View Single Post
Old 01-9-2009, 12:12 PM   #14
Tasselfoot
Retired BOSS
Retired StaffFFR Simfile AuthorFFR Veteran
 
Tasselfoot's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Widget Heaven
Age: 40
Posts: 25,184
Send a message via AIM to Tasselfoot Send a message via MSN to Tasselfoot Send a message via Skype™ to Tasselfoot
Default Re: Batch Review Thread

Code:
1/9/09

The Queue
Chaoz Fantasy - V4N - accepting under condition of fixes
Chaoz Japan - megamon88
Cryosleep - Patashu - 32nd triplets might be overdone for difficulty of the file, but they are consistent throughout
Dying Flame - SulferDragon
Ievan Polkka - jx - some of the 16th jack sections seem overdone
Inside the Fire - dore 
J'ai Envie de Plaisir - Patashu - technical, sure...  nobody else feels this is a dump?
Jeanie and Caroline - kommisar - definitely needs a final note or two
Kyrie - jx
Largiloquent Dithyramb - dore - one of the worst songs and song names of all time.  maybe cut ending?  it's longer than my schlong.
Marisa Stole the Precious Thing - classic rocker - on condition of minor tweaks
Nebula - kommisar - agree.  maybe missing some notes.
Nitrx - V4N - meh
October - Xandertrax - conditional on fixing some burst patterns
On Conquest and Capture - dore - on condition you drop the 48th and 64th notes that make hands.  not needed for this file.
Perfect Cherry Storm - Spitfire - seems overlayered to me.  Is the 24th jumpjack needed?
Pulling Through - blu
Schmollbluk - Spitfire
Streets - Xandertrax - pretty repetitive.  some jacks annoying as hell.
Tricky Concert - Xandertrax - SDP.  Teh Tricky Techno vEasy.  Check sync.


Files Played By Tass But Not Queue'd
Blue Betrayal
Boss Battle 1 - what they said
Bouff - will be a fun file
Bus rides with people - too much climax theory on ending
cloud control - cut and fix
devour - what judges said.  file is almost fun.
down but not out - cut.  look into layering/rhythms.
elements of a party - song cut and YNS
happy dreams - seems overlayered
impulse - fix up judges stuff...  cut?
midnight shooter - fix up missing notes
off the wall - layering at end of piano.  layering near end overdone?  around 1000 combo
pulling through gamma - wetodid
push - i waited about 30 seconds for notes.  none came.  quit out.
rain - this song really sucks.  jacks, few spots w/ 12th jump bursts, ending spins.
rose at nightfall - really boring.  some weird patterns w/ 32nds.
skeletor - long song is repetitive.  hell hell long rolls.  combo'd 1st megaroll!
slow down - i hate you and this ****ty file.  fix ending down jack.
thinking different v2 - really fun...  still a bit of work though.
twelve - fix up.  will be fun.
up in the air - fix up a bit.  only major right hand bias i noticed was in the 24th gallop section near the end.
yorukumoryuu - 48th bursts.  16th jump-glut-spin-bursts.  cut?


jx's notes
{The Traveller} (silvercomet1525) [? / 2]
offsync, PR could be better

Adrenaline FX (DJAirWave) [? / 3]
rhythms/jump placement are inconsisent/weird at parts

All I Ever Wanted (DJAirWave) [? / 2]
offsync at parts, many misrhythms, awkward patterns overall

Black and White (Silvuh) [+? / 5.5]
inconsistency in layering (snares)
weirdness on color notes

Blasted By Bubbles (MooMoo_Cowfreak) [? / 3.5]
missing notes, misrhythms(esp 24ths are out of place), PR could be better

BLUE BETRAYAL [Oni] (Patashu) [+. / 7] (12)
no comment, go for a file w/ highest notes

Boss Battle #1 (SulferDragon) [+? / 5.5]
patterns on m31, missing notes at the end of m47
PR is partially ok but could be better on other parts

Bouff (Patashu) [+. / 6.5] (9)
16ths with are a bit odd but fit the music I guess
rhythms on m64?

