★★Sam and GG's Megapack RELEASED!★★

[NFD]

Originally Posted by NFD

Why would you have a tournament with dumps?

__

[kommisar[os]]

dont make me pull the mad card...

[who_cares973]

Originally Posted by GG_Guru

@Gundam-Dude: Maybe you didn't get the picture but..

And If you're gonna do a review at least try to be a little more open-minded? because our intentions were not so that each file is synced to perfection but the idea was to get it to match the rythm as close as possible.

i thought sync and pattern choice and flow was part of making the file match the song

This is not the FFR Batch, you're not even a judge. Do you have any files in the game? No.

rofl wow you must have pretty low expectations if you think stuff that gets into ffr is top of the line.

So before you start pre-determining crap maybe you should look on the bright side of this pack's purpose, to have fun. We cannot stretch that enough, nothing more and nothing less.

usually a fun file means its done right ?_?

Originally Posted by stargroup

hey guys dark chancellor expert here

I have a phd in rhythm simulation and I have been doing critical analysis of files my entire life

this pack sucks bye

lol

Originally Posted by Izzy

How good a stepfile is, is a pretty subjective thing. You can't tell someone they did something wrong because that's not how you would have done it or that isn't how you think it should be. You can't bash a file for the lack of originality or creativity. All of you people who think you are the shi"t at making simfiles need to get off your high horse and screw off. It isn't something you want to be an elitest dick about.

majority rules

Originally Posted by GG_Guru

I understand the motive but what ticked me off was Gundam's "I'm not gonna play this it's probably gonna suck" post because that's just plain ignorant.

dumps are rarely fun to play

In my point of view you can't really judge your opinion based on the first few songs you tried out then just assume that the others are crap, right?

if 7-8 files in a pack suck then chances are the rest are going to suck too

I agree some songs are poorly stepped and this was our first pack so I can't really ignore that fact.

saying that its your first pack is no excuse for having poorly stepped files. there's a sticky that explains what you should take into consideration when making a pack but apparently i once again had high expectations for you.




also saying the pack is only for fun right after being told the pack sucked is like drawing a ****ty picture and calling it abstract art

EXAMPLE IN CASE YOU ARE A VISUAL LEARNER

you:i drew a picture ^_^


everyone: it looks like ****

you: it isnt **** its abstract art =/ jeez

[kommisar[os]]

i thought it was a lightning bolt striking behind a pair of ass cheeks at first but then saw it was abstract art thus it has to be awesome

[TC_Halogen]

Packs and/or threads like this are the reason why I think 4-panel sucks. Nothing against you Guru, but:

1.) Dump files are retarded and the advocated their creations are just dumb.
2.) They aren't masterful in anyway whatsoever.
3.) I like playing accurate files. This is why I play Solo all the time and play 4-panel almost never.
4.) Listen to any Dark Chancellor in this thread because they are telling you how it is.

Etc.

[kommisar[os]]

solo rulz thread ruined.

[A2P]

I haven't made a simfile in a while

[TC_Halogen]

Also, I just realized that this is in the wrong place (should be inside the simulator files forum).

[Izzy]

Originally Posted by who_cares973

everyone: it looks like ****

you: it isnt **** its abstract art =/ jeez

I think it looks like crap, but then again people pay a lot of money for painting that look like total **** to some.

[GG_Guru]

lol who_cares you're awesome

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

Packs and/or threads like this are the reason why I think 4-panel sucks. Nothing against you Guru, but:

1.) Dump files are retarded and the advocated their creations are just dumb.
2.) They aren't masterful in anyway whatsoever.
3.) I like playing accurate files. This is why I play Solo all the time and play 4-panel almost never.
4.) Listen to any Dark Chancellor in this thread because they are telling you how it is.

Etc.

