judge.

Your superiority is ignominious.

Stop attempting to say there's an objective way to view simfiles. It's inexistent.

[Wayward Vagabond]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

there is no "only qualified because there's no one left"

bmah/JX chose the people to be on the team because they're qualified to judge

theyre only qualified as judges because there -is- no one left. you honestly think ichliekjfnvd is qualified to be on the judging team? really? do you honestly think that.

[ichliebekase]

Originally Posted by Wayward Vagabond

theyre only qualified as judges because there -is- no one left. you honestly think ichliekjfnvd is qualified to be on the judging team? really? do you honestly think that.

Oh boy was I waiting for this.

If I wasn't qualified, then why did jx approach me to become a judge? If I'm not qualified, then why haven't I been kicked off the team? Oh, because, as you say, there's no one left. Welp, guess that sucks for you.

[Choofers]

equal opportunity

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by AlexDest

Your superiority is ignominious.

Stop attempting to say there's an objective way to view simfiles. It's inexistent.

I never said there was an objective way to simfiling as a concept, I expressed an overly dramatized statement. If KBO was still around, I could show you a post that I made about how there is no right way to make a correct simfile with plenty of musically relevant examples that no one was able to respond to.

There's nothing ignominious about saying that a simfile should have a structure, and I'm sure a lot of higher level simfile artists would agree. Regardless of what you think, that is an objective measurement. There's also an objective way to view simfiles in terms of correctness in rhythm and sync, so if you want to sit here and say THAT doesn't matter, then you have issues.

and Carlos: honestly, at least she goes out of her damn way to provide somewhat detailed notes. I won't sit here and say that I didn't question her being on the team at first, but she's done a ton of judging at ThirdStyle and her notes are helpful/specific. Having someone who at least provides plentiful notes to help a user is better than someone who writes one-liners that are like "yeah, file is ok [7/10]" since a user doesn't even know what they lost points for.

sorry, but if people are going to take things this way, then the judgment team needs to be restructured.

[psychoangel691]

Originally Posted by AlexDest

Your superiority is ignominious.

Stop attempting to say there's an objective way to view simfiles. It's inexistent.

Originally Posted by kommisar

I'm all for having people on as a learning experience, but I wouldn't throw them in as main judges. You may think of it as an "elitist" statement but I'd be concerned if half the judges thought 2 minute dumpstream files were the pinnacle of simfile making. To be a judge, one should understand how fun files are made. There is such a thing as an objectively good file and I don't think it should come at the cost of letting lesser quality files in game.

If there's a such thing as an objectively good file then it can be looked at objectively as well.



Anyway on all this junk, bmah and JX have final say on who stays and who goes. If you don't like someone being on the team say it to them and see what they have to say about it.

[Choofers]

I'm going to go grab a breakfast burrito.

If the drama is still continuing by the time I get back, I'm doing dramatic reading of random posts in this thread.

[Niala]

Originally Posted by Choofers

I'm going to go grab a breakfast burrito.

If the drama is still continuing by the time I get back, I'm doing dramatic reading of random posts in this thread.

I would like to see that.

[Xiz]

Originally Posted by Choofers

I'm going to go grab a breakfast burrito.

If the drama is still continuing by the time I get back, I'm doing dramatic reading of random posts in this thread.

Yes Niala, Me too!!

[MarioNintendo]

Guys if the backup judges make you so uneasy about the quality of the accepted files just send your stuff on time and we'll never have to ask them to do your part.

[megamon88]

Not bad for the middle of the day.

[Niala]

You know the batch notes are nearly up when...

[AlexDest]

[AlexDest]

plopadop for next judge

i'd like to read a novel review on my file anyday from you

[kommisar]

My point still stands that I wouldn't choose some of the people judging right now to be judging. If saying my opinion makes me a dick then so be it. It's not my decision but last I checked I can throw in my 2 cents. And yeah, I've seen some 2 minute DumpSTREAM files get higher scores than they deserved, but their opinion isn't mine.

I'd be willing to make a video on how to "objectively" judge/make Simifiles.