Retired BOSS
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Widget Heaven
Age: 40
Posts: 25,184
|
Re: Batch Review Thread
Code:
10/15/07
THE QUEUE
Devotion and Desire - DSC & blu
Dimensions - SulferDragon - any way to fix up the 1st 2 vocal sections?
Do a barrel roll - EW
Fantasia - eastsideman
Frictional Nevada - jimerax (this is a FGO people!)
Gameboy Rave - EW - make sure to only include 1 difficulty...
Glove Stage - EW
Guitar v Piano - Xandertrax
Hybrid - eastsideman - should 550-600ish go to guitar?
Hyper Hyper - eastsideman
Infinity 301 - SulferDragon
L9 - jx
Lapis - bmah
Love - EW - got 3 perfs on this...
MegaScorcher - eastsideman - didn't notice what rebirth said
Psychopathy 101 - silvuh
Read the Mind - SulferDragon
ROAR - SulferDragon
Rumia, Sealed... - EW - agree w/ jx
Same Dream - EW
Survive - bluguerrilla
Toph's OP - EW
Tougenkyou - jx
twinklesky - bmah
00.01 - SulferDragon
101 kittens - stargroup - about damn time a file for this song got in the queue
Songs Tass Played But Did Not Queue, Or Didn't Play
a dragon's honor - 77 4 framers, very similar song to dragon's final roar
am3p - not good enough. bland.
angel stays on this ground vocal - agree w/ jx, esp 1st vocal section
ascii art core - way overstepped. right hand biased.
balamb style - what jx said
bang bang bang - vocals
bouff - too many 4 framers
chaos sphere - DNP
crystal monolith - what jx said, maybe less jacks
delta beat - what jx said. few16th patterns awkward.
dragonic rage - overstepped, go to melody. all ****ing dragon songs sound the same!
dreamin in the 80s - bit overstepped
endless altercation - what rebirth said
experience - DNP
flower forever - step the whole thing
happy rainbow - what jx said
high - no permission
highway star - repetitive
huzzah - what jx said
i am maid - DNP
ice disk - what jx said
intergalactic - DNP, fix noteskin issue
mr evil - little more to vocals
oh em gee 3 - i will shoot myself before this gets into ffr
skeletones - no 3 framers in the file, but what rebirth said
lunatic princess - DNP, overstepped
phonograph plays part and parcel - understepped... and didn't i put a ban on JE? lol
variations2 (jx) - 158bpm vs 160bpm for EW? also, what rebirth said... fix up a bit still?
vertex - what rebirth said
wave rip - what they both said
wow wow 220 - any way to change single-double jacks so they aren't jacks?
too much bass - song.
Rebirth
(Too Much) Bass: +?
00.01: +
101 Kittens (flipsta_lombax): +?
101 Kittens (SulferDragon) +?
- Best 101 Kittens file I've seen yet, but its still not quite what I'd be looking for
- Has some 12th jacks that mightv'e been a problem
4 Chord: -
- Fun, but overstepped for FFR
Eleventh Hour: +?
- 12th jack
A Dragon's Honor: +
- Has a lot of jacks, but its correctly stepped.
Aidra: ?
AIRWAVE: +?
AM-3P: +?
Angel Stays on this Ground Vocal: +
- Changed gap by 20. F12 once
As Do I: ?
- Needs a harder simfile
Ascii Art Core: +
- Should be rejected for hyper jumpstream and 24th/32nds bursts at high bpms and stuff. But I think we need another good guru file
Balamb Style: +?
Bang Bang Bang: +?
Beneath the Sand: ?
- 16th jacks lol
BOUFF: +
Chaos Sphere: +
- Only accepting because I think it'd make an alright easy file. The song is boring, and with strict judging, I'd normally reject this for the song
CIA Rave v3: ?
- v3 for this sim would have to somehow be incredible
Clockwork Genesis: ?
- 16th jack at beginning lol.
- The queue'd file is better anyway
Close Combat: +?
Cloud Control (Knoobish): +?
- Jumpstream was kinda a little much. File is good otherwise
Cloud Control (OMEGAspike):
- Same problem as the other one. Jumpstream. This file feels better than the other though
Club Beats: -
- Way offbeat, probably wrong bpm and everything
Cool: ?
