View Single Post
Old 08-23-2007, 01:59 AM   #2
Tasselfoot
Retired BOSS
Retired StaffFFR Simfile AuthorFFR Veteran
 
Tasselfoot's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Widget Heaven
Age: 40
Posts: 25,184
Send a message via AIM to Tasselfoot Send a message via MSN to Tasselfoot Send a message via Skype™ to Tasselfoot
Default Re: Batch Review Thread

Code:
8/22/07

Even if your file was queue'd...  make sure to read the notes from all 3 testers.  Also, you'll note in my comments that I agree with jx a ton but never with rebirth.  That is because I had jx's notes in front of me, but I did not have rebirth's notes in front of me.

The Queue:
Air Breeze - Vote4Nixon
Ancient's Death - SulferDragon
Ascii Art Core - Neonatrias
Baby Want Me - MixMasterLar
Beaker Sunset - L Endorphin L
Black Noise - Scytlock
Blue Army - dore
Brooks Was Here - dore
Bundy - BDN
Casio Destroy Toy - ElectricWerewolf
Charge!!! - SulferDragon
Chlorophyll - BDN - oni - 2 24th alien sounds not stepped near end
Choprite - BDN - no 3 framers
Crazy Hair Day - stargroup100
Digital Intervention - vemuck
Disconnected Sanxion7 Remix - eastsideman09
Duality - eastsideman09
Electro Rush x8 - ElectricWerewolf
Euphoria - eastsideman09
Field of Snow - SulferDragon
Fluity Loops - ElectricWerewolf - verify for me that you got permission from Vospi again?
Happy Happy Shinig Star!! - Cyanite
heel and toe - bmah
Hero's Theme (wip) - stargroup100 - Tass feels that it is overstepped, but rebirth and jx like it, so tass is queue'd it.
Hiszekeny - ELectricWerewolf
Horizon Remix - rshadow888
Hyperactivity - stargroup100 - who is the artist of this song?
I am maid - .dot
Indigo - who_cares973
Lost - starfalcon176
Matador - xSerpentinex
Midnight of the North - blah x6
Nanatsuropanda - stargroup100
Over the frail dream - sulferdragon
Plunging Hornets - BDN
PSYCHIC DiVE - SulferDragon
Pupil of Frenzy - Neonatrias - see jx's comments
Purple - dore - the 225bpm version
Reversing Darts - jx
Rock Paper Snippers - ElectricWerewolf - Rock song
Rocking Ass - dore - my fault probably...  jx/rebirth didn't get the dwi/mp3 for this, so i was the only one to test.  fun though.
Shin Trigger - SulferDragon
Sing a Song - Kalazor
Snow Stream - BDN - verify for me again permission from Vospi?
Southern Cross - jx
Syndrome - Ben Speirs
Synful Sub - Valtrix - seemed a wee bit overstepped
The Final Fantasy - Kalazor
The Worst is Yet to Come - SulferDragon
Underground - blah x6
X - MeaCulpa
You're Not Alone Remix - vemuck
600 AD in Piano - Knoobish
{Arabian Assassin} - DarkbearX - replaces ledwix's file
{I Don't Need You Anymore} - dore
{James Bond Breakbeat} - Vote4Nixon - this goes in queue...  but i doubt i'll ever put it in game.  this song is just awful for a bond mix.  i forget who, but some artist is working on a better one.  so, hopefully someone will step that.


