[Tasselfoot]

8/1/07:

Queue:
AAA
Adult's Sketchbook
Affected
Arabesque
BB Euro
Bury Me on the Jedi Battlefield
Cruel Whole
Twilight Techno
Dragon's Final Roar
Epidermis - BDN
Fly With Me
Frozen Fire
HTIJ
Half Symphony - SB
Horizon II - SB
Infernoplex
Kaleidoscope
Legend of the starfighter
Midnight Dragon
Monstrous Turtles
Neon-213
Norfolk Gals
Pita
Rottel-da-STAR
Saikyou OX Keikaku
Sakura No Kenshi
Snowball Fight
Sound of my Dream
Speed Limit 38
StarmineX
Synaxis Symphony
The Space Between
Wild Sky
Wisdom - Exag0n
{Arabian Assassin}
Total: 35 songs

Further compare: F by Exag0n to the F by Zero that is currently in queue.


Songs I'm not 100% sure about permission: Rottel-da-STAR, Legend of the Starfighter...  so gimme info about these 2 if you have it.




JX:
[both +] 
15 [+?] - a bit gap late (especially 8ths at the end are off), missing a few notes at the beginning of short streams
AAA [+] (9)
Affected [+] (8)
Careless Love [-] - problem with effect of the song, really unclearly sounded piano, and too short with no fun factor.
Choprite [+?] - want a songcut somehow, silent places especially ending is boring.
Clockwork Genesis [+?] - rhythms are good, a bit overdoubled at parts, some 8th double patterns are weird
CS Gun Sounds - DJ Cristo [+?] - a bit BPM off (BPM is set higher, onsync at the middle), rest is fine
Dragon's Final Roar [+] (8)
Fly With Me [+] (7)
H.T.I.J. [+] (6) - patterns could be pitch relevant, but fine as it is
Half Symphony - Silver_Brian [+] (6) 
Hiszekeny [+?] - rhythms are basically ok but misrhythm on 24th roll at M23, some notes on silence, a bit overdoubled.
Horizon II - Silver_Brian [+] (7)
I'll be right here waiting for you [+?] - blue notes on 4ths at the beginning, rest is fine
Infernoplex [+] (9)
Kaleidoscope [+] (8)
Lapis [+?] - felt middle non-stream parts are a bit too sparse compared to the music and 16th streams at beginning/end
Monstrous Turtles! [+] (10)
Neon-213 [+] (9)
Norfolk Girls [+] (4) - 30 seconds file, a bit too short in general though
Pita [+] (5) - 30 seconds file, a bit too short in general though
Rottel-da-STAR [+] (11) - permission?
Saikyou OX Keikaku [+] (8)
Sakura No Kenshi [+] (7)
Snowball Fight [+] (8)
Sound of my Dream [+] (5)
Speed Limit 38 [+] (8)
StarmineX [+] (9)
Synaxis Symphony [+] (9)
Terror From Beyond v2 [+?] - rhythms are fine, 8th patterns are overall a bit too jacky(4-framers)
The Space Between [+] (8) - sync is acceptable since basically BPM constant song
Together As One [?] - inconsistency of difficulty at parts
Wild Sky [+] - (8)
Wisdom - Exag0n [+] - (9)
{Arabian Assassin} [+] - (8)


[Shash +] 
Adult's Sketchbook [+] (10)
Air Breeze D [+?] - overdoubled at parts, triplet rhythms are a bit repetitive
BB Euro [+] (10)
Bury Me on the Jedi Battlefield [+] (8)
Crystal Syndrome [?] - yellow/blue notes on 4ths at beginning, 8th patterns
Digital Intervention [?] - gap late, rhythm is off at parts (especially 24ths)
Twilight Techno [+] (8)
Dot Matrix Hero [+?] - double placement is a bit weird for me, 16ths rhythms around m45
Elements of a Party [+] (7) - double placement could be better but ok
Epidermis B [+] (11)
ESC [+] (10) - I know it's overdouble'd, but aren't too bad
F E [+] (9)
FictionJunction [+?] - no need for use jumptrills for most of mini-16ths, rhythms/8th jacks are ok
Fun at Times [+?] - patterns of beginning streams, also 24ths are better for the rhythm of beginning of short stream.
Funktacular [+?] - some doubles on 4-framer staircase-minijacks aren't needed IMO
Gigadelic [+] (9) - permission?
Going on Spring Wind [+?] - blue notes on 4th
Innocent Decay [+] (10) - beginning is overdoubled for me, but ok overall
Midnight Dragon [+] (10)
PowerinSilence + [+?] - 8th jacks, double placement
Romeo and Juli8 [+] (7)
Tibs Types with a British Accent [+?] - 8th triplets are a bit repetitive so go with other instrument, short 16th are a bit awkward
Welcome to the Jetgrind [-] - no problem with steps but I'm not a fan of 8 seconds files


