Quote:
Originally Posted by TC_Halogen
you also need to learn to read, since I put (Halogen-) right at the beginning of it, and you also need to stop flaunting around your opinions as if they're law, since you tend to do that (and you can't deny it mr. I hate SAMBISTA x200245983240982345). It's acceptable as a file, which I said, and I didn't even call it something perfect, I said that I approved of it. so yes, kindly, step the **** back.
it's perfectly acceptable as a file, everything that it follows is completely clear and just because you doesn't like it, doesn't mean that you're correct.
second, EVERYONE needs to stop publicly being rude to someone to submitted content to the tournament - I don't give a shit if you don't like the file but you know what, they contributed just like anyone else who submitted content. if people are going to start being inconsiderate towards us and have ridiculously snide attitudes, then we will cancel the tournament. Kayla's already personally vented once about it - I'm sure a LOT of you already know that FFR has been one of the last things I've cared about, so the last thing I need to hear is people complaining about senseless garbage.
|
Had no idea that (Halogen-) meant it was you lol my bad
Kinda just skipped over it in the post.
Not sure where you're getting I'm implying my word is law, I stated my opinion on the file and that was that.
I'm glad you ~approved~ it, but that still doesn't change my opinion or the fact that the patterns in the file are not well musically justified.
Some people enjoy giving feedback. Some people enjoy reading my feedback. Some people *gasp* even learn from it, which is awesome.
Submitting a file to a public showcase such as this tournament is, in my mind, inviting feedback. I plan on giving feedback for every file in this tournament- if people are going to misinterpret this as me implying my word is law then so be it, misinterpret away.
I've actually said I'm fine with playing S.Y.S.T.E.M. as a tournament file- it's a good test for 1-handed anchor jacks. It makes a nice D5 file. I play bad files in Dossar tournaments all the time too and still quite enjoy myself, the feeling of competition and pushing your limits is rewarding. But Dossar doesn't even remotely pretend the files in his tournament are good lol they are just files that test skills and somewhat go to music, which is about what I'd consider the S.Y.S.T.E.M. chart to be.
Stop snapping any time anyone says something you remotely disagree with. People are allowed opinions bro.
p.s. Yeah I still hate SAMBISTA too. At least I'm consistent.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Xx{Midnight}xX
Actually Hi19's comments are appreciated. Plus I've done the same sort of thing to him, so I really kinda understand why he phrased it as he did.
A few things about S.Y.S.T.E.M.
1. It's actually "S.Y.S.T.E.M." I'm dumb and made that mistake. <3
2. The patterns weren't chosen to be "fun." Neither of my charts this tourney are "fun." I stepped them in the interested of being a little more technical than usual.
3. How it got into the tourney has no relevance on this chart as a whole, it was actually charted for the last custom and it needed a good deal of work. This is actually the better chart compared to the other one.
4. This chart is WAY better than NVLM's technical shit dump, if you asked me.
5. It's not a perfect chart, I accept this.
6. You all really need to pull of this stupid "You hate it because it sucks" argument. It's a disgusting argument.
7. The chart is stepped to the beat, all the minijacks are justified, as it's a large pet peeve of mine when people have no purpose for them. The only hands of this chart are literally 3 sounds at once. Notes aren't placed to PR. The anchor jack section was originally 1 1 1 1 1 1 34 sort of thing. I thought changing it to how it was would help keep the difficulty more consistent.
Yeah that's just my thoughts. I'm fine with Hi19 saying he dislikes it. I'm no stranger to it, and honestly seeing things like that makes me want to work harder.
PS: What's funnier is that compared to how I've phrased comments I thought Hi19 was reasonable. Thanks for the input everyone.
|
This is a good post. Disagreeing with the way you made one of your charts doesn't mean I think any less of you as a person or anything, it just means I don't like the chart lmfao
I'll agree the jacks themselves are absolutely musically justified, but the 1-handed anchor jumps are not. If you are going to use that kind of pattern that is difficult to hit, it needs to be either REALLY justified in the music, or you will get hate for it. You will probably get hate either way, to be honest. However had you gone with (13) and (24) jumps instead I think I might have even liked the chart haha
The 1-handed anchors totally destroy the flow for me.