MOVEZ (IT'S OUT THIS THREAD IS DEAD)

[MooMoo_Cowfreak]

I see Lurker has been doing lots of shitposting recently so Imma just chill on this, didn't mean to fuss up the thread by feeding the troll

[James May]

Just giving more feedback to files.
Sensation
Hard
17.899 (and repeating occurences): the 32nds are intermittent when you can hear the 32nds cascading throughout this part, either layer them accordingly or remove the 32nds entirely in this section.
66.879: Because in this section you left the 32nds off completely despite haveing them sparsely placed in the previous section, hence the suggestion of removing the 32nds.
73.802: I would say that this is off by a 96th, should belike this

74.841 to 88.802: The drums and the snares are barely layered in it, I know that you are going for the guitar mainly in this song but personally, if you want to go that route, either place the snares as mines to accentuate it or empty it.
88.802 to 94.341: Same issue as the section in 17.899 & 66.879.
147.764: missing note here at the end of the piano trill, I think some of the notes on that trill might have been a bit off but I'll have to check it out in DDReam to do so since I'm using Arrow Vortex right now, but I am definitely hearing a key on that spot.
148.033: Missing note.
157.399, 157.456, 157.514: Ghost notes, the holds itself on 157.341 is sufficient on its own.
163.533: Misisng note to accentuate the string.
165.187, 165.245, 165.302, 165.360: Not hearing the emphasis on those four notes.
167.437: Should be shifted down to 167.476.
168.052 & 168.110: Misisng notes
173.149: Missing note
183.187 & 183.418 (with other instances): Okay...you layered the drums on certain parts, but there were other spots like these two notes that needed the jumps to accentuate the kicks. Check the layering. Also, 185.149 isn't a jump, that should be shifted up to the 8th on 185.033.
186.995: Hand isn't needed here, no sound signifying it.

In all honesty, I loved the file, I really do, just need to check on those sections for the consistent jumps/hands usage.

Choco Love
Hard
3.025: Jump should be on 3.056
6.025: should be on 6.056
9.025: Same here fam
23.978 & 24.002: Ghost notes
27.025: Hand
36.400: Should be a freeze and not a triplet tbh, conflicts with the roll on 36.587
54.330: Would suggest removing the mine here
54.400: Clarification on the quad?
55.525: Hand
55.806: Hand
56.087: Would say hand but the flow on this part would feel bleh lmao
56.791: Remove mine, would feel that players might get mine meme'd, but that's your choice, since I'm partial to staccatos x.x
62.556: Ghost note
64.361: Bump down to 64.408
68.556: Ghost note
69.025: freezes aren't warrented here excet for the vocal
71.275: Oh god this irks me a lot, here's how it should be

72.869: Forced minijack ruins the flow, also remove the 48th on 72.806
74.369: Same as the one on 72.869
74.712: Burst starts on here, followed by another note on 74.775
136.712: Should be 32nd burst here.
75.775: Same as 72.869
102.025: Clarification on quad?
102.400: There are instances where the jumps here aren't emphasized and aren't needed to be honest.
103.525: Same as above, double check the jump placements.
171.025: Remove the mines, its a bit of a dick move xD
201.048: Shoft that mine a bit lower, people might get mine meme's here
-Gonna go through more later, it's already 1 a.m. here lmao-

[lurker]

Originally Posted by MooMoo_Cowfreak

You mention in your original post that packs like ODI 3, Untitled SM Pack, and FFR CP 4 are viewed as, "an anemic, half-hearted mess that no one in the intended audience will rate highly, and everyone outside of that audience will ignore because it is simply too easy." Please cite anyone who has voiced this opinion. As someone in the intended audience, those are three packs which I in fact quite enjoy and play regularly. ODI 3 might just be my favorite pack, actually.

very few people actually bother with those nowadays

Originally Posted by James May

Okay, can we move this elsewhere and gear our focus back to the pack.

please don't try to shield yourself from criticism i might actually report you if you do it again

