[psychoangel691]

Originally Posted by VisD

I wasn't actually commenting on whether it needed work or not or saying that it didn't need work; in fact I haven't opened the file yet since I got the notes. The point was the contradiction (*which I found to be frustrating), not a judgment on either side particularly.

But when pointing out the contradiction you're acting as though it was one person saying it was good and one saying it needed work when there were two people saying it needed work. The whole reason for having multiple judges is because someone may notice something someone else doesn't.