Video Game Collaboration

[Madokidoki]

SUBMISSIONS OPEN

Well, I'm a bit of a noname here, but I've always wanted to make a pack and whatnot, so here goes.

This pack is supposed to be a spiritual successor to all those video game megapacks and other such things. Here are da rules:

1. You're only allowed to submit things from a video game ost, remixes or trailers.
2. You may not submit anything from a BMS game.
3. You must have one single or solo chart.
4. Anything goes after that really. Feel free to step Touhou, japanese games, western games, and whatever else you want.

So this pack, if it gets submissions, might work like a filter for some other packs. If it doesn't, well whatever, I'm ok with that. I'll be the only judge, unless I get submissions and someone wants to help.

Anyone who doesn't have graphics will be provided some. I'm very willing to do graphics for anyone who submits. Also, any files that are from other packs are ok too, just as long as they follow the rules.

Depending on how many submissions I get, if any, this could be a minipack or a full pack. All that matters is I get SOME files. Remember, you can submit either 4key or 6key, either is fine, but I'd really like 4key charts, though any good solo chart is cool too. I'm just hoping to get maybe a little response before FFR Winter opens up.

Send file here: vgcsubs@gmail.com

SUBMITTED FILES:

Angel Island Zone (SSBB Remix) (bmah) [4k]
At Dawn (Profraine) [4k]
Besaid Island (emithith) [4k]
Condensed (Pw) [6k]
Dance in the Forest (Pw) [6k]
Duel (Seiba) [4k]
DUMP SUCCEEDED (INFORMATION) (Midi) [4k]
Final Boss (LongGone) [6k]
Frog's Theme (Midi) [6k]
**** Jason (Nai) [6k]
Ithavoll Building - Lower Floors (Profraine) [4k]
Jungle Japes (yotipo91) [4k/6k(?)]
Malevolent Mansion (TheForc3Within) [4k]
Over the Northern Mountains (Pw) [6k]
POP A PARADE -Part 1- (Profraine) [4k]
Sandopolis Zone Act 2 (Profraine) [4k]
Super Mario Bros. (TECHNO Remix) (Elite Ninja) [4k]
Traverse Town (Midi vs Nai) [4k]
Victory is Right Before Your Eyes (Diokatsu) [4k]

Files with Orange have no graphics set. You can make them if you're feeling cool! some of these have graphics that i might replace if i wanna. If you're file has graphics that you want to replace, just tell me!
ACCEPTED FILES:

Angel Island Zone (SSBB Remix) (bmah) [4k]
At Dawn (Profraine) [4k]
Besaid Island (emithith) [4k]
Condensed (Pw) [6k]
Dance in the Forest (Pw) [6k]
Duel (Seiba) [4k]
Extend Sky (Diokatsu) [4k]
Final Boss (LongGone) [6k]
Frog's Theme (Midi) [6k]
Ithavoll Building - Lower Floors (Profraine) [4k]
Jungle Japes (yotipo91) [4k/6k(?)]
Malevolent Mansion (TheForc3Within) [4k]
Over the Northern Mountains (Pw) [6k]
POP A PARADE -Part 1- (Profraine) [4k]
Super Mario Bros. (TECHNO Remix) (Elite Ninja) [4k]
Traverse Town (Midi vs Nai) [4k]
Victory is Right Before Your Eyes! (Diokatsu) [4k]

PS: check dis thread out Sargon my meng made a songlist gen so dope :')
http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...d.php?t=120979

[Madokidoki]

All reviews will be about the hardest chart, unless I say otherwise. I've played the other charts, just not gonna review them since most people will be playing the hardest or second hardest charts.

Condensed (Pw) [6k]

• Gonna judge the hard chart as the main, seeing as I'm not good enough to actually rate the oni as a player. Layering is consistent and the multiple charts are a godsend. Oni is a nice challenge as far as I can see and the chart is fun and the song is perfect for solo imo.

Accept

Dance in the Forest (Pw) [6k]

• I'm not a pro solo player, but I absolutely love chord/quad mash in single and solo. Great difficulty curve and fun song!

Accept

Extend Sky (Diokatsu) [4k]

• Refraining from judging since it's my own file. I'm gonna touch it up and what not. If there is Touhou stuff submitted aside from this, I'll probably pass on it since too much Touhou is...bleh.

Pending

Ithavoll Building - Lower Floors (Profraine) [4k]

• Bayonetta! Too be honest, this track is not exactly eventful, but I like the steps. It sowcases how stream and freezes can actually be used together. Reminded me of freezes in BB Evolution. Like it and good for the game diversity. Also, cool drum rolls!

Accept

Jungle Japes (yotipo91) [4k/6k(?)]

• Official judging after I get the solo file, but this is in. Great colored note theory and jacks. Only thing is I would've stepped bursts in other places, but the way you've done it at least add a little more diversity. It's nice to see a file that isn't using constant note smashing to compensate for lackluster steps.

Pending

Over the Northern Mountains (Pw) [6k]

• Reminded me of dondon's Rescue sim. Great chart, thick layering, fun to mash and fun to look at. Not much to say. Consistant file quality from you.

Accept

[TC_Halogen]

How long is this pack going to be open for?

[YoshL]

smgalaxy/portal 2 stuff coming from me probably soon

[Madokidoki]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

How long is this pack going to be open for?

For as long as I think that I'll still get submissions. For a realistic person, that will be about a little after FFR Winter opens up, however, I'll keep them open if submissions are still coming in and for as long as people need if they wanna submit something. So if anyone has a file they wanna try and complete, they can take as long as they want, barring it's like December when they finish.

And thank ya!

[TC_Halogen]

Sweet. I'll try to get some more Ace Combat music charted (nothing like Megalith, I promise).