Songs Tass Played But Didn't Queue
a dragons final roar - see jx's comments
a nightmare before kefta - missing ending notes, should be a break in the 5th jumps where there is no music, 32nds are overstepped compared to rest of file
a2 sauces op - this is garbage, although i did get my first ever AAAA testing it
all of your love - cut it around note 500.  also, i'm very wary of using remixes of commercial songs
anaconda remix - what jx said.  slow 32nds... are they onsync?
angel stays on this ground - few parts overstepped, vocal mix should go more with vocals
barney remix - see jx's comments
crying soul - sync, boring, extra 8th note at end of bursts in beginning, 8th jumpstream seems overdone
destined marionette - agree with jx
dot matrix hero - what jx said.  especially 1st mario land section
extra terrestrial - what jx said; 550ish especially
fascination maxx - i think i deleted this for some reason.  i'm guessing ben asked me to.  so, i didn't play it.  but both jx and rebirth did and both +d it.
hadazamui rittou - cut part of beginning
hardcore symphony - permission, jx is right, song is a bit repetitive
healing smile - what jx said
i once was a hero - cut this.  8ths near end felt overstepped
venetian spirit - what jx said
legacy - deleted this file.  i'm guessing at eastsideman's request.  didn't play it, but both jx and rebirth +d.
otters dance - agree with jx, would even tone down whole file's difficulty a notch
progression - agree with jx
same dream - song not all that great.  what jx said.
secret zombie room v2 - 24ths = 3 framers; what jx said.
sonic green hill zone - what jx said
starwolf - 32nds need to go
summer in believe - permission, try to tone down jumpstream in middle
surface - what jx said
the creeps - permission, what jx said
violent syndrome - agree with jx.  song is kinda bland for stepping.
waverip - overdoubled
you dont know what - what jx said
101 kittens - 32nds near beginning; more consistent on which sounds you're stepping to
{Adrinaline Pumper} - cut the last few arrows.  not really a fan of thos chart/song overall
{Barbed Wire} - fix colors and sync
{Firestorm} v2 - tass doesn't like v2's.  easier version of v1, not really original, trills are weird.
{Mercury} - agree with jx.


Rebirth's Notes:
(Too Much) Bass: ?
- Those pink notes you have before the jumps in the 20s measures are supposed to be yellow notes
- Has too many jumps

101 Kittens: +
- Goes offbeat after one freeze near the end (I can fix easily)
- I don't think any of those brown notes are really there
- Fun simfile though

260: -
- Exited out because more than half of the simfile was offbeat as hell. Those weird yellow note 8th streams are wrong

600 A.D.: +
- Very nice syncing
- We need more files like this. Very cool file

A Dragon's Honor: +
- Has a bunch of 12th jacks at 133 bpm, but I know what you stepped them to so I guess its ok

A Nightmare Before Kefka: + (Permission?)
- Do we even have permission for this?

A2 Sauce's OP (dore): +
- Uh.. technically its a correct simfile, but its pretty stupid

A2 Sauce's OP 2 (Engler) +?
- Has one 16th minijack which is bad for FFR when its 140 bpm
- Like the first OP, its stupid but I guess its an alright file

Air Breeze: +
- Repetitive 16th triplets..
- File is good for what the music gives you to use though

All of Your Love: +
- Was a little understepped in a couple parts, but you tried to make an easy file out of the song so thats ok

All The Memories: +?
- A few minor sync issues
- Simfile couldv'e been more interesting. Fill in some dull spots and make those parts fun to play

Alpha Helix v2 (omgitznpv): ?
- Those 24th streams look like they'd have some 3 framers in them
- Feels overdone. Too hard
- I don't think this song really needs a v2

Alpha Helix v2 (Ben Spiers): +?
- Better than the other submission for a Alpha Helix v2, and its an alright file, but I still don't think the song needs a v2

Anaconda Remix: +
- lol drum and bass music is always repetitive
- Good file though

Ancient's Death: +
- File fits the music so its alright

Angel Stays On This Ground Vocal: +
- The gap should be 1003 instead of 1040
- Once I changed the gap, it was a REALLY fun file

Ascii Art Core: +
- This will be a pretty hard file once/if it goes into the game

Aurora: +?
- That part near the end is kinda overstepped. It'd be fun for SM but I'm not sure about for FFR
- Otherwise good

Baby Don't You Want Me: +
- Those yellow notes should all be blue notes

Barney Remix: +
- lol missing note on the fourth beat of measure 35

Battleman Zero Theme: +?
- 155 bpm part feels very weird. Might be offbeat, I didn't check for sure

Beaker Sunset: +
- once I changed the gap by 80 it was pretty good >_>

Beatlejuice Theme Remix: ?
- Gap is way off
- Rainbow notes were stupid
- Really uninteresting