- Needs a harder, better file for this song
Cosmos: -
- Freezes lol
Crystal Monolith: +
- Changed gap by 20. F11 once
CY.5: +?
Darkened Lights: +?
- Kinda had too many one handed trills. Could be fixed up some too
Delta Beat: +
- Missing a couple jumps in random spots, but its good (even with that climax at measure 68)
Demon(s): -
- I have no idea what the hell these notes go to. Incredibly offbeat
Devotion and Desire: +
- I expect a bunch of 4 framers, but the file is good
Dimensions: +
Disconnected Hazard: ?
- Song doesn't have any of those 12th/24th note stuff. Offbeat, etc. Needs a better chart
Do a Barrel Roll: +
Dont Call Me Peanut: ?
- Song makes simfile incredibly boring
Dragonic Rage: +
- I enjoyed this one. Jumps made it fun
Dreamin in the 80s: +
- I think those 200 bpm parts just shouldv'e been 100 bpm 32nd streams maybe, but ok. Good file
DS Boss: -
- offbeat. Needs better file
Electro Rush X8: +?
- ElectroWerewolf's file was better
Endless Altercation: +?
- Change those green jumps to red ones. Resubmit, because other than that its good
Enigma: +?
- minijacks
Epidermis v2: -
- I can tell just by the arrow count that this is going to look a lot like the v1 thats in the game
- No v2, at least not for a while. v2 for this file needs to be easier anyway
Experience: +
- I was going to reject this, but you did a nice job in some parts which made it a lot more interesting
Fantasia: +
Fantasy Impromptu (Zeron): +?
- Can have a much more pitch relevant chart, which is what I'd like to see for this file
- Streats felt too freeform
Fantasy Impromptu (i love you): +?
- Same thing as the other Fantasy Impromptu file
Final Audition: +?
- Had to change gap by 100 lol
- File didn't seem too fun anyway
Final Fantasy VII Fighting Mix: ?
- There aren't any 12th notes in the song lol
- Boring steps
- Offbeat
Flower Forever (Cyanite): ?
- Offbeat. It has a constant bpm
- Wasn't fun to play at all. Cyanite, you can do much better...
Flower Forever (eastsideman09): ?
- During the red-yellow-yellow note part thing near the beginning, you don't need jumps in there.
- Wasn't too fun
Forsaken Neon: -
- Mine was better
Flight of the Bumblebee v2: -
- lol no
Fictional Nevada: +
- holy crap FGO file for sure
- Those green note things looked pretty stupid
- Might be too much for FFR
Futurescope.exe: +?
- Wasn't fun to play
Gameboy Rave (heavy): +
Gargoyle: +?
- Wasn't what I was looking for in this sim. Rhythms, patterns, etc
Geno's Forest: -
- Wrong bpm or something
Gerudo Interlude: ?
- Song is kinda meh. Gives for a boring simfile
Glove Stage: +
- Kinda seems like correct rhythms so ok
Guitar vs Piano: +
Happy Rainbow: +
Haven: ?
- Random jumps and streams and stuff. Missing some notes as well
Heart Attack (Codyboyrulez0): ?
- Song is too quiet for a simfile. Shouldn't be stepped at all
Heart Attack (RB IcePh0enix): ?
- Same reason as above
Higasi: +?
- Not quite what I'd be looking for in a sim for this. Less jumpstream, even though it was minor. The melody is a 5 note 16th stream, not a 7 note
High: +
- It has a stupid random quad at the end, so we'll just remove that if its accepted. (Tass - don't reject for this, just simply remove it)
Highway Star: ?
- This was just a weird sim. Needs to be different
HOT PEPPERZ: -
- lmao this looks exactly like Exige's simfile for this song
Huzzah: +
Hybrid: +
Hyper Hyper: +
- Fun file, but I have a suggestion. You have some blue-yellow gallops where the yellow note is a jump. I think you should put a red note after all of those. It'd be really fun then
I am Maid: ?
- Isn't this simfile in the queue already? By this very sim author?
- Stricter judging says no on this simfile now. Its not quite what I'd be looking for, and there are some really easy parts where everything else is 8th jumps and stuff like that
I'll Be Here For You: ?
