High FGO Special Batch [Sep 2015]

[Xtreme2252]

I thought I sent in a Frictional Nevada chart at the end of September.

[DossarLX ODI]

Originally Posted by Xtreme2252

I thought I sent in a Frictional Nevada chart at the end of September.

Yes, it's in Phase 2 of this batch. The update on the Batch Search Engine says Sep 30, 2015 9:24.

[DossarLX ODI]

Notes for Set 3 in Phase 1 have been posted. Concerning Set 2, I have provided reviewer judgments 4 out of the 5 files in that Set with one file stepped by me, and that file awaits a reviewer judgment from a different veteran judge. OWA already gave lead notes for all 5 files.

Results for Phase 1 Set 3:

Accepted
3 SAP - [9/10] Maybe All This Time I Was Wrong {The Flashbulb} (YMIA & Halogen)
2 SAP - [8/10] You're gonna love my nuts {Reizoko Cj} (gameboy42690)

Conditional Queue
2 SAP - [8*/10] You Universe {Blitz Lunar} (hi19hi19)
1 SAP - [7*/10] Stress Free Style {MOSAIC.WAV} (Scintill)

Rejected
[4/10] shit palette 2.0 {goreshit} (HeZe)

[gameboy42690]

Originally Posted by You're gonna love my nuts notes

I’m wondering why “with” wasn’t stepped in the very beginning, but “slap chop” was.

Because it's not intended to go with "slap chop", but the other sounds playing at the same time as "slap chop". :P

[AOD_ELEMENT]

it will be nice next September when this batch comes out

[SKG_Scintill]

[7*/10] Stress Free Style {MOSAIC.WAV} (Scintill)
...
General note: the 12ths in this file are 198 BPM 16ths for reference
...
Maybe want to tone down the meme notch just a tad at the end

Not fixing the ending. Climax theory on a FGO (Shrooms what)

Apart from that,
since the v2 in Set 4 is exactly what the general note says (the same file, but quantized at 198 bpm), perhaps I can send the fixed v1 (woke up an hour ago, fixed now) to replace that one?

[DossarLX ODI]

I'd like to give a reminder that there is a process for handling reviews on CQ'd files.

RATING APPEAL
In the event that a stepartist feels a review for a file is unfair, a civil response to the lead and veteran judge can be provided with the concerns through either a PM or sending an email to ffrsubmissions. A file’s rating can only stay the same or be improved through this process. Disrespectful behavior from either the judge or the stepartist will result in a small loss of SAP. If after discussing with the lead and veteran judge the stepartist still feels a concern, a request can be made to a different veteran judge. Details from the review must be provided with adequate explanations. This policy only applies to files currently in Conditional Queue or for files that were Rejected with at least a 6 rating or Resubmission Privileges.

On that note, please do not fill the batch threads with review comments.

[SKG_Scintill]

oops

[DossarLX ODI]

Notes for Set 2 in Phase 1 have been posted. A Batch Search Engine Update will be coming later today.

Results for Phase 1 Set 2:

Accepted
2 SAP - [8/10] Dysnomia {YZYX} (DossarLX ODI)

Rejected
[5.5/10] Hyper-INF-LATiON {cosMo@Bousou-P feat. Hatsune Miku} (SonicX.)
[5.75/10] LE6!ON - {Frums} (Lambdadelta)
[5/10] My Wolf Eats Preps {Renard} (YoshL)
[5/10] The lost {midoriA} (hi19hi19)

[YoshL]

expected that from wolf eats preps and i'm half glad that it's not going to be in ffr lol

dysomnia is an awesome song though so A+

[SKG_Scintill]

sent resub of Stress Free Style, not sure if I was meant to

[hi19hi19]

Originally Posted by DossarLX ODI

[5/10] The lost {midoriA} (hi19hi19)

rip in peace

btw I still promise to do High-Priestess fixes and the rest of my CQ'd files the moment finals are done.
I'm really excited to do You Universe fixes, I am glad to see that file was received well.

[One Winged Angel]

[DossarLX ODI]

Phase 1 in the High FGO Special Batch is now complete.

The reviews for all 6 Sets can be found in the Batch Review Thread. I've merged the results from Sets 4, 5, and 6 to prevent quadruple posting. The BSE will be updated with these results soon.

Results for Phase 1 Set 4:

Rejected
[6.5/10] Mondo Brutale {Komprex} (hi19hi19) - eligible for rating appeal
[4/10] Parousia-LAST JUDGEMENT- {xi} (YoshL)
[4/10] Ultraviolent Junglist {Venetian Snares} (DarkZtar)
[2.5/10] Resistance 8 {Pyongyang Hardcore Resistance} (HeZe)

Other
[PASS/10] Stress Free Style v2 {MOSAIC.WAV} (Scintill) - v1 is the focus instead.

Results for Phase 1 Set 5:

Accepted
[8/10] oppIrish(GYPSYCOREremix) {cybermiso} (gameboy42690)

Conditional Queue
[8.5*/10] Epileptic Crisis {Nightmare} (ilikexd)
[8*/10] Breath After Breath {Craving} (hi19hi19)

Rejected
[5/10] DIST SQUAD {Dj Sharpnel} (ItsOnlyDanO)
[1/10] Apocynthion Drive {HertzDevil} (DarkZtar)

Results for Phase 1 Set 6:

Accepted
[8/10] Grind4 {Dev/Null} (rog)

Rejected
[3/10] VEC†LEGGENDARIA {Rotteen} (gold stinger)
[3/10] Onset {Bexarametric} (Mourningfall)
[2/10] Corporal Jigsore Quandary {The Berzerker} (mi40)

As far as Phase 2 is concerned, I'll see if One Winged Angel is available to provide some more lead notes to start as he did the majority of them for Phase 1.

[t-rogdor]

hell yeah baby

[ItsOnlyDanO]

I kinda realised after i sent in dist squad the walls were pretty dumb

Might just make them 32nds and re-work some of the files in other areas and just send it in normally

[Wayward Vagabond]

Rog killing it

[DossarLX ODI]

One Winged Angel told me the earliest he'd be able to do lead reviews for a set in Phase 2 is Tuesday (and I'll be busy next week anyways), although I could see a Phase 2 set being finished next weekend. This week and next week happened to be a very busy week for me so I had to stick to mostly planning.

[DossarLX ODI]

Chiming in to say that Sets 1 and 2 have Lead Notes. I'm planning on doing Set 1 first and then Set 2 this week.

[DossarLX ODI]

Notes for Set 1 in Phase 2 have been posted. A Batch Search Engine Update with these results will be coming later today.

Results for Phase 2 Set 1:

Accepted
[8/10] cold (Kurorak's Bootleg) {Kurorak} (hi19hi19)
[8/10] Punkture {dDamage} (DossarLX ODI)

Conditional Queue
[9*/10] ElectroMashcore {Reizoko Cj} (gameboy42690)
[8*/10] Powerflux {YZYX} (GammaBlaster)

Rejected
[5/10] A.Q. Children [Cut] {t+pazolite} (hi19hi19)