Black Noise: +

Blue Army: 
- I can't really judge this since I have a Blue Army simfile of my own in the queue

Brooks was Here: +
- Good file lol

Bundy: +
- Has a few sync issues. I'll fix before it goes into the game, if it does

Casio Destroy Toy: +
- Fun file

Charge!!!: +
- Fun file

Chlorophyll (Oni steps): +
- Might have 3-framers, not sure
- Technically correct file, but it might be a little too much for FFR

Choprite: +
- File might be too much for FFR, like Chlorophyll
- Accepting it but I HIGHLY RECCOMMEND you change those 48th jumps right after the red note jump. Maybe take those teal jump notes out, because those are almost quads

Composer: +?
- The pink and purple notes in that one 48th stream at the end of the song would be a 3 framer or worse. Change it, then its queueworthy

Crazy Hair Day: +
- Repetitive rhythms and patterns
- 16th jacks but its 100 bpm so I guess thats alright

Crying Soul: +
- notes are early in the simfile. Might need a tiny bpm tweak so everything is the same. I'll change if/when it goes into the game

Destined Marionette: +

Digital Intervention: +
- changed gap by 40
- cool file

Disconnected Saxion7 Remix: +

Disconnected Disco: +?
- Pretty good file but there are some 16th jacks near the beginning, where you have those small 32nd triplets. 16th jacks + 139 bpm = almost 2 framers. Change those then queueworthy

Dot Matrix Hero: +
- Fun file, no changes needed

Duality: +
- 12th jack in the middle of measure 45. It might need changing

Electric Candles: 
- I didn't play any of the charts because I don't know which one I'm supposed to be playing

Electro Rush X8: +
- I'd like to see a crazy hard file for this but this sim is ok

Elevated: ?
- Uh, the downbeat of the simfile shouldn't be a yellow note. Move it up to a red note then resubmit. Its good otherwise

Enjoy the Silence: ?
- Not entirely all correct rhythms but whatever. Some of those notes shouldv'e been yellow arrows instead of just blue or red. Listen closely to the music and make changes where needed
- 30 bpm part is really really early, but when it goes to 125 bpm its fine
- Repetitive song/simfile + easy simfile + 5 minute long song = incredibly boring
- I'm not so sure this song is step worthy becuase of the third comment

Esperanza: +?
- 24th minitrills in about measure 35 might be troublesome
- 32nd trill at around measure 50 at 147 bpm = almsot 2 framer = no
- Change those things and its queueworthy

Euphoria (eastsideman09): +?
- In the slow part, you have a few 64th bursts ending in a jump. That might cause 3 framers and will probably need a change
- Very good file

Euphoria (Spenner): ?
- Change gap by 40
- eastsideman's was better

Extra Terrestrial: +
- Bunch of 4th jumps that felt meh, but whatever

Fascination MaxX: + (Permission?)
- Those gallop things at 400 bpm were pretty weird
- Do we even have permission?
- Good file

Field of Snow: +

Fillipino style hardcore: -
- Might be a technically correct file but its too insane for FFR

Final Audition: +?
- Change gap by 40
- 24th streams in thewill probably pose a problem. 3 framers (12th jacks)
- Otherwise good, queueworthy

Final Fantasy VII Fighting Mix: +?
- Those blue jumps in the beginning are supposed to be red. You're off by an 8th note on those jumps
- Big syncing problem after about 20 - 30 seconds in

Fruity Loops: +
- Good file. 
- Gets a little repetitive

Forsaken Neon: ?
- Boring, weird patterns/rhythms
- Some of those 12th streams are supposed to be 16th streams
- Seems like you're missing some notes in the middle

From Mount Chorus v2: ?
- I don't think that song has any 16th notes lmao
- 8th jacks and crap
- This song doesn't need a v2

Gargoyle: +?
- Repetitive rhythms and patterns...
- Patterns don't feel too fun

Geno's Forest F-Zero vROFLOL: -
- Retarded. I exited out after measure 4

Hadazamui Rittou: +
- I almost fell asleep becuase this was so meh
- Incredibly repetitive. Not a song that should really be stepped, but I'll accept it since the simfile is technically correct