[Tass +] 
600AD [+?] - a bit off at parts (beginning of m21/m29, m55), weird double placement. small bursts are better than double on some parts. but overall nice sync.
Air Breeze - V4N [+?] - 24th rolls on 32nd rhythm, offsync at parts
Arabesque [+] (6)
Classical Ecstasy [?] - gap/bpm late, too jacky 8ths, permission?
Cruel Whole [+] (8) - there should be notes on some blank places but ok
Dishwater - Parental Advisory [+?] - jumpstreams are a bit too continuous
Frozen Fire [+] (8)
Legend of the Starfighter [+] (8)
Lucid Quazar [?] - notes are off at parts
M.A.M.A. [-] - yea hilarious file but couldn't stand both song and steps so quit out
Over the Frail Dream [+?] - blue note on 4th, patterns are ok
Power [+] (1)
Roar [+?] - might be better patterns/rhythms than 8th with doubles after M20
Starmine [-] - np with steps but highly doubtful for the permission
You're Not Alone [+?] - double placement, all doubles on some parts, no double on some parts
{The Traveller} [?] - offsync, especially nearly 16th off end of the streams at the middle, pattterns are ok



Shash:
101 Kittens ? (Beginning is offbeat, 48th jacktrill, few of the stream patterns could use work. Some parts were really good, others were really bad)
123 Funk! +? (Trills are a bit much...it'll be 4-frame hell)
15 +
600 A.D. in Piano +? (Part from 55-57 doesn't make any sense at all really, especially jumpwise...nice syncing though)
AAA +
Adult's Sketchbook +
Affected +
AIM Anthem V2 ! (This song does not need a V2)
Air Breeze D +
Air Breeze V +? (Some notes around 38-42 are offsync, triplet patterns in D are better)
Alpha Helix V2 +? (Stream and 32nds are unnecessary)
Arabesque ? (A file this short to this kind of music only doesn't really work with random patterns IMO...needs more music-relevant patterns)
Arnold Remix ? (Jack, sync, song is basically totally unnecessary when we have stuff like tPaTB already)
BB Euro +
Beaker Sunset +? (4ths on blue)
Bury Me on the Jedi Battlefield +
Careless Love +
Chicken Dance ? (Offbeat in places, file really doesn't flow very well)
Choprite + (maybe cut the ending, still good though)
Chrono Trigger Antimatter - (Quit out...completely offbeat)
CIA Rave V3 ! (V3 on this is just not happening)
Classical Ecstacy ! (DE permission?)
Clockwork Genesis +
Counter Strike Gun Sounds D +
Counter Strike Gun Sounds B < (pure preference, both are good)
Cruel Whole +? (Too long and repetitive, cut at around 85?)
Crystal Syndrome +
Crystalis +? (So many 3-framers, though they all fit the music perfectly...discuss maybe?)
Dan ! (per request)
Delta Beat ? (Jump use, rhythms barely go with song at all)
Digital Intervention + (Not sure if 24ths are needed but it's ok)
Twilight Techno +
Disconnected Hyper +? (24th bursts are unnecessary)
Dishwater ? (Don't like the long 16th jumpy streams...song is kind of boring for FFR)
Shihen V2 - (I would honestly prefer something harder than this for a V2 of this song...this isn't really necessary as a V2, only major difference is some rhythms and the song cut)
Dot Matrix Hero +
Dragon's Final Roar +
Eating Candies - (Freeze)
Elements of a Party +
Endless Dream ? (It's not a bad idea for a V2, but god the jumpstream patterns are bad...plus the 24ths don't fit)
Epidermis B +
Epidermis E < (Preference...don't like the stream that much in this one, and it doesn't seem to do as much as B)
Equivelocity ? (Jumpstream and jumpspam are unnecessary...patterns could stand to be less random)
ESC +
ESC (Amplified) +? (Jacks, jumpstream is too much)
Exotica V2 - (Doesn't seem different enough from V1)
Extra Zookeeper ? (wow major YNS lol)
F Z < (E is just too good really)
F E +
Fantasy Impromptu +? (Patterns at end are eh, file goes offbeat somewhere in the second half)
Fascination MaxX Generation +? (Minijacks, that funny 32nd burst thing)
FFL Final Boss - (Ew offbeat, and patterns are meh)
FictionJunction +
FF7 V2 ! (No V2's for this)
FF7 V2 ! (Read above)
Fish on a Parachute +? (Rhythms from 82-89 don't fit very well)
Fly With Me +
Forsaken Neon +? (Oust the 16ths and all 8th jacks, any can be 3-framers)
Frozen Fire +? (Don't like the jump use on the gallops, would be better as tap-jump tap-jump)
Fun at Times +
Funktacular +
Galaxy of Wizard ? (Quit at jacks)
Gigadelic + (We have permission for this??)
Going on Spring Wind +
HTIJ +
Half Symphony S +
Half Symphony V < (Preference)
Hardcore Symphony ! (Permission)
Healing Smile ? (Stream patterns need work, 3-framer possibility in there, green wtf?)
Hidden Sorrow - (Quit out, jacks oh god)
Hiszekeny +
Horizon II S +
Horizon II A < (S has better pitch relevancy)
Horizon Remix ? (Jacks, meh patterns...either have random stream or music-relevant stream, don't try to have repeating patterns that don't actually go with the music)
I'll Be Right Here Waiting For You +
Infernoplex +
Innocent Decay +