Bus Rides With People (kommisar[os] & bluguerrilla) [+. / 7] (11)
fun, felt some parts are a bit overdoubled though

Buzzards (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+? / 6]
it has some misrhythms, and patterns on 64th long bursts should be fixed
minijack placement is a bit random

Chaoz Fantasy (CyclopsDragon) [? / 4]
missing some rhythms, PR could be better

Chaoz Fantasy (Vote4Nixon) [+? / 6]
some patterns/rhythms(missing some 16ths, ending 4th) could be improved

Chaoz Japan (megamon88) [+. / 6.5] (9)
not bad actually, 8th jump section is a bit boring for me tho

Cloak Steppin (HighAndr0id) [+? / 6.5]
ONS could be avoided, misrhythms on m16, m40-, m55m etc.
the concept is fun though

Cloud Control (Vote4Nixon & championanwar) [? / 5]
somewhat PR but could be better, misrhythms on 24ths
song is kind of.. repetitive.

Colossus (Silvuh) [- / NA]
multi difficulty

Cryosleep (Patashu) [+. / 7] (7)
decent, rhythm's accurate

Cutthroat (TC_Halogen) [+? / 6.5]
enjoyable, but rhythms could be more accurate/consistent. 
is the last burst needed?

Dad (danny53x) [- / NA]
no file

Decipher(x3Fallen) [? / 3.5]
kinda inperfect rhythm/layering

DeVouR (Xandertrax) [+? / 5.5]
getting accurate but still gay, needs more jump removement/pattern fix

Dizzy Division (unkdavar) [? / 2.5]
way too inconsistent overall

Down But Not Out (_.Spitfire._) [? / 4.5]
inconsistent in layering, a few misrhythms

Drift (Silvuh) [? / 3]
wrong bpm (it should be 8th/16th based), misrhythms due to that

Drop (OperationStrawbarry) [? / 4]
PR could be better, 16th jumps at the middle are kinda bad.

Dying Flame (SulferDragon) [? / 5]
rhythms on m22-26 don't make sense imo. others are fine but a bit boring.

Elements of a Party (dore) [? / 5]
funny but music is way to repetitive (need songcut), also a bit inconsistent

Elfin Pirate (Redsky139) [? / 4]
misrhythms/offsync at parts, some burst patterns, layering could be better

Fantasty Impromptu (Quasar889) [-- / 0]
quit out after I saw legendary patterns on beginning (aka NoVa PuLsEr).
plus in most of the time arrows don't go with the music

Forgotten Aura (kjwkjw) [? / 3.5]
rhythms for drums aren't done correctly, and inconsistent

Game Boy Fiend (Vote4Nixon) [- / NA]
withdrawal

Half Symphony (Vote4Nixon) [+? / 5.5]
jacks could be more instrument/pitch relevant

Happy Dreams (HighAndr0id) [+? / 6]
good sync, PR and layering could be better on some parts

Higan Retour -idling mix- (Knoobish) [? / 3.5]
could be layered more correctly overall, most hands aren't needed, PR

HoH (Heaven or Hell) (trumaestro) [? / 3]
fairly offsync at parts, didn't like the layering style much

HOT PEPPERZ (NSane) [- / 0]
wrong bpm

Ievan Polkka (Rin&Len ver.) (JX) [# / NA] (10)

I'm A Maid (NSane) [- / 0.5]
BNS, misrhythms, random patterns/jump placement

Impulse (ClAsSiC_RoCkEr) [+? / 6]
overall decent, jump placement at parts, misrhythms on m38/42, notes for guitar on m103-104?
4 minute rock is long in general

Inside the Fire cut (dore) [+. / 6.5] (7)
ok PR, felt a bit underlayered at parts tho

Introsphere (Extended) (Vote4Nixon) [? / 4.5]
has some incorrect/inconsistent 16th rhythms, notes not very audible things
also needs better layering in some parts (voice part was interesting tho)

J'ai Envie de Plaisir X2 (Patashu) [+. / 7] (12)
in m38- putting jumps on all BD looks ridiculous even though they are technically correct (also patterns)
ver accurate file tho