Happy Happy Shining Star: +
- Its a really fun file, but it'd be even better if you took out those 8th jacks in the 4th jump parts. I reccommend you do that because that'd make this file even better

Hardcore Symphony: +
- Pretty good file

Healing Smile: +
- aisdufnaisdf fun fun fun

Heel and Toe: +
- What was that last note two measures after all of the steps? I'd remove that and send the fixes to one of us (if its accepted into the queue)

Hero's Theme: +
- It'll be a pretty hard file for FFR, but thats ok
- Fun

Hiszekeny: +?
- Yes the file is good, but I feel its a bit overstepped, for FFR. The song is really calm and quiet, and the simfile has a bunch of jumps. I don't think all of those are really needed

Holy Orders: +?
- Some of those longer 24th streams have 12th jacks if you look closely. Might pose a problem in the game
- I'd prefer a harder file for this. One that uses the song to its full potential
- Those teal notes at around measure 108 aren't in the music lol. Sounds like 32nds or something, I didn't pay too much attention to the music there

Honey, I've Never Had Sex That Wasn't Awkward: -
- Probably too insane for FFR. Jumpstream, and a bunch of trills that will definitely cause 3 framers. Maybe even 2 framers
- Don't get me wrong though.. the file is alright. Its much better suited for Stepmania though

Horizon Remix: +

Hyperactivity: +
- Interesting patterns

I Am Maid: +
- Good file, though it couldv'e been done differently and wouldv'e really stood out more to me. I guess I just like Bursurk Lurk's Stepmania file for it too much


I Once Was a Hero: +?
- Has one 12th jack that doesn't fit the with the rest of the simfile. I suggest you change that

Ice Cap Zone: +?
- Fun simfile, I like it.
- One 16th minijack at measure 64. We can't have those at 145 bpm, change it

Indigo: +
- Good, fun file

Indulgence: +?
- One of my favorite files in the batch, but we can't have those 24th trills in there. Change them.

Venetian Spirit: +
- Good file. A bit repetitive, but that can't be changed.

Ken's Theme: +?
- Long ass 8th streams with a ton of running men. Running men aren't a problem but its really boring and repetitive
- Whole file is just repetitive. 

Kirby's Dream Land: +?
- I love these songs XD. Good simfile too, but its missing some notes. With a song this cool, I want it perfect. It just NEEDS those few 16ths you left out in the melody (or were they 32nds?)
- Has some 16th jacks which might be a little problem as well. 4 framers for sure. 

Legacy: +
- Has a few jumps that I thought were out of place in the slow part

Live at the Abbey: -
- Exited out after about 30 seconds. The file is way too much for FFR. Too many jumps, too fast and too many 8th jacks at 245 bpm

Lost: +

Lucid Quasar: +?
- Those yellow notes are supposed to be blue (From the beginning to measure 12 and from about measure 30 to measure 36)

Matador: +

Midnight Dragon (omgitznpv): -
- Incredibly offbeat, exited out

Midnight Dragon (behanjc): +?
- I'm going to assume the one in the queue is better. This file is missing some notes and some notes are off near the end

Midnight of the North: +
- Nice file. Fun easy file

Motherboard March: +?
- Sync is off and goes further off as the song progresses. Probably a bpm problem

Nanatsuropanda: +
- So incredibly fun, and its a really unique file. Possibly my favorite out of the whole batch

Neon-213: +?
- Felt like the same patterns and stuff throughout the whole 16th stream. 
- A bunch of un-needed jumps in slow parts too

Otter's Dance: +
- Mild jumpstream and 32nd bursts...Interesting. File would be pretty hard but thats ok

Over the Frail Dream: +

Plunging Hornets: +
- Might be too much for FFR, like 99% of Venetian Snares songs are, but I'm accepting it because its correctly stepped.