You're right about one thing, accurate files are fun because they make more sense. Most people dont like playing dumps because it depicts the song's "true rhythmic pattern" but we still went ahead and combined all our files on this pack knowing that fact because because other people would enjoy playing them. (Take midare's megapacks for example) We already knew most of these would get a bad assessment, in fact it was already pre-meditated. We're not looking at accurate stepping, no. If we wanted that we would have made way better files than the ones in this pack. Charts that actually follow the beat note by note without adding any extra color notes. We didn't want this to be a "Dark Chancellors" pack at all and if you were to compare both, if that that was the case then yes these files do suck but that wasn't our plan. I agree with everything you're saying but with a different perspective know what I mean?

[Gundam-Dude]

I was gone the entire day so I haven't had time to post earlier when you directed comments towards me.

I'm only giving you my opinion on your files speaking from my own personal experience as a step artist. Sure, I may not be a Dark Chancellor, but that does not mean that I can't give you some honest and constructive criticism. I'm not just a random step artist either. I'm pretty well known for submitting and judging for the Xoon packs, if you have doubts towards any of my judging. The way you're interpreting my reviews are far too personal since you're classifying my review as "trolling" and "time wasted". Be glad that I actually spent time and effort to download this pack and go through the files. Originally I was just going completely ignore this (e.g. see my very first post in the thread).

That's all I have to say to you. In regards to any other of your thoughts or comments regarding my review, I honestly don't care. I gave you my 2 cents. Whether or not you agree with any of it is completely up to you.

[who_cares973]

stop trying to cover up the fact that you suck at stepping

[EAGAMES]

Originally Posted by kommisar[os]

i thought it was a lightning bolt striking behind a pair of ass cheeks at first but then saw it was abstract art thus it has to be awesome

I saw that, too.

[GG_Guru]

Okay guys I'm finishing up the thread right now further details will be explained tomorrow afternoon. G'night.

[Nullifidian]

Originally Posted by GG_Guru

Most people dont like playing dumps because it depicts the song's "true rhythmic pattern" but we still went ahead and combined all our files on this pack knowing that fact because because other people would enjoy playing them.

LMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAOLMFAO
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA I can't help but laugh at this.

True rhythmic pattern my ass. You just suck at stepping and are trying to cover it up.
You think we won't see through this? What do you hold us for?
That's an insult to our intelligence basically.

Also, do you even read what you write? I see many errors in this part alone, and so many contradictions in your entire story, which brings me to the following:

Originally Posted by GG_Guru

We already knew most of these would get a bad assessment, in fact it was already pre-meditated.

Kind of contradicting with the last part I quoted isn't it?

"Nice try though."

Originally Posted by GG_Guru

If we wanted that we would have made way better files than the ones in this pack. Charts that actually follow the beat note by note without adding any extra color notes. We didn't want this to be a "Dark Chancellors" pack at all and if you were to compare both, if that that was the case then yes these files do suck but that wasn't our plan.

Don't make me laugh. Even if you did "decide to step seriously", the files would suck ass.

And saying you didn't want this to be a Dark Chancellors pack is implying you have the potential to make one, but just didn't want to, which is the LAMEST BS excuse ever and a poor cover up for how bad the files in this pack are.
Even if you did try, you wouldn't come anywhere close as a dark chancellor pack.
Like, no competition at all.


Last but not least, it seems you try to use alot of fancy words and "complicated" sentence structures.
Doing that means you're either:
a) Smart (lmfao)
b) Covering up the lack of intelligence by making yourself "look smart".

I think the latter.

[jimerax]

well you guys here're tips for being less dumb.

(to reviewer)
Yes you have right to post any critisisms (not flaming) here and constructive critisisms should
be thankworthy. You may get pissed when files you play suck or authors don't listen to you, but
stop posting here anymore when you realize further argument is useless.

(to pack author)
You don't have to take all of those critisisms here, but don't flame those posters/reviewers.
also, when you get decent critisisms at least try to get better if you're going to make another
pack in future.

thanks.

[GG_Guru]

Thanks jim. ^.^

[Mollocephalus]

jimerax's perfectly right, i guess i am too acustomed to ODi's reviews. kil jumping out of nowhere saying your file is pizza/10 is common bacon.