Jeanie and Caroline (Kommisar[os]) [+. / 6.5] (11)
fun file, a bit repetitive/some bursts are weird tho

Kyrie (JX) [# / NA] (11)

Land of Eternity (SulferDragon) [? / 4.5]
PR could be better, misrhythms on m19, 35, 51, etc

Largiloquent Dithyramb [dore] [+? / 6]
almost no change from previous one other than gap

lolhappy (HammyMcSquirrel) [? / 4]
song is repetitive, better layering on 8th/16th stream sections

Lunar Dial (Vote4Nixon) [? / 3.5]
misrhythms/missing notes on many parts, PR/layering could be better

Marisa Stole the Precious Thing (ClAsSiC_RoCkEr) [+. / 6.5] (10)
minor PR/layering fix could be done, but overall decent. ps this needs awesome bg flash

Midnight Shooter (TC_Halogen) [+. / 6.5] (11)
some long 8th jacks are annoying, missing notes/PR could be better at parts but ok

Mitsudomoe Motion - Triangular Fight (i love gabba vs. Frozen Beat) [? / 3.5]
pretty inconsistent, misrhythms,  some jacks/16ths are going for nothing

Mr. Heat Miser (HammyMcSquirrel) [? / 3.5]
unique rhythms but offsync and misrhythms at parts, layering could be better

My Holiday Dinosaur (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [? / 4]
felt every section is way too repetitive

Nebula (Kommisar[os]) [+. / 7] (10)
there're some misrhythms(48ths) and missing notes, but enjoyable file

Nitrx (Vote4Nixon) [? / 4.5]
felt first half is underlayered, and missing notes even with this layering

October (Xandertrax) [+? / 6]
rhythms are followed well, jump placement could be better, some burst patterns are awkward

Off the Wall (bluguerrilla & Vote4Nixon) [+? / 5.5]
first stream pattern could be 6842 instead of 4268, some minijacks don't fit the pitch
m41- is too simple without layering piano

On Conquest and Capture (dore) [+. / 6] (8)
short song, some rhythms of grace notes don't feel right though

Peacemaker(Darkstalker_X) [? / 3]
p.inconsistent, misthyrhms, PR could be better

Perfect Cherry Storm (_.Spitfire._) [+. / 7] (11)
technically ok

Pulling Through (bluguerrilla) [+? / 6]
Pulling Through Gamma [dore] [+? / 6]
basically the same except for bpm, m25- understepped, also missing some bursts that could be fun

Push (Vote4Nixon) [+? / 5]
I think this is technically ok, but boring due to the song

RAIN (_.Spitfire._ & bluguerrilla) [+. / 6.5] (9)
really hate ending 24th spins (should be better stream patterns), but overall ok

Rose At Nightfall (SulferDragon) [+. / 6.5] (9)
maybe ok file except for some PR issue

Schmollbluk (_.Spitfire._) [+. / 6.5] (12)
kinda long and seems some parts are overdone, technically acceptable for a hard file

Science Party (Coolgamer) [? / 2.5]
pretty inconsistent in rhythms/layering, PR could be better

Secret Zombie Room V2 (unkdavar) [? / 4.5]
not too bad for the consistency, but it still could be layered better/harder

Skeletor (psycho & bluguerrilla) [+? / 6]
rhythms on m42, some roll streams could have better patterns imo, want song cut

Slashfic (OperationStrawbarry) [?]

Slow Down (Xandertrax) [? / 4.5]
those jacks are ok except for the ending down ones, and apparently layering could be better

SM 64 - The Alternate Route Remix (megamon88) [? / 4]
green notes on m21? felt really long, also some parts don't flow too well

Starfox Speed Mix (CosmicRain) [? / 5]
a few PR errors/misrhythms, didn't like jump placement much(melody, jumpstreams)

Streets (Xandertrax) [+? / 5.5]
seems technically ok, just not the best layering choice/jack placement

Sunset Dept. (CyclopsDragon) [+? / 5.5]
song is cool, but there're many misrhythms so they could be fixed for accuracy