Iron Echoes - (Jumpstream is way overstepped, patterns don't flow at all, very beginning is understepped)
Jetstream - (Quit out, jacks, offbeat jumps)
Kaleidoscope +
La Playa ? (Offbeat at the beginning, file is kinda repetitive and boring)
Lapis +
Legend of the Starfighter +? (Those mid-16th jumps aren't necessary)
Lolit Speed - (wtf dude, wtf)
Lucid Quasar ? (Song is pretty boring for a file, seemed pretty offbeat overall)
MAMA +? (I still don't particularly like this idea, but if we're gonna use it then at least lose the 32nds)
MaxX RessurexXion - (Quit out, blue 4ths, offbeat or something, jacks)
Midnight Dragon +
Monstrous Turtles +
Mute City ? (Difficulty variance is too much for song, trills/8th jacks randomly used)
Neon-213 +
NG81953 +? (Stream patterns/jack, try actually naming your file next time)
NG86437 - (Horrendously offbeat, file has no name, song is simply terrible)
Noir Remixed V2 (Quit out, talk about a song that does not need a V2...offsync or something but I wouldn't bother fixing to be honest)
Norfolk Gals + (lol)
Oasis ? (The one 16th stream has awkward patterns, rhythms don't flow well in general, especially that 8th trill part, 16ths at end go on for too long after the fade-out)
Orchestral Angels +? (The part with ALL 8th jumps [68-76] should really go tap-jump-tap-jump)
OV Zero Version - (BPM halving at beginning is just incorrect, beginning is very understepped, patterns in rest of file are ridiculously awkward as are the rhythms, especially the trill parts, randomly placed 8th jacks galore)
Over the Frail Dream +? (Blue 4ths)
Over the Ocean +? (Blue 4ths from that big stop section on)
Partay ? (Offbeat notes and jacks all over the place)
Pita +
Popcorn Remix LOL ? (Offbeat, rhythms are mostly wrong or boring)
Power +? (Way too long, cut please)
PowerinSilence +
R3 V2 ? (Rhythms with yellow jumps don't go with music very well)
Renaissance +? (24th trills = 3 framers, oust them or make them not trills)
Revival Day Impoetus ? (Patterns/rhythms don't flow, 24ths out of place mostly)
ROAR +? (All the places like in m19 feel incorrect, move the two consecutive 8th jumps to the sound that most of the others seem to go to)
Romeo and Juli8 +
Rottel-Da-Star +
Saikyou OX Keikaku +
Sakura no Kenshi +
Salad For Your Thursday +? (Stream at 24 needs a fix)
Shade of Stars +? (File is fine but dear GOD it needs a cut...WAY too long/repetitive)
Shift in Time ? (BPM seems halved especially near end, jump use is pretty random)
Shind Bad - (Nice job shuffling the SM steps)
Skyscrape +? (Totally random jump use for the most part)
Snipertime ? (Offbeat, patterns don't flow, lots of random offbeat rainbow arrows)
Snowball Fight +
Soul Shift V2 - (This is another one of those songs that just really doesn't need a V2)
Sound of my Dream +
Speed Limit 38 +
Spirit Pulse - (Quit out, jacks, awkward stream patterns, file is too long for me to bother finishing)
Starmine ! (Permission?)
StarmineX +
Synaxis Symphony +
Syndrome Craze B ? (After around 47 or so, LOTS of offbeat notes/rhythms, all 32nds and yellowjump parts are overstepped)
Syndrome Craze G +? (All the 24ths don't really work...I'd suggest 16th trills instead for the parts in the music that have 32nds)
Tell Me a Story - (Like half the notes are offbeat)
Terror from Beyond V2 +
The Space Between +
The Turquoise Crayon ? (Better jump use please, too many pointlessly repetitive patterns)
Tibs Types with a British Accent + (I don't particularly like this file and I don't know why, so I'll + it anyway and let the others decide)
Together as One +
Twister Hit - (Understepped, needs more jumps and way more jacks *rolls eyes*)
Vampire Killer ? (Streams need work, last jump wtf?)
Vertex ALPHA ! (To be fair, I did take a quick look at the chart and yea...no. We already said no more of Silvia's Vertex songs unless they're amazing, this clearly isn't)
Viva la PAINKILLERS ? (The 16th streams would honestly be a lot better as random index stream than what you have...the turnstream especially does not fit at all)
Welcome to the Jetgrind +
WiFO ? (If you remove all the 32nds and manage to make the file really fun you MIGHT have a chance at a + from me here)
Wild Sky +
Wisdom E +
Wisdom N ! (Multiple difficulties)
You're Not Alone +? (Tone down the things with 3 8th jumps in a row, this makes a decent easy file but then those are too hard)
{Arabian Assassin} + (However, I would turn the 2nd 4th jump in m19 into a tap, for consistency)
{Barbed Wire} +? (Green parts are slightly offbeat...and they shouldn't be green, we don't want noteskin tricks)
{Event Horizon} +? (Sandwiches at beginning don't really fit IMO)
{I Don't Need You Anymore} +? (Jumptrill 16ths are not really necessary, and I don't really care for the big 24th rolls either...also the end feels kinda overstepped)
{The Traveller} +? (Better stream pattern variety please)