- Had minijacks, and rhythms not stepped correctly
Ice Disk: +
Infinity 301: ?
- Felt meh to play
Intergalactic: +
- Despite the green and orange notes... its correctly synced and everything... good job
Introder: +?
Intruder Alert: +?
- Didn't feel too fun I guess. Mightv'e been because of the song
L9: +
Lapis (Xiaounlimited): ?
- Random steps everywhere and stuff. Overstepped
Lapis (robertsona): -
- bmah's is better
Lapis (bmah): +
- Change gap by 40. F12 twice
- THIS one is fun
Life: ?
- It mightv'e been stepped correctly, but the song isn't one that should be stepped. Boring sim because of that
LOLtechno: -
- tons of offbeat notes
Look to the Future: +?
- It has some minijacks that don't need to be there
Love (ElectricWerewolf): +
- Really fun easy file, nice job. VERY FUN on pad
Love (XPTRIRRYNESSXD): -
- EW's was better
Mad Girl: +?
- It has a near quad thing near the beginning. Two 32nd jumps. Get rid of it
Makiba: ?
- First part of the sim was pretty good, but it got stupid after 30 seconds
- Might have a sync problem too
Super Mario - Plumber's Underground: -
- Wrong bpm it looks like
MegaScorcher: -
- Fix the stop, because it gets really offbeat after that.
MODEL DDX: ?
- This sim seemed alright.. but its way too much for FFR I think
Lucky Star OP: -
- Rejecting before I even play it, because I KNOW we do not have permission for this
Mr. Evil: +
Music: -
- Change them to the correct note colors...
Never Give Up: ?
- Boring/dull song makes for boring/dull simfile
Neverland: ?
- Not fun to play. Random notes
Novo Mundo: +?
- Its a very good simfile, but we can't have the 140 bpm 16th minijacks in FFR. Change those and resubmit. Easily accepted afterwards
OH EM GEE 2: +?
OH EM GEE 3: +?
Orchestral Angels: +?
- Boring/repetitive
Otter's Dance (Silvuh): +?
- I think it can be fixed up a little. Can be made a little better
Otter's Dance (Arcsynth): ?
- Thought Silvuh's was better
Paranoia Sigma: +?
Pump Me Up Amadeus: +?
- Do we have permission?
Popcorn Remix: -
- It was offbeat, and I can't tell where to sync it to
Procrastination on a Paper: ?
- Sounds like you missed a lot of notes
Psychopathhy 101: +
- The purple/pink notes part seemed offbeat, but since you made the song, I'll assume its correct
Read the Mind: +
ROAR: +
Rumia, Sealed Youkai of the Night: +
Same Dream: +
Saria's Song: +?
- Some offbeat notes
Sasoribi: +?
- Get rid of that final jump. I'm sick of seeing songs with those
Scream of Roki: +?
Scythe of 13: +?
- Still think its a little overstepped. For example, measures 100 - 114 don't need to be a constant 8th stream. Theres nothing in the music but those 4ths
Shind Bad: +?
- Mine was better
- Didn't feel very fun at all
Skeletones: +?
- Do we have permission?
- Fix the sync up, it gradually goes off as you get further into the simfile
- Sounds like you missed a few notes near the beginning
Sly v2: -
- Doesn't need a v2
Smithy Showdown: +?
- Not a very appealing simfile
Smitty's Downfall: +?
- Dull simfile. I think it can be better
- Couple offbeat notes
Stronger: -
- rofl this simfile has freezes
Super Mario 3 - Overworld Theme 2: ?
- It doens't need all of those jumps
Superstar: ?
- Song doesn't really work for any kind of simfile
Survive: +
Sword Strike: -
- These notes don't even go to anything...
Terror: +?
The Doomsday: +?
- I don't really think it needed some of the 16th jumpstream... not sure
The Euphoria: +?
- Song was meh. Doesn't make for a good simfile
The Lunatic Princess: +?
- Kinda overstepped
- I can tell you copied the dwi file from my simfile and made your own steps from that. My SM simfile for it is how it should be done
The Phonograph Plays Part and Parcel: -
- Easy simfile for this... doesn't work
Thinking Different v2: -
- Doesn't need a v2
Together As One: ?