Swallowing an Avalanche  (New Mix) - Bynary Fission

The Final Hour (silvercomet1525) [? / 4.5]
not wrong, but PR could be better, weird layering

the Mooned Incects [sc979] [? / 5]
PR could be better, 24th+48th bursts are weird, want some layering

The Swarm (MooMoo_Cowfreak) [? / 4]
overall inconsistent, jump placement. PR somewhat

Thinking Different V2 (Silvuh) [+? / 6]
interesting at parts, but some 48ths/64ths aren't really needed

TizAshura (Vote4Nixon) [? / 3]
felt it's missing a lot of rhythms

Tribe Attacker (alexdestructions) [? / 2]
misrhythms, bad hand/jack placement

Tricky Concert (Xandertrax) [? / 3.5]
offsync, tweak the bpm, PR could be better

Tricky Concert_(dandandamdandan1111) [? / 2.5]
offsync as well, worse layering/PR

Turbulence (AG Hi'per Mix) - Bynary Fission [? / 3.5]
layering for drums is quite inconsistent, PR issue/could have more minijacks technically

Turn Soonest to the Sea [Oni] (MeaCulpa) [? / 4]
offsync at parts, some bs rhythms, missing 32nds on m16-

Twelve (TC_Halogen) [+. / 6.5] (9)
missing some rhythms, barely ok file

uNdEr YoUr BeD_(dandandamdandan1111) [? / 3.5]
kinda funny but felt missing a lot of sounds, PR could be better

Up In The Air (HighAndr0id) [+? / 6]
interesting file, but there're some misrhythms/missing notes, inconsistency

V.L.S.I. (woker-X) [? / 2]
pretty inaccurate rhythms, jack placement

Versatile (CosmicRain) [? / 2.5]
layering could be better, bad jack placement

Voyage 1969 (Zybanthia) [? / 5]
PR is decent at parts, could be better at parts
layering for drums (esp. m49-) could be more consistent

Wish (Reprise) (HammyMcSquirrel) [? / 4.5]
maybe getting better slowly but still inconsistently layered 

Xxxperiment_(dandandamdandan1111) [? / 3]
I don't get some 16ths and jumps, overall weird

yorukumoryuu yamikaze [sc979] [+? / 5.5]
32nds like m24- aren't needed, also similar 48th bursts are weird. PR could be better overall

Mouch (robertsona) [? / 3]
pretty boring even for an easy file

Science Party (Coolgamer) [? / 2.5]
rhythms don't feel right, inconsistent

ska ska and again ska (ahr2nd's Omegka Prologue Mix) [robertsona] [? / 3]
repetitive as hell

Swallowing an Avalanche  (New Mix) - Bynary Fission [+? / 5.5]
most rhythms seem fine, some jack placement is weird


blu's notes                                             
Adrenaline FX (DJAirWave) [?] {2/10}
_
. You could step so much more in this song if you wanted to...
. The layering choices were weird, first snare, then BD, then it fell apart, no feeling of good progression
. PR was not there

All I Ever Wanted (DJAirWave) [?] {3/10}
_
. Stop creates BNS = a no-no, copy and paste to fix
. Then YNS in the slowdown lol
. You need to step more of those 24ths in the drums
. Overall it's pretty ok how you stepped it but you missed some stuff in the ending that you had been stepping throughout
. Ending might be more fun if you put jumps to all the vocals

Black and White (Silvuh) [?] {4/10}
_
. Overall, this file is pretty meh
. The fast rhythms and jacks were much harder than the rest of the song, felt choppy and uneven in difficulty
. M30-40 or so I couldn't even tell what some of the steps were going to
. m58-59 those colored notes make zero sense
. I don't even know how you'd fix this file

Blasted By Bubbles (MooMoo_Cowfreak) [+?] {5/10}
_
. m18, m42, m58, m91 should be no 24ths (should be 16ths)
. m21 needs some 48ths
. m29 make that trill a roll
. m40 should be 24ths into that 48th burst
. m83 should be 32nds not 24ths i think
. last green note should be a down step
. Overall missed 16ths to hihat and some BD, go through IT ALL at .5x and just watch the steps go by to catch what you missed

