Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[iironiic]

Originally Posted by Xx{Midnight}xX

With this I ask this politely...

Then why are you even a judge?

I ask myself the same question :P

But at least the past few times I've judged has been somewhat consistent with the other judge's ratings, so I suppose "not knowing what I'm talking about" is an overstatement haha.

[Xx{Midnight}xX]

Originally Posted by Anaru

cause he's a simfile author and you're not

unless you want to count speedcore 300 as a good simfile

1. I actually wasn't trying to be a jerk about it.
2. You're just using a pair of biased lenses. If you look at the chart beyond the fact it's speedcore and it had a major bout of shit dumped on it the first time and actually looked at the chart you'd not say it's that bad.
3. It's honestly a fair question. If someone doesn't know what they're talking about or what they're doing they shouldn't be a judge.

[Choofers]

Originally Posted by Xx{Midnight}xX

1. I actually wasn't trying to be a jerk about it.
2. You're just using a pair of biased lenses. If you look at the chart beyond the fact it's speedcore and it had a major bout of shit dumped on it the first time and actually looked at the chart you'd not say it's that bad.
3. It's honestly a fair question. If someone doesn't know what they're talking about or what they're doing they shouldn't be a judge.

actually no, speedcore 300 was a terrible file and if I haven't deleted it, I could literally tear it apart and tell you exactly what is wrong with it

[Xx{Midnight}xX]

The chart you have would be before all the fixes.

[Choofers]

it's still probably a terrible chart

[Ziergdsx18]

o

[Anaru]

ps) i cant fc speedcore 300 therefore it must suc

>:C

[ninjaKIWI]

Originally Posted by Anaru

ps) i cant fc speedcore 300 therefore it must suc

>:C

Hopefully we'll get some files more difficult than a 4 from you this batch.

[MarioNintendo]

Originally Posted by iironiic

I ask myself the same question :P

But at least the past few times I've judged has been somewhat consistent with the other judge's ratings, so I suppose "not knowing what I'm talking about" is an overstatement haha.

... What? xD Come on, Wilson, I love you and all, but even I can see that the fact one is consistent with other people's ratings doesn't mean he's fair. You have to find better qualities than that

[AlexDest]

Originally Posted by Xx{Midnight}xX

The chart you have would be before all the fixes.

have u acquired the knowledge of how to step speedcore




111% doubtful

[Netjet!]

Oh hey what's going on in he-



oh

[i love you]

IMO this is how I see it:

Good FFR Judge: Someone who knows how to judge a file based on that person's stepping style. Someone who plays the file first before looking in the editor. Someone who base their judging more on fun factor rather then the file being technically correct. Someone who does not play favoritism and judges each file equally regardless of who the stepper is (I honestly think less people does this if not all). Someone who rates files based on reason rather then subjectiveness and someone who can actually step files well and know what they are talking about.

Bad FFR Judge: Someone who judges files based on their stepping style rather then the person who stepped the file in the first place. Someone who cares more about the file being technically correct rather then fun factor. Someone who can not step files well enough to understand what is truly going on with the file. Someone who gives bad ratings because of a few minor errors or that the song choice was bad in their opinion (notice that I did not mention about repetitiveness because that is a totally different factor). Someone who does not play the file first before looking at the editor and last but not yet, someone who accepts a file based on favoritism or because of the fact that the person is known to make good files. Just because someone is known to make good simfiles does not mean that every single one of their files is going to be great or considered an automatically accept. If you are currently an FFR judge who has this mindset, get that shit out of your head right now. Judge all files equally.

PS: Do not take what I said seriously. It is probably bad advice. (:

[AlexDest]

Originally Posted by Netjet!

Oh hey what's going on in he-



oh

AJs face is the answer for everything

[One Winged Angel]

Hypermidnite Industries

[TC_Halogen]

Back on topic, I'm actually excited for next batch - I should cap out at 4 files, but if my next file gets 2 points (18+), then I'll be up to 5. Crossing my fingers!

Right now, I have Crimson Flood, ERIS, Blackout (not quite done), Streams of Red and Orange (also not quite done), and hopefully, I'll have one of the latin songs that I found on newgrounds finished. I just can't wait for this batch to be over and done with judging-wise - yes, I still have quite a few files to judge.

[Anaru]

Originally Posted by AlexDest

AJs face is the answer for everything

it's so true..

[who_cares973]

Originally Posted by Arch0wl

just wanted to stop by and say http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jsz4L-IzQZo would be an incredible file, for FFR or otherwise

this is great

Originally Posted by hi19hi19

repetitive jumpstream/32nd roll dump, or understepped awkward 16th stream file

i invite someone to prove me wrong though, it is quite a nice song

i'll prove you wrong

Originally Posted by i love you

IMO this is how I see it:

Good FFR Judge: Someone who knows how to judge a file based on that person's stepping style. Someone who plays the file first before looking in the editor. Someone who base their judging more on fun factor rather then the file being technically correct. Someone who does not play favoritism and judges each file equally regardless of who the stepper is (I honestly think less people does this if not all). Someone who rates files based on reason rather then subjectiveness and someone who can actually step files well and know what they are talking about.

Bad FFR Judge: Someone who judges files based on their stepping style rather then the person who stepped the file in the first place. Someone who cares more about the file being technically correct rather then fun factor. Someone who can not step files well enough to understand what is truly going on with the file. Someone who gives bad ratings because of a few minor errors or that the song choice was bad in their opinion (notice that I did not mention about repetitiveness because that is a totally different factor). Someone who does not play the file first before looking at the editor and last but not yet, someone who accepts a file based on favoritism or because of the fact that the person is known to make good files. Just because someone is known to make good simfiles does not mean that every single one of their files is going to be great or considered an automatically accept. If you are currently an FFR judge who has this mindset, get that shit out of your head right now. Judge all files equally.

PS: Do not take what I said seriously. It is probably bad advice. (:

i take bribes does that make me a bad judge?

[Choofers]

choofers for ffr judge

[Ziergdsx18]

choofers for admin

☆ﾐ(o*･ω･)ﾉ

[hi19hi19]

Originally Posted by who_cares973

this is great


i'll prove you wrong

Sounds like techno dildo which is why I said that lmao

If you're going to make a legit chart make sure to also make a dumpy edit for your fans 8)