- Wasn't a very fun simfile
Toono Youkai Zensen: +?
- Needs more jumps to make it a good file
Toph's OP: ?
- Felt like a weird file. 24th gallop things aren't in the music from what I can hear
Toph's OP 2: ?
- File is good, but the music in the beginning is just far too quiet
- Has a minijack at the end of measure 36
Tougenkyou: +
- Fun
Tricky Disco: +?
Truly, Truly This Is The End: ?
Twin CHevron Remix: -
- What the hell is this?
* twinklesky *: +
- Change gap by 20. F12 once
- Awesome simfile
Vampire Killer: ?
Vanity Angel (bluguerrilla): +?
Vanity Angel (omgitsnpv): ?
Variations 2 (ElectricWerewolf): +?
Variations 2 (jimerax): +?
- The better of the two, but still not quite good enough
Vertex: +?
- Still just a dull simfile
Vertex GAMMA: +?
Viral Unity: +?
- It just seems like the steps can be arranged better
WAIWAI230: +?
- Didn't seem like it needed all of those jumps. Needs some more filler notes too
Wave Rip: +?
Way of the Dungeon: +?
WOWWOW220: +
- Change gap by 20. F12 once
Yager: -
- Change the notes to the correct colors...
{Flying Away}: +?
- Song just won't give a good simfile
{Lazy Summer Days} (Silvuh):?
{Lazy Summer Days} (Xandertrax): ?
- Silvuh and Xandertrax, I think you two should collab on a Lazy Summer Days file. There were parts that I liked in both of these files, and parts that I disliked. If your files were combined, I think it'd be a very good file if done right.
JX
A Dragon's Honor (SulferDragon and ElectricWerewolf) [+?] - nice PR patterns, some weird double placement on 12ths, others are fine.
Aidra (MV_Kingslayer) [-] - offsync, YNS
AIRWAVE (i love you) [+?] - not bad, but it's better to use more 16th rhythms with percussion inside 8th streams
AM-3P (Sanxion7 'House Party' Dub) (Wyde) [+] (7)
Angel stays on this ground -Vocal Remix- (bmah) [+?] - want to go with the vocal more without being too inconsistent in difficulty, minor layering problem. other parts are good.
As Do I ~FFR~ (MixMasterLar) [?] - offsync(gap early), felt understepped even for an easy file
Ascii Art Core (cetaka) [+?] - doubles should be toned down overall, some 24ths are actually 32nds. other rhythms are good
Balamb Style(scottish) [+] (5) - patterns could be more PR tho
Bang Bang Bang-(behanjc) [+] (6) - funny attempt
Beneath the Sand(Sequal) [?] - jacks, stream patterns, rhythms
Bouff (eastsideman09) [+] (9) - a bit jacky overall tho
Chaos Sphere (SulferDragon) [+?] - felt a bit repetitive at the beginning
CIA Rave v3 (i love you) [-] - too similar, no V3 for this
Clockwork_Genesis (Spenner) [?] - jacks, the one in the queue is better
Close Combat-behanjc [+?] - overdoubled on 8ths zone, patterns are PR but a bit too repetitive for me
Cloud Control (Knoobish) [?] - seems a bit off(gap late?), tone down jumpstreams
Cloud Control (OMEGAspike) [+?] - streams are a bit too continuous, also tone down jumpstreams a bit
Club Beats (Garenzo) [-] - offbeat
Cool (verra) [?] - both song and steps are boring for me, easy song though
Cosmos (Sheckler) [-] - freezes
Crystal Monolith (Neonatrias) [+?] - tiny awkwardness on patterns (more PR patterns are better)
CY.5(TK_Breed) [?] - offsync at parts, jacks are slow but shouldn't be there
Delta Beat (0 Vector Mix) (Silvuh) [+?] - overdoubled
Demon(s) (KH Luxord) [-] - offsync (wrong BPM), totally weird steps
Devotion And Desire (DrugstoreCowboy & bluguerrilla) [+] (8)
Dimensions (SulferDragon) [+?] - doubles on vocal = better IMO, because rhythm part of this song is repetitive
Disconnected HaZarD (insomniac_platypus) [-] - a lot of misrhythms
Do A Barrel Roll (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (10) - rhythms aren't very audible tho
Dont Call Me Peanut (DrugstoreCowboy) [?] - offsync at parts, it's not constant BPM
Dragonic Rage (Silvuh) [-] - music ends halfway, and steps are going with silence..