BLUE BETRAYAL [Oni] (Patashu) [+] {jx/10}
_
. Missed sounds and it's overdoubled
. Ok let's [heavy] please
. hell yea


Boss Battle #1 (SulferDragon) [+.] {6/10}
_
. Overall ok, didn't like the jacks to snare but did like the jacks in the stream
. ending might be more fun with the 'guitar' or whatever put to jumps
. Not a lot technically wrong, just was kinda meh to me

Bouff (Patashu) [+?] {6/10}
_
. The 16ths to weird keyboard noises were okay I guess, played kinda weird, can't hear it really well at 1.0x, 
..also they should sometimes end in a yellow note
. Could have stepped some of the drum bursts like m17
. Some sections felt overdoubled, like during solo, singles would play better
. hihat could be stepped, felt weird to hit have a step on those quarter notes
. m62 guitar noise at the beginning a 16th
. m64 missed sounds in guitar

Bus Rides With People (kommisar[os] & bluguerrilla) [#] {fun/10}
_

Buzzards (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?] {5/10}
_
. m5 64th unnecessary
. 32nd jacks please n
. Probably no 12ths or 24ths or 48ths in this song anywhere, probably all 64ths like DaD
. m30 64th burst ends too early
. This would be more fun with fewer jacks

Chaoz Fantasy (CyclopsDragon) [>] {4/10}
_
. Not as good as v4n's, though fun

Chaoz Fantasy (Vote4Nixon) [+.] {6/10}
_
. m48 would play better as (24)3.3(14) instead of (24)323(14)
. m56 (24)312(34) fits the PR better than what you have
. Some of the stream could have better PR but meh

Chaoz Japan (megamon88) [+.] {7/10}
_
. m59 should go (34).123.31(24) not (34).12323.(34)
. m61 should step the crashes, so it goes 4213.243.2.3 instead of 42.3.2.3.2.3 <- if you want
. And the ending crash echo too <- if you want
. fun file

Cloak Steppin (HighAndr0id) [?] {4/10}
_
. m16 make that trill at 4231 roll
. m29 don't like that first 2121 or those other rhythms there, should go to that echo-y sound
. m33 don't like that 32nd jack
. m74 should have some jumps on yellow notes
. PR at the very end could be better
. Overall overdoubled, imo
. Also, some of the rhythms, especially 32nd trills sounded like they weren't exactly that rhythm

Cloud Control (Vote4Nixon & championanwar) [+.] {6/10}
_
. Parts like m37 not sure what that yellow jump is going to
. m65 missed violin 16ths
. Ending needs better layering, in fact, you either need to cut it at 86.05 or continue to step the song because
..as it is now, the cut sucks, +. assumes you cut the ending

Colossus (Silvuh) [+?] {2/10}
_
. bpm is off by like .1-.2 or something
. overall boring because of the song choice, I know it's an easy sim but still

Cryosleep (Patashu) [+.] {6/10}
_
. Don't like the 32nd triples because of PR (BD-BD-BD+snare just doesn't play right as a triple/minitrill/whatever you call it)

Cutthroat (TC_Halogen) [+?] {4/10}
_
. long blank ending waaay boring, cut it before those 3 jumps please
. Overall, needs more grace notes and much better PR

Dad (danny53x) [?] {3/10}
_
. Sent old dwi???
. This file would be much more fun without jacks
. Jump placement weird at parts
. Some grace notes felt like too much

Decipher(x3Fallen) [-] {1/10}
_
. Too much stream and misrhythms all over the place
. Cool song though...
 