Progression: +
- Pretty cool once it gets to the second half of the sim

PSYCHIC DiVE: +

Pupil of Frenzy: +
- holy **** I love dBu simfiles
- Very good. Every note felt perfect
- I think you missed a couple notes in the 30 BPM part XD

Purple: +

Rendering My Boredom: +?
- Could use some less jumps
- the teal notes are supposed to be yellow

Rendering My Boredom 2: +?
- Those yellow jumps in the middle are off (Measure 20 something, and around measure 50)

Reversing Darts: +

Rock Paper Snipers: +

Same Dream: +
- One of my favorite sharpnel songs but its so repetitive
- Its hard to tell what those jumps were going to in the big 8th stream in the middle of the song. I still don't really know

Scythe of 13: +?
- Has a ton of jumps but I know a lot of those are necessary for a song like that
- Not sure about that 32nd streams 
- It does feel a bit overjumped once you get past measure 110

Secret Zombie Room v2: +

Shin Trigger: +

Shind Bad: +?
- Needs some more 16th fillers on a song like that. little 5 note 16th streams in the beginning and stuff like that
- First 40 seconds of the sim were pretty boring. Definitely needed to be more interesting

Sing a Song: +
- Would be nice if you didn't have a jump go to every beat in that one long 8th stream at measure 20 - 30 (about), but have jumps going to that one sound you put jumps to everywhere else

Sly: +?
- Gap is off a little bit
- Some notes offbeat even after I fixed the gap

Snow Stream: +

Sonic Green Hill Zone: +

Southern Cross: +
- Epic song
- Jumps in measure 85 - 87 are off a whole beat. Fix those because this sim is good
- You missed some jumps throughout the whole song since I can tell you did jumps to the lyrics

Starwolf: +
- Not sure about that 32nd stream at the end

Summer in Belize: +

Surface: +
- Pretty repetitive with weird pattern combinations

Survive: +?
- Once it goes to the higher bpm it goes offbeat slightly (First bpm change after like 20 seconds)
- Sync the simfile as best as you can, because its pretty good.
- At around measure 100 to measure 120, I suggest you not make those all jumps. Where there is no drum sounds in the background, and just vocals, put single steps, not jumps.

Sync: +?
- I suggest you step the sounds you missed in the beginning
- Goes offbeat as the song gets to the end. Resync and resubmit, because I enjoyed it otherwise

Syndrome: +

Synful Sub: +

Tell Me A Story: ?
- tons of offbeat notes on both charts

Terror From Beyond v2: +?
- All of the green notes in the middle are off
- Jumps from measure 86 to 93 (about) don't seem to go to anything

TGTMN: +?
- I think you have some of the rhythms off in the beginning.
- Overjumpped a bit

The Attic: +?
- Has a 24th jack in the middle of the measure 20 - 29 area

The Creeps: +

The Final Fantasy: +

The Worst is Yet to Come: +

Three: ?
- I had to change the gap by like 80
- Some notes are offbeat
- 32nd trill at measure 39. Can't have that at 135 bpm

Touched By The Light: +?
- I think some notes were a little offbeat, I didn't pay too much attention
- Song felt boring and repetitive..

Underground: +

Violent Syndrome: +

WaveRip: +?
- Felt overjumpped

X: +
- Fun file

You Don't Know What: +
- Pretty fun for a sharpnel file. Nice job, I like it.
- Seems to be slightly off early near the end. Try to fix that

You're Not Alone Remix: +

{Adrenaline Pumper}: +

{Arabian Assassin}: +
- Some parts seem offbeat. Not perfect syncing, but I think it might be close enough for nobody to notice. Please try to fix though

{Barbed Wire} MAC7: +
- ohi weird colored notes that are supposed to be 16th streams or something
- Good sim though, I guess

{Firestorm} v2: +

{Flying Away}: +?
- Notes should be moved up or down an 8th beat. Downbeat should almost always be a red note

{I Don't Need You Anymore}: +
- Well stepped file

{James Bond Breakbeat Remix}: +
- Very nice stepchart for the song

{Mercury}: +
- Quite a few jumps but they seem alright



JX's Notes:
A Dragon's Honor (SulferDragon) [+?] - if going for jacks, want more pitch relevant patterns

A Nightmare Before Kefka (Scytlock) [+?] - should be notes on last orchestra hits, stream patterns. rhythms are good.