Dreamin' In The 80's (bluguerrilla) [+] (10) - could be less jacky tho
DS Boss (t-rogdor) [-] - offsync
Electro Rush X8 (unkdavar) [-] - overdoubled, no 260 BPM stream for FFR
Endless Altercation (smartdude1212) [+] (10)
Enigma(Sequal) [?] - patterns, jacks
Epidermis (Cyanite) [-] - why do you even try to make a V2 of this?
Excite Bike v2 (Mitchtyler) [-] - no dwi, and just no V2 for this
Experience (Sweet_Feet) [?] - blue on 4th, patterns could be better, if you use 24th long burst you shouldn't miss some other small bursts
Darkened Lights (tepsu) [-] - song is a bit boring, onehanded trill overuse, jacks
Fantasia (eastsideman09) [+] (8)
Fantasy Impromptu (Zeron) [?] - need better stream patterns
Fantasy Impromtu (i love you) [?] - stream patterns, doubles should be put on proper places.
Final Audition (omgitznpv) [?] - offsync, weird rhythms/patterns
Final Fantasy VII Fighting Mix (freakysnots) [?] - off at parts, 16th + 12th rhythms at beginning?
Flower Forever (Cyanite) [>] - m63-78, m93-94, m109-110, m125-126 should be different rhythms(understepped).
Flower Forever [eastsideman09] [+] (8)
Forsaken Neon (Darkstalker X) [+?] - 24th minijack, less 8th jacks at this speed, oterwise good
Fotbb v2 (Mitchtyler) [-] - offsync, understepped
Frictional Nevada (JX) [+] (12)
Futurescope.exe (omgitznpv) [+?] - felt repetitive at parts, double placement
Gameboy Rave! (ElectricWerewolf) [-] - multi difficulty
Gargoyle (eastsideman09) [+?] - off at parts(especially 8ths at second half), most small bursts should be the same rhythms, 32nds are closer IMO.
Geno's Forest - 8 Bit Rock (Coolboyrulez0) [-] - the music isn't enough different from/better than the one in the game IMO
Gerudo(MixMasterLar) [+?] - off notes at m29, less small spins, others are fine
Glove Stage - Ultra Sweden (ElectricWerewolf) [++] (10) - fun/great rhythms, perfectly done
Guitar Vs. Piano (Xandertrax) [+?] - steps are going on after the song ends, hopefully shorter music for this concept. nice full pitch relevancy tho
Happy Rainbow (bmah) [+?] - a bit understepped.. more 16th streams on some 8th section are better. not bad as it is though.
Haven (Shadowlessheart) [-] - missing some rhythms, jacks/stream pattern, cut the music
Heart Attack (Coolboyrulez0) [?] - problem with the song, repetitive, stream patterns
Heart Attack (RB_IcePh0enix) [?] - problem with the song, stream pattern
Higasi (omgitznpv) [?] - double placement, patterns, 12th minijack?
High (Oni-Paranoia) [-] - wtf last quad, others are queueworthy (difficulty might be 6)
Highway Star (i love you) [+] (9) - BPM is just 150.000 I guess
HOT PEPPERZ (Sheckler) [?] - overdoubled, stream patterns
Huzzah!! (SulferDragon) [+?] - PR patterns are better on clarinet parts, some 32nds roll pattern?