DeVouR (Xandertrax) [+.] {6/10}
_
. m23 on should be single notes per layering scheme so far
. m92 4312 roll would be better than 4231
. Some parts still cluttered lol this file is probably never going to make it in D:

Dizzy Division (unkdavar) [-] {1/10}
_
. Needs better PR, layering and rhythm choice

Down But Not Out (_.Spitfire._) [+] {8/10}
_
. cut at 171.3 for awesome 

Drift (Silvuh) [+.] {5/10}
_
. Expand 2->3, Compress 2x, BPM = 95
. Overall pretty good but some of the PR felt off

Drop (OperationStrawbarry) [+?] {5/10}
_
. Still missing some of the stick sounds
. Jacks may be too hard compared to the rest of the file
. Needs to be better to v2 the in-game one

Dying Flame (SulferDragon) [+.] {4/10}
_
. lol sounds like raustdragonblack
. Overall stepped ok but PR could be more interesting

Elements of a Party (dore) [+] {7/10}
_
. YNS & voice BPMs
. fun

Elfin Pirate (Redsky139) [+?] {6/10}
_
. m27 that pattern is too hard, do, 21432 instead of 434321
. m32 again pattern too hard, do 4321 or something instead
. Overall good transitions in the layering but you have to choose patterns for the faster rhythms better

Fantasty Impromptu (Quasar889) [-] {1/10}
_
. More misrhythms than I'd shake a stick at
. PR needs major work
. D:

Forgotten Aura (kjwkjw) [-] {1/10}
_
. Jesus this song goes on for freakin ever
. Ok tons of misrhythms and very boring

Game Boy Fiend (Vote4Nixon) [4] {m/e}
_
. no me da la gana

Half Symphony (Vote4Nixon) [+?] {5/10}
_
. m23 missed snare
. Some of those jacks aren't needed, especially in the intro
. Does this song really need a v2? :\

Happy Dreams (HighAndr0id) [+.] {7/10}
_
. m50, m55 that first blue jump doesn't belong (might be in other places too)
. m82 jack
. Might want to check over the double placement because this is a complicated layering job

Higan Retour -idling mix- (Knoobish) [?] {3/10}
_
. PR sucks almonds
. Overstepped but that doesn't really matter
. Layering not great

HoH (Heaven or Hell) (trumaestro) [-] {2/10}
_
. Wow sync is no good
. The difficulty jumps waaaaay too much
. Overall meh

HOT PEPPERZ (NSane) [-] {0/10}
_
. lol no


I'm A Maid (NSane) [-] {0/10}
_
. terrible

Ievan Polkka (Rin&Len ver.) (JX) [+] {8/10}
_
. lol this song will be stuck in my head for 3 days now

Impulse (ClAsSiC_RoCkEr) [+.] {7/10}
_
. step the intro
. double the bpm sooner
. m34 don't hear those 32nds
. That ending is kinda long
. Overall, really fun

Inside the Fire cut (dore) [+] {8/10}
_
. Solo easier, good enough

Introsphere (Extended) (Vote4Nixon) [?] {4/10}
_
. Part before talking feels choppy
. Some notes seem to go to nothing
. Vocals layered in play terrible

J'ai Envie de Plaisir X2 (Patashu) [+] {9/10}
_
. Awesomely hard
. Maybe 2x BPM in the hard part so it's easier to read?

Jeanie and Caroline (Kommisar[os]) [+] {8/10}
_
. Maybe one note at the end so the guy finishes talking at 135.07 

Kyrie (JX) [+] {9.5/10}
_
. lol this file is awesome

Land of Eternity (SulferDragon) [+.] {7/10}
_
. The 24th runs would be much more fun with no 12th jacks in them
. Feels a little overstepped but I think it's fun this way

Largiloquent Dithyramb (dore) [+] {can'tspellthis/10}
_
. Much easier without 200 bpm jacks >_<

lolhappy (HammyMcSquirrel) [+.] {7/10}
_
. m45 missed a 16th to bass drum
. I liked the stream technique you used but some of the PR could be brushed up, might be ok as it is

Lunar Dial (Vote4Nixon) [?] {4/10}
_
. m35 needs some 12th notes to the harpsichord
. Honestly I don't hear MANY of these 32nds, 
. m61 needs more steps
. Overall missed a ton of drums that really need to be stepped and other stuff too, especially near the end (m100 or so)

Marisa Stole the Precious Thing (ClAsSiC_RoCkEr) [+] {8/10}
_
. m72 overstepped
. Other than that good
. >:3