[XxMidigamixX]

Sweet. Going to get something in for this. Is there a limit to how many files we can submit (to prevent it from having the pack filled with one person's files and whatnot)?

Also...submitting a 6k chart of Frog's Theme

EDIT: sent

[Madokidoki]

Originally Posted by XxMidigamixX

Sweet. Going to get something in for this. Is there a limit to how many files we can submit (to prevent it from having the pack filled with one person's files and whatnot)?

Also...submitting a 6k chart of Frog's Theme

EDIT: sent

Nope, you can submit a bunch of files, just depends on if you literally overload the pack. I think at like 6 submissions, I'll start to ween out your files even if they're good. I don't want a one simartist dominated pack, but I want as much as I can fit. And judging will commence as soon as I get a few more files for a new batch!

Background for Condensed. Pw said he wanted abstract BGs, so I tried to make some. If you want more similar stuff, make sure to ask and Profraine is also gonna make some.

[XxMidigamixX]

Alright. I'll try to finish the full version of Cirno's Hot Spring when I get on a comp that doesn't cause DDReam to lag like a bitch x.x

EDIT: Might be tempted to submit another file after Cirno's Hot Spring but who knows...

[Madokidoki]

Originally Posted by XxMidigamixX

Alright. I'll try to finish the full version of Cirno's Hot Spring when I get on a comp that doesn't cause DDReam to lag like a bitch x.x

EDIT: Might be tempted to submit another file after Cirno's Hot Spring but who knows...

btw I actually haven't recieved the frog's theme file

[XxMidigamixX]

oh crap...it does that every time with aol. is there a link in the email btw?

[Madokidoki]

Well, it's more like I haven't gotten an email from you lol. You can PM me a link as well or send it to diokatsu@live.com

[XxMidigamixX]

alright. lemme PM you the link. Don't know why aol is being a derp x.x
EDIT: PM'd you the link

[Madokidoki]

Don't even worry about it.

[XxMidigamixX]

got another 6k file to send woop \o/

[XxMidigamixX]

Any update? O.o

[Madokidoki]

wait for a few more submissions. keep em coming. 4key files would be nice.

[XxMidigamixX]

Alright.

Edit: Sending Traverse Town [Piano version]; might be Tempted to do 3rd Mov.: Riku ~Scherzo e Intermesso~ and Last Battle (From Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga) both by Yoko Shimora

[Madokidoki]

Ok so got some subs:

**** Jason (Nai) [6k]

• I'm sorry, but this file is virtually unplayable. Being a little liberal with layering is fine, but you can't just throw down stuff I'm sorry. 32nd trills on my mid and ring might be cool, but they're not consistant and don't always fit the music either. 6key can be nice, but I'll notice the lack of layering so much more.

Reject

POP A PARADE -Part 1- (Profraine) [4k]

• It might just be me, but this is one of your best files that I've ever played. The polyrhythms and the sheer difficulty makes it fun and it's just a dope and happy as **** song.

Accept

At Dawn (Profraine) [4k]

• Fine file, fun and fitting and the freeze usage is pretty distinctive of your files in this pack. Not as good Pop a Parade, but still pretty great.

Accept

Sandopolis Zone Act 2 (Profraine) [4k]

• Ok, so I do have a problem with this file: can you just remove the freezes in the second half? It'll just change things up since it repeats and make it less repetitive. If done, will definitely accept.

Pending

Traverse Town (Midi vs Nai) [4k]

• Despite this being a better 6key song than 4key, you should try stepping more 4key. It's easier to fudge the layering if you're new. On that note, I'm gonna accept this, but you need to layer a little bit more consistently. Try going through the file and mapping just the main melody and then make jumps with the drums, background piano, synths, whatever is in the song you're stepping. It's a bit easier and you'll be able to see how the song builds up. Nice colored notes though.

Accept

Frog's Theme (Midi) [6k]

• Despite layering issues, the song is great and even if it is just a mash at some points, I had fun playing it. This file might be amateurish, but it's a great song and a fun, if not overstepped file. Just fix up those freeze issues and it'll be in.

Pending

[XxMidigamixX]

Originally Posted by Madokidoki

Ok so got some subs:

**** Jason (Nai) [6k]

• I'm sorry, but this file is virtually unplayable. Being a little liberal with layering is fine, but you can't just throw down stuff I'm sorry. 32nd trills on my mid and ring might be cool, but they're not consistant and don't always fit the music either. 6key can be nice, but I'll notice the lack of layering so much more.

Reject

Traverse Town (Midi vs Nai) [4k]

• Despite this being a better 6key song than 4key, you should try stepping more 4key. It's easier to fudge the layering if you're new. On that note, I'm gonna accept this, but you need to layer a little bit more consistently. Try going through the file and mapping just the main melody and then make jumps with the drums, background piano, synths, whatever is in the song you're stepping. It's a bit easier and you'll be able to see how the song builds up. Nice colored notes though.

Accept

Frog's Theme (Midi) [6k]

• Despite layering issues, the song is great and even if it is just a mash at some points, I had fun playing it. This file might be amateurish, but it's a great song and a fun, if not overstepped file. Just fix up those freeze issues and it'll be in.

Pending

Thanks for the feedback. I actually intended Traverse Town to be an easy piano file (Also, there's isn't really that much to layer since it's the piano version) and yeah, **** Jason was shit -_- (despite lowering the rate to hear some obscure sounds in the background. I wasn't really that satisfied with how it came out...). And I'll reduce the 32nds in another chart and scrap the freezes in the main chart for Frog's Theme.

Edit: Just finished scraping the freezes that went along with the 32nds and made another chart without the 32nds for Frog's Theme.