Hybrid[eastsideman09] [+] (9) - at this BPM overall a bit too jacky tho
Hyper Hyper-Definitive Version- (eastsideman09) [+] (8)
I am maid (.dot) [+] (9) - isn't this already in the queue from you? awkward double placement at a few parts tho
Ice Disk (ElectricWerewolf) [+?] - good file but rhythm issues, m66-81 could be long streams, after m81 a bit repetitive/24ths don't fit the music
I'll Be Here For You (Shadowlessheart) [-] - jacks, patterns, rhythms, double placement
Infinity 301 (SulferDragon) [+] (9)
Intergalactic -Zenon Mix-(Scytlock) [-] - offsync
Introder (DnB Edition) - rshadow8888 [?] - gap early, song is a bit repetitive, rhythms/patterns(especially trills) could be better
Intruder Alert! (Scytlock) [+?] - felt jumpstream parts are a bit overstepped
L9 (jx) [+] (10)
Lapis -heavens remix- (Xiaounlimited) [+?] - overdoubled overall
lapis -the heavens mix- (robertsona) [?] - difficulty inconsistency, patterns could be better
Lapis -The Heavens Remix- (bmah) [+] (10)
Life(TK_Breed) [+?] - felt 8th + mini-16th rhythms are repetitive, tone down 8th jacky patterns
LOLtechno (Garenzo) [-] - offsync
Look To The Future (Shadowlessheart) [?] - off at parts, many 16th jacks without good reason, most 24ths/32nds aren't needed
Love - (XPTRIPPYNESSXD) [?] - offsync, YNS, double placement
Love (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (5) - a bit long for this difficulty tho
Mad Girl (HK_Keith!) [?] - off at parts, continuous 8th streams, double placement
Makiba - cyrx900 [?] - repetitive song, and patterns don't flow well overall, especially jumpstreams and 24ths
Mario - Plumber's Underground (Poleaxe & Coolboyrulez0) [-] - notes are totally off
MegaScorcher (eastsideman09) [+] (9)
Model DDX (Sulferdragon and bmah) [?] - double placement (m2-17), 24ths at m21?, 24th patterns are bad plus they have a lot of pot 3-framers
Motteke Sailor Fuku!! (Lucky Star OP) (damanwithdaskillz & MeaCulpa) [-] - no permission
Mr. Evil (SulferDragon) [?] - steps are going on after the music ends.. just for me? and it's better going with the vocal, extra voices more
Music(TK_Breed) [?] - ONS
Never Give Up (Goldenwind) [?] - song is boring IMO, a bit jacky patterns
Neverland (Eternity Mix) (Shadowlessheart) [?] - misrhythmed at parts, pattern/double placement coule be better, long for this difficulty
Novo Mundo (Dj_Ossa) [+?] - 16th minijacks
OH EM GEE 2!!! (MrZombie and Macgravel) [-] - freezes, jacks
OH EM GEE 3!!! (MrZombie and Macgravel) [+] (8) - joke file lol
Orchestral Angels-(behanjc) [+?] - a bit repetitive/overdoubled at second half, song cut is better IMO
Otter's Dance (Hotroot Mix) (Silvuh) [+?] - weird 32nd rhythms/patterns at parts
Otter's Dance (Hotroot Mix) [Arcsynth] [+?] - minor misrhythms with the melody, need to step bursts correctly (mostly 32nds)
PARANOiA ~SiGMA~ [DXY] [?] - jacks, weird rhythms at parts
PMU Amadeus (i love you) [-] - no permission
Popcorn Remix LOL (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+?] - understepped, and simple 4ths don't flow the music too well
Procrastination on a Paper (omgitznpv) [?] - rhythms/patterns could be better
Psychopathy 101 (Silvuh) [+] (5) - weird music though
Read the Mind (SulferDragon) [+] (7)
ROAR (Rage Mix) (SulferDragon) [+] (9)
Rumia, Sealed Youkai of the Night (ElectricWerewolf) [+] (9) - ending should go with the piano instead of less audible hihats tho
Same Dream (ElectricWerewolf) [+?] - difficulty/rhythm are ok, but beginning/ending are repetitive
Saria's Song (Coolboyrulez0) [?] - offsync/misrhythm at parts
Sasoribi (Cyanite) [?] - m25-33, m75- should be streams, a lot of misrhythms (32nds in m38 are 24ths, 16ths in m41 are 12ths, at m50 pianos are 32nd double rolls... etc)
Scream of [roki] (roundbox) [+?] - fine but missing small burst rhythms, patterns could be more PR
Scythe of 13 (Xandertrax) [+?] - funny concept but fix 32nds(apparently overdone + 3 framers) and one-handed trills
Shind Bad (Silvuh) [>] - the one in the queue is better
Skeletones (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+] (10) - could have some 3-framers?