Midnight Shooter (TC_Halogen) [+?] {6/10}
_
. m16 missed some drums and throughout the sim
. m53 missed a double
. m61 missed some 16ths to guitar
. Needs more filler notes to keep the flow going overall
. m160 missed two doubles, m164 missed more
. m167, m176 missed guitar
. Overall missed a ton lol, this kind of song you need to step all the rhythms and then it'll be super fun

Mitsudomoe Motion - Triangular Fight (i love gabba vs. Frozen Beat) [?] {2/10}
_
. Some of the guitar needs manual sync
. Didn't like the jacks, take them out
. long 8th jumpjack made no sense
. Some 16ths go to nothing

Mouch (robertsona) [+.] {boring/10}
_
. Ok, technical easy files are really boring
. Like, really really boring
. Like, seriously, .63 notes per second

Mr. Heat Miser (HammyMcSquirrel) [+?] {5/10}
_
. Why BNS at the end?
. Needs jumps, like jumps to that skidding sound, and more
. layer please!
. fun otherwise

My Holiday Dinosaur (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?] {2/10}
_
. Wow, this song, just, wow
. The sync is off later in the song
. Some of the jacks later in the song seem superfluous

Nebula (Kommisar[os]) [+] {8/10}
_
. rly fun
. may have missed a few 16ths but it doesn't really matter

Nitrx (Vote4Nixon) [+] {8/10}
_
. Very fun, maybe mix up the jumps at the end a bit?

October (Xandertrax) [+] {8/10}
_
. another really fun file this is a streak!
. ok some parts are kind of handed making it really hard to PA but it may be ok how it is

Off the Wall (bluguerrilla & Vote4Nixon) [#] {win/10}
_

On Conquest and Capture (dore) [+] {8/10}
_
. cool song, cool file

Peacemaker(Darkstalker_X) [+?] {6/10}
_
. freeform stream could be more fun
. bursts should be 32nds
. m68-74 missed some 16ths (one per measure)
. m84 missed a burst
. really fun file! make the fixes, I don't think it needs PR fixes, it's nice how you stepped it

Perfect Cherry Storm (_.Spitfire._) [+] {8/10}
_
. Perfect Cherry Blossom Storm

Pulling Through (bluguerrilla) [#] {nubbin/10}
_

Pulling Through Gamma (dore) [+] {9/10}
_
. Why didn't I step this version? D:

Push (Vote4Nixon) [+] {8/10}
_
. Cut it at 164.72 the ending feels too long now without the intro, + assuming you cut it

RAIN (_.Spitfire._ & bluguerrilla) [#] {lolanotherfilenamedrain/10}
_

Rose At Nightfall (SulferDragon) [+] {8/10}
_
. Finally a whole simfile of Kingdom Hearts music haha

Schmollbluk (_.Spitfire._) [+] {9/10}
_
. hard!

Science Party (Coolgamer) [?] {2/10}
_
. Misrhythms and terrrrrrible layering, felt like ctrl+r

Secret Zombie Room V2 (unkdavar) [+?] {4/10}
_
. I feel like the intro and outro could be stepped better
. Mostly right but there are definitely a few misrhythms and few jump issues to the snare, you missed one or two
..and had one or two extra in other part

ska ska and again ska (ahr2nd's Omegka Prologue Mix) [robertsona] [+.] {boring/9}
_
. Wow, boring, maybe mirror some of these sections, or turn them
..or step more of the noises so it's not so damn boring 


Skeletor (psycho & bluguerrilla) [#] {SKELETOR/10}
_
. I BOW TO NO ONE!!!

Slashfic (OperationStrawbarry) [-] {wrongbpm/10}
_
. BPM = 180
 

Slow Down (Xandertrax) [+] {7/10}
_
. Nice n short now, longest 8th jack ever

SM 64 - The Alternate Route Remix (megamon88) [+?] {4/10}
_
. Didn't like the stream in m48 on, very quiet noise being stepped there
. Maybe cut at 146 seconds in
. The intro is also painfully long, cut the first 35 seconds or so please
. Missed some drums in some parts

Starfox Speed Mix (CosmicRain) [?] {3/10}
_
. Hated the jacks caused by layering
. Many many misrhythms

Streets (Xandertrax) [+] {8/10}
_
. Fun gallops and minijacks woo! 

