[flashflash account]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

OK so here's basically where I'm at:

both claims are believable. I can see why fg would give the gun to sunfan and I can understand roundbox's thought process as well

The main thing I don't like from either of them is this:



seems like an excuse post. The only thing is, she has been around a bit since making this post

I also just think roundbox sounds slightly more natural. Funnygurl is saying all of the right things to say in this situation (Roundbox is the wolf, etc) but something about the way she says it just seems more like script-like to me, like she knows that is how she has to play and there are certain points she has to make

I really do not know though, this isn't very strong. Why do you think it's roundbox?

roundbox's claim relies on an additional assumption (that he got blocked), fg's doesn't
roundbox and fg both were defending star, but roundbox's defense was also offensive towards me (more wolfy)
after the shot roundbox immediately voted star
fg still wanted to know who I shot (though it should have been obvious at that point, that's what I need to unpack)

there are other things too but I think roundbox needs to speak first