Sly (omgitznpv) [-] - no V2s for this
Smithy Showdown [SMRPG Remix] (Coolboyrulez0) [+?] - felt some notes are off, more PR patterns
Smitty's Downfall (DrugstoreCowboy) [?] - offsync at parts, 8th patterns are a bit repetitive
Stronger(JTPROG) [-] - freezes, 24ths don't make sense, etc
SuperMario3 - OverworldTheme2 (Ravenazin100) [+?] - overdoubled, rhythms are fine
Superstar (MeaCulpa) [+?] - ending jumpstreams are overdone, others are fine
Survive (bluguerrilla) [+] (9)
Sword Strike (Shadowlessheart) [?] - jacks, rhythms/double placement could be better
Terror (DAshoe93) [-] - jacks, could be better stream patterns, 8ths are overall repetitive,
The Doomsday (Zeron) [+?] - missing some drum rhythms, rhythms at m32, others are good
The Euphoria-(behanjc) [+?] - fine but a bit boring, could be better rhythms/double placement
The Lunatic Princess-(behanjc) [+] (11) - a bit overdoubled in general but not bad placement.. good rhythms, non boring long file
The Phonograph Plays Part and Parcel (Brilliant Dynamite Neon) [+] (4)
Thinking Different v2 (Knoobish) [-] - a bit harder, but basically quite similar to V1. plus 16th jacks aren't recommended
Together As One (D.J. Cristo) [+?] - a bit overdoubled
Toono youkai zensen-(behanjc) [+?] - decent file but 24th small bursts are all spins.
Toph's OP (ElectricWerewolf) [++] (9) - success in going with the rhythm
Toph's OP Remix (ElectricWerewolf) [-] - multi difficulty
Tougenkyou_H.E.Remix (jx) [+] (10)
Tricky Disco (revolutionomega) [-] - multi difficulty
Truly, Truly This Is The End (D.J. Cristo) [?] - offsync at parts, missing some rhythms
Twin Chevron Remix (verra) [-] - offsync
twinklesky (bmah) [+?] - 12th jacks at 172 BPM(= pot 3-framers), pattern is PR tho. ok if they are manually fixable
Vampire Killer (Neo-Thunder Mix) (DAshoe93) [?] - stream patterns, and I don't think this song has any 12th/24ths
Vanity Angel (bluguerrilla) [+?] - weird 32nd streams (first two)
Vanity Angel (omgitznpv) [?] - first 8ths, stream patterns could be better
Variations2 (jx) [+] (9)
Variations 2 (ElectricWerewolf) [+?] - understepped, mine's better IMO
Vertex - revised (omgitznpv) [+] (8)
Vertex GAMMA (Silvuh) [?] - rhythms are fine, off/overdoubled at parts, steps are going on after the music ends?
Vital Unity (2007 Remake for FFR) (Oni-Paranoia) [+?] - wtf last quad, others are fine
WAIWAI230 (bmah) [?] - guitars are 24th at m9, m11-13, m59-64 are understepped
WaveRip(remastered) (Silvuh) [+] (10) - a bit overdoubled tho
Way out of the dungeon (cyrx900) [?] - gap off, jacks, rhythms are fine
WOW WOW 220 (bmah) [+] (8) - a bit 8th jacky tho
Yager (RubiedCross) [-] - ONS, jacks
00.01 (SulferDragon) [+] (8) - nice patterns
101 kittens (flipsta_lombax) [>] - minijack, decent but sg's is better
101 Kittens (stargroup100) [++] (9) - pretty nice detailed rhythms, only framer issue would remain I guess
4 chord touhou (cetaka) [+?] - good rhythms, but try to avoid 24th trills and other 3 framer jacks
(Too Much) Bass (lol) - rshadow8888 [+] (7) - song is lol
[SHD]Eleventh Hour (i love you) [+?] - 12th jacks, some notes are off
{Flying Away} (Shadowlessheart) [?] - BPM should be doubled, beginning is off use BPM changes, jacky patterns are overused without good reason
{Lazy Summer Days} (Silvuh) [+?] - overdoubled at parts
{Lazy Summer Days} (Xandertrax) [+?] - many 12th jacks at 165 BPM, change the patterns, others are fine
__________________
RIP
Last edited by Tasselfoot; 08-19-2008 at 09:58 PM..
|