Sunset Dept. (CyclopsDragon) [?] {3/10}
_
. Half this bpm would be better
. Tons of misrhythms and the layering needs to be better

Swallowing an Avalanche  (New Mix) (Bynary Fission) [+?] {6/10}
_
. m31 wth bpm changes?
. m66 on some of the jumps seem wrong
. this song is pretty badass :O
. Jacks would be better as trills

The Final Hour (silvercomet1525) [+?] {6/10}
_
. m47-56 layering messed up (some jumps missed, some jumps to nothing)
. m101-104 needs better PR in the single notes
. The slowdown parts could be better

The Mooned Insects (sc979) [+?] {6/10}
_
. Lots of misrhythms in 48ths and 32nds

The Swarm (MooMoo_Cowfreak) [+?] {5/10}
_
. Didn't like the runningmen
. Didn't like the ending 3 jacks
. Didn't like that you didn't step more of the noises in m45 on

Thinking Different V2 (Silvuh) [+.] {6/10}
_
. These polyrhythms or whatever you want to call them suck to play
. Missed some synth in the intro

TizAshura (Vote4Nixon) [+.] {7/10}
_
. Flow would be better if you stepped all of that one synth, you know the one I mean

Tribe Attacker (alexdestructions) [+?] {6/10}
_
. Parts like m52 are missing one yellow note
. 16th jacks aren't as fun as the 12th jacks, they don't fit as well
. Probably not FMO, the hands _are_ fun though :\

Tricky Concert (Xandertrax) [+] {7/10}
_
. Easy and fun, see robertsna! 

Tricky Concert_(dandandamdandan1111) [>] {4/10}
_
. Not as good as xandertrax's

Turbulence (AG Hi'per Mix) - Bynary Fission [?] {5/10}
_
. Some 16ths to nothing
. I think people might prefer a v2 of this song that's JACKY
. BPM slightly off, it's late by the end of the song

Turn Soonest to the Sea [Oni] (MeaCulpa) [+?] {6/10}
_
. A ton of the drum rhythms are off
. Weird cut, is this song cut in the heavy version?
. Some PR a bit weird but overall pretty darn fun
. Some BPMs off by 2x or .5x

Twelve (TC_Halogen) [+?] {6/10}
_
. Missed rhythms and misrhythms throughout
. BPM seems slightly off
. Gap too

uNdEr YoUr BeD_(dandandamdandan1111) [?] {3/10}
_
. BPM way off
. Needs a climax part
. None of these 24ths belong
. PR needs to be 100000x better

Up In The Air (HighAndr0id) [+] {8/10}
_
. Some parts are _very_ hard on your right hand
. Other than that very fun

V.L.S.I. (woker-X) [?] {4/10}
_
. Jacks too hard for the file
. Too streamy (stream to nothing)
. Tons of misrhythms

Versatile (CosmicRain) [?] {4/10}
_
. Bad PR
. Boring Layering
. Jacks are a bit lol

Voyage 1969 (Zybanthia) [+?] {7/10}
_
. m41-56 needs better PR
. m81 on needs CLIMAX!
. Fadeout with no steps is waaaaay too long
. Seriously now, who are you?

Wish (Reprise) (HammyMcSquirrel) [+.] {6/10}
_
. m38 seems like there are too many 16th notes, possibly true in other parts of the sim as well
. Much better than before

Xxxperiment_(dandandamdandan1111) [?] {4/10}
_
. Most of those 16ths should be swung
. Boring overall

yorukumoryuu yamikaze (sc979) [+.] {7/10}
_
. m64 missing some notes
. Don't like the 48ths but they go I guess
. Damn this sim is fun and hard, could use a bit of climax near the end there

{The Traveller} (silvercomet1525) [+?] {6/10}
_
. BPM off at parts, needs just a bit more work, maybe get the BPM changes from CnB?
. too many jumps! Seriously!
__________________
RIP

Last edited by Rebirth0; 05-20-2009 at 11:03 PM..
Tasselfoot is offline