Tass:
101 Kittens +? runningmen, 48th trill doesn't fit rest of file's difficulty, overjumped @ 700ish
123 Funk ? sung put me to sleep
15 +
600AD +
AAA +
Adult's Sketchbook +? jumptrill in middle
Affected +
Aim Anthem v2 - wtf was that in the middle?
Air Breeze D ? many groups not triplets, V4N's better, more pitch relevant
Air Breeze V +
Alpha Helix v2 ? opening, trills, 32ns 600ish triplets
Arabesque +
Arnold Remix ? joke file should be harder, plenty of spots missing, jack @ 300
BB Euro +? 8th section @ start of middle
Beaker Sunset +? 2 jumps in opening, chain
Bury Me on the Jedi Battlefield +? little better burst/stream patterns
Careless Folk +
Chicken Dance - had to quit out, too ****ing annoying, file not very good
Choprite +
Chrono Trigger Antimatter - parts offsync, BNS, quit out @ 32nd staircases
CIA Rave v3 - no v3!
Classical Ecstasy +
Clockwork Genesis + few patterns a bit awkward
CS Gun Sounds B bit overstepped
CS Gun Sounds DJ C +
Cruel Whole +
Crystal Syndrome ? YNS in beginning, BNS throughout, chains, permission?
Crystalis - release it for SM.  we have enough jack syndrome'd crystalis on FFR
Dan - permission
Delta Beat +? offset in beginning, notes missing in 700ish
Digital Intervention +? bit long/repetitive, part @320 off
Twilight Techno +? patterns in 1st stream
Disconnected -Hyper- ? overdoubled, some 8ths in 1st half feel off an 8th
Dishwater +
Shihen v2 - too similar
Dot Matrix Hero overdoubled, more non RBY
Dragon's Final Roar +
Eating Candies ! Mult difficulties, freezes, permission
Elements of a Party +? YNS & voice BPMs
Endless Dream ? grossly overstepped
Epidermis BDN +? less runningmen and trills
Epidermis EW +? more non RBY, missing flowing to main sounds in middle
Equivelocity ? 500 & 850 overstelled for file, jumpstream
ESC +? overdoubled
ESC Amplified ? minijacks, 2nd half needs more creativity
Exotica - dont see the need
Extra Zookeeper - quit out, annoying, YNS
F E ? bit overstepped, one spot twice w/ stream where there shouldn't be
F Z +? better of 2, 24ths may have 3 framers, just overall could be better
Fantasy Impromptu +? stream patterns
Fascination Maxx ? file is bland, bpm changes, jacks
FFL Final Boss _? offset, stream patterns a bit
FictionJunction ? song is blah, jack syndrome out the butt, repetitive
FF7 Battle v2 hi19 +? bland, slightly overstepped, permission
FF7 Battle v2 S ? not good, quit out, follow music better, permission
Fish on a Parachute +? 2nd chain, 4 note 16ths near end should got to music better
Fly With Me +
Forsaken Neon +? 3 framers, remove any 8th jacks
Frozen Fire +
Fun at Times +? pretty boring, weird patterns
Funktacular +? just not a fan of easy files with tons of 4 framers
Galaxy of Wizard ? jacks, sync
Gigadelic +? too long, jumpstream needs breaks, permission
Going on Spring Wind +? permission? parts in middle not pitch relevant
HTIJ +
Half Symphony SB +
Half Symphony V$N < like the non-jack, less doubled version better
Hardcore Symphony +? fix up opening stream, slightly less doubled
Healing SMile +? inconsistent stepping of sounds, 64ths, end note
