Keyboardsmash Phase I: Legacy Submissions Open

[choof]

sending file

[choof]

pls respond

[James May]

Pelican Moondance (Choof)
Beginner - Accept
Shit...this is brutal. Aside from clusterfuck of colours, if I didn't look at the cdtitle or who stepped it I would've thought ji stepped it for a second just by how many colours there were rofl.

Bleeding In The Rain (Rog)
Beginner - Accepted
Accurate chart, the 32nd jacks aren't that indicative of any difficulty issue as the solo compensates for it imo. Not sure how the others would see it but the file is fitting for the length and its pleasant to play albeit the solo is a bag of skittle lmao.

Super Hey Ya (MrTea)
Heavy - Accept
I kinda want to see an easier js file in here to be fair. Song is catchy and its not everyday where you get a simple js file that's not icyworldnbjs kind of stuff. Nothing too erroneous but the intro did make me lag a bit but that might be because of the bpm or the comp.

[stargroup100]

gonna finish off the new charts once I restart computer but I just decided to play one before that and felt I had to review

Pelican Moondance (choof) - It has that Robotomy flavor to it. I'm digging it. Like Robotomy, some parts are especially brutal, but I'll let these slide because I'm really liking this new style of charting and I want to see it developed a bit more before critically refining it. Accepted

[choof]

I could definitely touch up the chart, I had loads of fun stepping it and would have no issue looking at things to fine-tune.

[t-rogdor]

Originally Posted by choof

I could definitely touch up the chart, I had loads of fun stepping it and would have no issue looking at things to fine-tune.

how about you let me ddream its asshole and it'll really be robotomy-esque

[stargroup100]

Super Hey Ya! (MrTea) - The beginning is really cute. Overall, I feel like you picked this because you really liked some of the fun riffs and effects, but you didn't really know how to treat the rest of the song. The parts where you did follow riffs and effects were done really well and are incredibly fun, but the rest of it just feels bland and repetitive. Especially in the chorus, I don't know what those miniholds are going to, and they even alternate between downbeats and upbeats, which confuses me. Figure out how to make the majority of the chart more interesting and it's a yes for me. Pending

Bleeding in the Brain (rog) - Should've indicated that I should play the Beginner chart or get rid of the Easy chart before submitting. Anyways, pretty solid, I generally have no problems with it. Only thing I would mention, and fixing this is minor issue, is that the one measure with 32nd minijacks is significantly harder than the rest of the chart. I personally have a strong general preference for charts that don't have inconsistent difficulty spikes. Accepted

a whole bunch of numbers - no I didn't even bother opening this folder don't waste my time

[DefTeaMachine]

the mini freezes go to the high hat/down symbols

[stargroup100]

Originally Posted by DefTeaMachine

the mini freezes go to the high hat/down symbols

Ah ok, I don't know how I missed that. Anyways, my personal suggestion would be to make these holds shorter so they're not as distracting.

[Rebirth0]

Ok back from a weekend trip. I will get to judging some files this week. I'd like everyone else to also (Kommisar, GD, lurker)

[choof]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CD84vPHAQyQ

about 2 minutes into a chart for this, may cut the intro or make a short cut to release as a preview
more art files ahoy

[Darkbreezee]

Originally Posted by Rebirth0

- Dark Chancellor Packs are about quality. If you're going to step a song, you need to do it in a way where after you're done, you truly believe that your file is so good that nobody should ever have to step that song again.
- I will however go against that rule at times and allow jumpstream/dumpfile submissions. If the chart makes sense and it is fun to play, and if it would actually make the pack better, I'm all for it.

So its not a dump-pack, thats promising =)
really looking forward to it

[DefTeaMachine]

ur pretty cute

[Pompompulin]

When this posting will be updated?

[choof]

where notes

[lurker]

amatias v2- last month i sent a pm to ghakimx explaining some problems i had with the changes in the new chart. there hasn't been a revision since so this remains a pending
atropos (rcaliber's)- mother of god this is great. this better not get rejected because it's sm5 only nvm
catastophie- kinda doubt you're actually going to fix this properly (you fixed maybe two of the piano flourishes and nothing else that was apparent)
danger danger- incredibly inconsistent and uninteresting
hakugin no datenshi-
timestamps because that v0 mp3 makes me sad
8.572-8.878: drums are quite clearly 24ths, not 32nds
14.617: missing note
37.194-37.959: there's definitely something more complex going on here than you're suggesting
51.123: missing note, fix it the way you did at 76.847
the ceiling could never hold us- thank you for stepping the generic hihats and/or completely ignoring the rhythm of the much louder synths in m. 141-170 otherwise i'd have to look through a lot more of this file. i'm not a fan of 7 minute long files that have nothing even possibly interesting happen until the 5 minute mark
warhead- no

now i have to download some stuff

edit:
we luv llama- "the entire first chorus section has an unbroken 8th right arrow anchor" -anonymous
bleeding in the brain- i'm guessing the easy chart isn't supposed to be there but the novice chart is really fuckin good

[choof]

where pelican moondance

[DefTeaMachine]

lurker is gay

[DefTeaMachine]

tfw ceiling gets rejected/pending votes cuz no one wants to take the time off of their busy schedule to play a 6 minute file.

Also i have nodie what you are going on about with the hats thing i dont even hear any lol

Well the file is obviously trash so into cringefest it goes smh

[choof]

Originally Posted by Rebirth0

Ok back from a weekend trip. I will get to judging some files this week. I'd like everyone else to also (Kommisar, GD, lurker)

lol