A2_Sauce's OP by dore (Engler) [-] - too boring, etc

a2_sauce's op part 2 (Engler) [-] - minijack, etc

Air Breeze (Vote4Nixon) [+] (8)

All of Your Love -Sanxion7 Remix- (blahblahblahblahblahblah) [+?] - song should be cut for this difficulty.

All the Memories (_GanonMetroid_) [?] - offsync at parts

Alpha Helix v2 - Ben Speirs [+?] - want more difficulty difference from V1, 16th long trills don't fit other parts

Alpha Helix V2 (omgitznpv) [?] - potential 3-framers, stream patterns, repetitive triplets

Anaconda Remix(who_cares973) [?] - partially understepped and repetitive

Ancient's Death (SulferDragon) [+] (7)

Angel stays on this ground -Vocal Remix- (bmah) [+] (8) - rhythms could go for the vocal more, but ok

Ascii Art Core (Neonatrias) [+] (10) - some stream patterns are a bit awkward but ok

Aurora [eastsideman09] [+?] - felt a bit overdoubled to the song for being 1000 combo

Baby Want me(MixMasterLar) [+?] - sync on the vocal, actually last notes on the vocal should be a bit more late

Barney Remix (xSerpentinex) [+?] - too long intro, cut or step. others are fine

Battleman Zero Theme (argo15) [?] - partially off, stream patterns

Beaker Sunset(L Endorphin L) [?] - offsync (gap late, and maybe bpm), got like all greats

Beetlejuice theme remix (cyrx900) [-] - offsync, stream patterns, placement of bursts

Black Noise(Scytlock) [+?] - stream patterns, last 8th trills are a bit repetitive

Blue Army [dore] [+] (10) - rhythms in m50-80 are a bit repetitive, but ok 

Brooks Was Here [dore] [+] (9)

Bundy (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?] - 12th jumpstream at the end, that part isn't that intense

Car Sax (Classic_Rocker) [-] - use dwi or sm format

Casio Destroy Toy (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (8)

Charge!!! (SulferDragon) [+] (8)

Chlorophyll (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+] (10)

Choprite (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+] (11) - no 3-framers?

Composer (D.J. Cristo) [?] - blue note on 4th, potential 3-framers, 32nd trill placement doesn't fit well

Crazy Hair Day (Stargroup100) [+] (7) - jacks are ok at this speed, 48th + double would be like triple tho

crying soul(who_cares973) [+?] - offsync (gap early)

Destined Marionette(.dot) [+?] - partially overdoubled, wrong rhythm at m77, ending 8ths should follow the music more. others are fine

Digital Intervention (vemuck) [+] (6) 

Disconnected Disco (solopro) [?] - jacky 32nds, stream patterns

Disconnected -Sanxion7 Remix- [eastsideman09] [+] (7)

Dot Matrix Hero (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (10) - still fun, but wanted some flows with the synth melody

Duality [eastsideman09] [+] (9) - potential 3-framer (12th jack), ok if it can be fixed

Eating Candies (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [-] - multi difficulty

Electro Rush x8 (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (8)

elevated(who_cares973) [?] - YNS, stream patterns

Enjoy the Silence (Ssonik) [?] - offsync (gap early), extremely boring so cut the music

Esperanza (meb_mmm) [?] - 24th/32nd trills, minijack

Euphoria (eastsideman09) [+] (8) - not very audible parts but 48th bursts are actually 64ths + 32nds for me, not a big deal for playing tho.

Euphoria (Spenner) [?] - 32nd trills, minijacks, rhythms don't flow well at parts

Extra Terrestrial(Scytlock) [+?] - want more variety in rhythms/patterns, kind of repetitive

Fascination MaxX (K2 Chaos Remix) - Ben Speirs [+] (10)

Field of Snow (SulferDragon) [+] (8) - partially a bit overdoubled tho

filipino style speedcore 4 pre (WTFBrandon) [-] - totally doesn't make sense

Final Audition (omgitznpv) [-] - 24th staircase, stream pattern, who's music is this?

