TWG 191: Don't Trust Your Mentor - Game Thread

[Duskfall]

Subaru is busy working a lot is that normal

[flashflash account]

Originally Posted by Duskfall

Subaru is busy working a lot is that normal

last I remember he was mega afk, or got shot night 1 as a PR
he's a relative newcomer

[SubaruPoptart]

Originally Posted by flashflash account

last I remember he was mega afk, or got shot night 1 as a PR
he's a relative newcomer

In most of the games I've played, I've been inactive as I didn't know what to do and social anxiety screwed me over as I was overthinking what I wanted to say. I was killed night 1 a lotta times, modkilled in one of em, the last game I genuinely strived to try to do stuff for, killed night 1 and yeah. This is the longest I've lived in a game I think.

[Duskfall]

Originally Posted by flashflash account

last I remember he was mega afk, or got shot night 1 as a PR
he's a relative newcomer

He did another post like it yesterday on me

Its just a whole lot of quoting and not a whole lot of content but it can come from a newbie town too so I can't really scumread him on that I guess

[SubaruPoptart]

Oh yeah the one wolf game I played Shadow got killed and I panicked and got myself nae-nae'd.

[SubaruPoptart]

Originally Posted by Duskfall

He did another post like it yesterday on me

Its just a whole lot of quoting and not a whole lot of content but it can come from a newbie town too so I can't really scumread him on that I guess

And how do I really produce "content"? Cuz in all honesty the only thing I know about reads are to quote stuff, and give kinda like, general statements about how I feel about em.

[SubaruPoptart]

I'm super trying I'm just a lil lost in how to do so

[flashflash account]

Originally Posted by Duskfall

He did another post like it yesterday on me

Its just a whole lot of quoting and not a whole lot of content but it can come from a newbie town too so I can't really scumread him on that I guess

while I don't think I've seen him make posts like these, I don't think it's something he could only do as town, or even close

[flashflash account]

Originally Posted by SubaruPoptart

And how do I really produce "content"? Cuz in all honesty the only thing I know about reads are to quote stuff, and give kinda like, general statements about how I feel about em.

hmmm

[flashflash account]

Originally Posted by SubaruPoptart

From this, I'm rolling a town.

Despite the fact I've played with them before, I can't really remember or deduce their playstyle into my reasoning, yet they've been consistent with their reads and how they consider the roles of the people he's deduced, so that's why I'm rolling town.

my biggest problem with this is that the takeaway just feels... disjointed from the rest of the read
it doesn't take into account the duskfall-fg-me interactions he seems to have focused largely on
and I think that means the read was forced

[Duskfall]

Subaru you are summarising the game a lot rather than trying to read and solve it from what I see. It just kinda feels like you are going "this is how a read looks" rather than actually trying to make a read.

[Duskfall]

Focus less on what happened focus more on why it matters

[Duskfall]

That being said rn I'm voting Subaru or xelnya today

[SubaruPoptart]

Originally Posted by Duskfall

Focus less on what happened focus more on why it matters

OK that makes a lot of sense- keepin this in mind here on out

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by flashflash account

okay, lemme backpedal a bit
the way that I'm reading her is kind of the same as reading backpack atm
I found their D2s very comparable
for FG, it was specifically her disliking duskfall and the way she was approaching it (even though I think she's totally wrong) that I think a wolf just never thinks of

backpack is the same way, sometimes he follows logic trails that I just think a wolf isn't capable of

does that make more sense?

Following logic that a wolf wouldn't follow is standard reading

I think the fact you couldn't answer my questions regarding her reads makes my case for me.

[flashflash account]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

Following logic that a wolf wouldn't follow is standard reading

I think the fact you couldn't answer my questions regarding her reads makes my case for me.

I think it's a good way to "catch" town
just like the opposite is a good way to catch good wolves

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by flashflash account

I think it's a good way to "catch" town
just like the opposite is a good way to catch good wolves

it's literally how you're suppose to read most, if not all, people

[flashflash account]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

it's literally how you're suppose to read most, if not all, people

?

there's a lot of ways to read people
and I don't think literal confirmation bias is really how you're "supposed to" :V

[flashflash account]

wolves are just going to win this game because they get to lurk while town tears itself apart smile

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by flashflash account

?

there's a lot of ways to read people
and I don't think literal confirmation bias is really how you're "supposed to" :V

You're saying you compared her content to DPB's not because of content but because the logic was something wolves wouldn't follow on that situation.

But that applies to everyone , in the sense that if anyone did something you wouldn't see them doing as wolf then you would read them town

So there's no reason to directly compare to DBP.

Basically what I'm accusing you of is pretending Funny has more content then she actually does; you avoided reading her for half the game (Funny = TWGma in your earlier reads) and now that you have to read her you don't want to look foolish calling someone town when you couldn't name their top 2 town's at this stage.

Bring back in that you would clear her over Trevor, who actually has done shit and is doing shit now, and your stance is absurd