View Single Post
Old 03-9-2020, 11:51 PM   #10
Buta-san
FFR Player
FFR Simfile Author
 
Buta-san's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2013
Posts: 492
Send a message via Skype™ to Buta-san
Default Re: Jan/Feb 2020 Set 2

Quote:
Originally Posted by bmah View Post
Let's Live in the Lovely Cemetery [Alternative Ver.] / Buta-san
rating: 9.5/10
- 2.95s: Single arrow.
- 12.54s: Could be a quick gallop.
- 23.65s: Percussion PR.
- 63.37s: Single 8th or jump to cymbal crash would be nice.
- 88.86s: Missing 16th to guitar.
- 108.37-108.51s: These could be just jumps instead of hands.
- Summary: Fun file with very few flaws, but the flow of the guitar solo is what really stood out to me. Great work.
Fixed above thank you.


Curious to know what you think about the layering for the beginning/ending around the solo.
Any better solution, or is there not much that can be done?
This 1+1 precussion/kick + melodic note thing sometimes feel off or hard to follow when the two dont snap.
Edit: thickened layer lightly in beginning heavily in ending.


Besides that heres stuff I fixed/changed but unsure about. Will revert or fix if demanded.
Don't really have to go through these, just wrote it down as a reference incase it helps.
Edit: I kinda got carried away and theres more changes than whats mentioned here.

Arrow Vortex
- 12.25s Missed jump: melody + precussion
- 18.37s 24th burst following glissando
- 25.45s Converted jump > dissonance
- 32.60s Ghost note: 16th
- 34.20s Missed note? Added, Sounds extremely high ptiched
- 37.12s Here onwards changed a good chunk of the whole solo
- 43.92s 24ths burst here? Added
- 50.97s Missed 32nd note. Not sure if its really worth adding? It might even be a burst of 48ths.
- 50.73s 24ths burst here? Added
- 66.98s 24ths burst here? Added
- 68.09s Added slide guitar
- 69.90s Bunch of changes in this measure
- 72.40s Missed jump: lead guitar + precussion
- 72.95s converted jump > Hand
- 73.09s Ghost note? Removed
- 83.50s Missed jump: lead guitar + kick
- 89.20s Changed a bunch in the measure starting here
- 97.40s Missed jump: lead guitar + kick
- 106.28s Missed jump: lead guitar + precussion
- 106.63s Missed note? 16th gallop
__________________
le stepman blog
Buta-san is offline