Final Fantasy VII Fighting Mix (freakysnots) [?] - offsync, double placement is weird

Fluity Loops (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (8)

Forsaken Neon (coolboyrulez0) [?] - 460bpm isn't needed, stream patterns, potential 3-framers

From Mount Chorus v2 (D.J. Cristo) [-] - JE songs shouldn't be that hard

Gargoyle-behanjc [+?] - patterns are awkward, middle-ending parts are repetitive

Geno's Forest F-Zero vROFLOL (coolboyrulez0) [-] - waste of time, dude

Hadazamui Rittou (Silvuh) [+?] - felt patterns of beginning is repetitive

Happy Happy Shining Star!! (Cyanite) [+] (10)

Hardcore Symphony (Shad0wlord) [+?] - 16th streams at the middle don't fit other parts, others are good

Healing Smile - Rednanaki [+?] - stream patterns at the middle, rhythms m26-33, m73-84 could be less boring, last measure is mis rhythm'd

heel and toe (bmah) [+] (8)

Hero's Theme (w.i.p) (stargroup100) [+] (9)

Hiszekeny (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (8)

Holy Orders (Silver_Brian) [+?] - rhythms are almost correct but missing some bursts and doubles (stepped too simply at parts), 24th stream patterns

Honey, I've Never Had Sex That Wasn't Awkward [dore] [+] (9) - discuss about potential 3-framer trills. pretty technical file overall

Horizon Remix (Final Cut) - rshadow8888 [+] (9)

Hyperactivity (Stargroup100) [+] (7)

I am maid (.dot) [+] (9) - this song has so obscene lyrics

I Once Was a Hero (WTFBrandon) (4) [+] - felt a bit long for an easy file tho

Ice Cap Zone (Glacial Mix)-(Alioth) [+?] - minijacks, felt long so song-cut is better

Indigo(who_cares973) [+] (6)

Indulgence [eastsideman09] [+?] - 24th trill should be other patterns

KaW-Venetian_spirit(Scytlock) [+?] - mis-rhythm around m50

Ken~Sharpnal~(MixMasterLar) [?] - 8th/16th stream pattern, double placement, felt a bit long

Kirby's Dream Land (freakysnots) [+?] - 32nd rhythms could follow the music better

Legacy [eastsideman09] [+] (8)  

Live At The Abbey (omgitznpv) [?] - not bad rhythms but way less 16th trills/8th jacks please, those don't work well on FFR at this BPM

Lost (starfalcon176) [+] (7)

Lucid Quazar (Vote4Nixon) [?] - offsync at parts

Matador (xSerpentinex) [+] (9)

Midnight Dragon (omgitznpv) [?] - YNS, off at parts

Midnight Dragon-behanjc [<] - the one in the queue is a bit better overall for not being too understepped, although some bursts and some pitch relevant patterns are better on this one

Midnight of the North (blahblahblahblahblahblah) [+] (7)

Motherboard March (Vote4Nixon) [+?] - a bit BPM wrong

Nanatsuropanda (Stargroup100) [+] (9) - quite a bit late at last 12ths but ok

Neon-213 (three17s) [?] - stream patterns

Otter's Dance (Hotroot Mix) (Silvuh) [+?] - rhythms are good, but tone-down right handed biased bursts at m32/46

Over the Frail Dream (SulferDragon) [+] (10)

Plunging Hornets (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+] (12)

Progression (Silvuh) [+?] - some 32nd bursts (and doubles with them) are a bit overdone to the music

PSYCHIC DiVE (SulferDragon) [+] (8)

Pupil of Frenzy (Neonatrias) [+] (9) - a bit off on some slow vibraphone part but ok

Purple[dore] [+] (11) 

Rendering My Boredom (coolboyrulez0) [?] - offsync at parts, stream patterns

Rendering My Boredom 2 (coolboyrulez0) [?] - YNS, stream patterns

Reversing Darts (jimerax) [+] (9)

Rock Paper Snippers (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (8) - sync is almost ok for FFR

Rocking Ass [dore] [-] - no dwi/sm?