Originally Posted by MooMoo_Cowfreak

I see Lurker has been doing lots of shitposting recently so Imma just chill on this, didn't mean to fuss up the thread by feeding the troll

this is just straight up dodging the issue

[leonid]

ok this is definitely a joke sry lurker i'm kinda slow at this

[lurker]

i honestly do not believe i have cared more about the direction stepmania is heading in than i do now

[James May]

Originally Posted by lurker

please don't try to shield yourself from criticism i might actually report you if you do it again

Then do it :T You've contributing absolutely nothing to this pack so you have no right to say squat in anything in regards to the fate of this pack :P

[lurker]

yeah i totally should've knowingly contributed to the continued oppression of newer stepmania players and charters before i started talking shit
being a hypocrite is way cooler

[Jousway]

I know he is fucking trolling but this topic interests me

like lurker, my 2 cents, if you really care, stop fucking complaining and host a beginner stepper pack, pce

like it doesnt have to be exactly you if you think you're not up to it (kek) but llike someone could basicly make a pack with slightly lower standards and more explained judging to teach new people to make files yo, might be fun :V

[lurker]

Originally Posted by Jousway

like lurker, my 2 cents, if you really care, stop fucking complaining and host a beginner stepper pack, pce

like it doesnt have to be exactly you if you think you're not up to it (kek) but llike someone could basicly make a pack with slightly lower standards and more explained judging to teach new people to make files yo, might be fun :V

my opinions will not help anyone feel more integrated into the community and neither will anyone else's with a join date before 2014

[Jousway]

Originally Posted by lurker

my opinions will not help anyone feel more integrated into the community and neither will anyone else's with a join date before 2014

so we should let soul evens host the pack hahahhahahahahaha

nah man who is going to teach deez kidz if no one of the older comunity with actual EXPRESSIVE step knowlage teaches them

[lurker]

expressivemanias are a social construct
new players do not need my validation to make expressive files

[Jousway]

Originally Posted by lurker

expressivemanias are a social construct
new players do not need my validation to make expressive files

so they shouldnt learn how to make fun patterns, not use invisable notes, and layer sounds properly, do you want QED files all over again? damn lurker wat up with ya

[leonid]

guys you really should argue this elsewhere but i mean what if people actually like hitting invisible notes? I also put them sometimes... make whatever you feel is fun

[James May]

Originally Posted by Jousway

so they shouldnt learn how to make fun patterns, not use invisable notes, and layer sounds properly, do you want QED files all over again? damn lurker wat up with ya

He has a secret fetch for QED files obviously~

Anyhow, let's shift this back to the pack. I'll give more feedback on Sunday, going to a Halloween party tonight and tomorrow I'm closing so Sunday I'll be going through more stuff

[sunn0glasses]

doooof james mayne, i'll keep workin on choco love til its good and well, but i'm tired of editing it right now lol. however! if u have notes for hack the club, hit me wit dat B-)

[James May]

Finished doing more feedback on Choco Love. Will tackle more tomorrow since I have to close tonight

[t-rogdor]

hey i changed my mind and Please Don't Remember can be in the pack, i'm one to talk about ghost notes and ExpReSsIve bullshit when I made like half of robotomy. it's a good file lmao

[James May]

Originally Posted by t-rogdor

hey i changed my mind and Please Don't Remember can be in the pack, i'm one to talk about ghost notes and ExpReSsIve bullshit when I made like half of robotomy. it's a good file lmao

Alrighty. I'll fix it up in a jiffy. Just got home from work

[dadcop2]

Originally Posted by t-rogdor

hey i changed my mind and Please Don't Remember can be in the pack, i'm one to talk about ghost notes and ExpReSsIve bullshit when I made like half of robotomy. it's a good file lmao

i can go back and look at it again to make sure it's all accurate, but i wasn't actually even going for expressiveness. the 192nds are following the really quiet synths in the background.

also, do u have any notes for up the bum no baiiiiibeez?

[sunn0glasses]

the deadline for fixes is this friday, right?