Sly (rel89) [?] - offsync at parts, stream patterns

Same Dream (ledwix) [?] - 8th parts are boring, weird ending, need a better music cut

Scythe of 13 (Xandertrax) [?] - streams/doubles pattern

Secret Zombie Room v2 (eastsideman09) [?] - 24th trills, second half parts are understepped

SGX - Tell Me a Story [Compendium Mix] (coolboyrulez0) [-] - multi difficulty

Shin Trigger (SulferDragon) [+] (8) - jumpstream part is a bit overdone tho

Shind Bad (rednanaki) [+?] - stream patterns, overuse of jumptrills

Sing a Song [Instrum] (Kalazor) [+?] - a bit repetitive, d-s-d 16th patterns

Snow Stream (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+] (8)

Sonic Green Hill Zone (MrPopadopalis25) [?] - patterns/rhythms are boring even for an easy song

Southern Cross (jimerax) [+] (11)

Starwolf(blindreper1179) [+?] - rhythms need to go with melody at some parts, tone down last 32nds stream + double

Summer In Belize (Shad0wlord) [+] (8)

Surface (EI_Tizzy) [+?] - felt a bit too long/repetitive, 8ths and stream patterns are a bit too 4-framer biased overall

Survive (bluguerrilla) [+?] - offsync at parts, especially chain parts at later-middle. less 4-framer patterns are better overall

sync (FOURSPLIT Remix) - Ben Speirs [+?] - ok but felt understepped at parts (beginning and ending)

Syndrome (Ben Speirs) [+] - (6)

Synful Sub(Valtrix; revised) [+] - (8)

SGX - Tell Me a Story [Compendium Mix] (coolboyrulez0) [-] - multiple difficulty

Terror from Beyond V2 (customstuff) [-] - offsync, GNS, need to be harder for V2

TGTMN [oni] - Cj_leonine [?] - patterns overall, apparantly overdoubled

The Attic(Scytlock) [-] - multi difficulty

The Creeps (Fedde Le Grand Remix) (TK_pavonineukon) [+?] - one handed trills at the beginning

The Final Fantasy (Kalazor) [+] (8) - a bit weird double placement tho

The Worst is Yet to Come (SulferDragon) [+] (5)

Three (Redorigami) [?] - offsync use BPM changes, 32nd patterns at parts

Touched by the Light (FFR Edit) (spinal_compression) [?] - some notes are off, understepped at parts

Underground (blahblahblahblahblahblah) [+?] - slightly gap late, stream patterns

Violent Syndrome(Scytlock) [+?] - long 8th jack patterns without good reason

WaveRip(remastered) (Silvuh) [+] (10) - ending is a bit overdoubled but not a bad double placement

X (MeaCulpa) [+] (8)

You Don't Know What (Cyanite) [+?] - fine, but felt a few notes are missed, and song is a bit too long/repetitive

You're Not Alone Remix (vemuck) [+] (6) - want a better song cut (fade out, etc) though

101 Kittens (dag12) [?] - gap early, some 32nd rhythms are a bit weird

260(who_cares973) [-] - most yellow notes are off

600 AD In Piano (Knoobish) [+] (8) - sync is fine other than 1 off note at m29

(Too Much) Bass (lol) - rshadow8888 [?] - 24ths don't make sense, overdoubled at parts

{Adrinaline Pumper} (ledwix) [+] (9) - last a few arrows aren't needed IMO though (they just make ending weird)

{Arabian Assasin} (DarkbearX) [+] (8)

{Barbed Wire} MAC7 (Vote4Nixon) [+?] - cute, unique colors but a bit offsync at parts

{Firestorm} v2  - rshadow8888 [-] - file is ok, but not enough difference from V1 except for double placement

{Flying Away} (Zageron) [-] - offsync, orange, green, etc

{I Don't Need You Anymore} [dore] [+] (10) - it's a non-boring marathon song

{James Bond Breakbeat Remix} (Vote4Nixon) [+] (7)

{Mercury} - rshadow8888 [?] - want songcut, slow jumpstreams are repetitive

All comments can go in the queue thread. Submissions for the next batch need to be in to me by Friday evening.
__________________
RIP

Last edited by Tasselfoot; 08-19-2008 at 09:56 PM..
Tasselfoot is offline