Hidden Sorrow - quit out in beginning, jacks
Hiszekeny + maybe step to some of the more unique sounds in the 2nd half
Horizon II A +? lacks intensity
Horizon II SB + green notes in opening?
Horizon Remix - quit out at pause in middle, pitch relevant stream, no jacks
I'll Be Right Here... +
Infernoplex +
Iron Echoes - quit out at 64th roll, way overstepped
Jestream - quit out, jacks, overstepped
Kaleidoscope +
La Playa ? overstepped, would make for a really nice 2 or 3 difficulty file
Lapis +
Legend of Starfighter + permission?
Lolit Speed - chains cause 3 framers
Lucid Quazar +
MAMA + hilarious
Maxx Resurrexxion - sync, BNS, jacks, flow
Midnight Dragon +? gap a bit off in beginning, overall could be a bit better
Monstrous Turtles +
Mute City < like the file in queue better
Neon-213 + boring song
NG81953 +? wtf is this? minijack
NG86437 - sync is off
Noir Remixed - i would not dare insult my friend by releasing this garbage
Norfolk Gals +
Oasis ? stream @ 200 not stream, 420s not 8th trill, 32nd too hard for file, ending rolls go past music
Orchestal Angels ? beginning needs to be easier, fix up 8th jump section
OV ZeroVision +? fix up section after 1st jack section, change from 8ths to vocals
Over the Frail Dream +
Partay ? jacks, missing sounds
Pita +
Popcorn Remix ? beginning half understepped, ending half overstepped
Power + clearly understepped.....   just don't think people will enjoy this.  at all.
Power in Silence +? steps to vocals?
R3 Omega really trying to discourage random v2's
Renaissance +? fix 3 framers in trills/24ths
Revival Day Impoetus ? 24ths are less note than you give them, jumpstream not in music in most places
ROAR +
Romeo & juli8 +? go to vocals throughout or mostly
Rottel-da-STAR + permission
Saikyou OX Keikaku +
Sakura No Kenshi +
Salad for your Thursday ? sound levels on the layers suck, file is repetitive as ****
Shade of Stars ? cut the song, repetitive, permission
Shift in Time +? beginning missing sounds
Shind Bad ? maybe cut 1st half? stream patterns, random 24ths
Skyscape +? missing notes in beginning
Snipertime - fix sync, shouldn't need 64ths, minijack
Snowball Fight +
Soul Shift v2 +? 1st half could go w/ music a bit better
Sound of my Dream +
Speed Limit 38 +
Spirit Pulse - quit out after 8th minijack
Starmine + permission from Ryu?
StarmineX +
Synaxis Symphony +
Syndrome Craze B - BNS, gap off, quit out after 10 sec
Syndrome Craze G +? 2 24ths that form jacks w/ jump
Tell Me A Story ? parts off, 24th 1 handed trills, jacks at end
Terror from Beyond v2 +
The Space Between + sync off a bit in a few spots
The Turquoise Crayon ? little more variety than straight 8ths, permission
Tibs Types +? ending seems more complex than 8ths
Together As One + how long is the full version?
Twister Hit - quit out at jacks, overstepped [Heavy]
Vampire Killer +? stream patterns suck, ending double
Vertex Alpha ? where are the 16ths?
Painkillers - worst stream ever
Welcome to the jetgrind +? bit overstepped, length
WiFO - no
Wild Sky +
Wisdom E +
Wisdom N ? 32nds? 4th jacks at beginning
You're not alone +
{Arabian Assassin} +
{Barbed Wire} MAC7 - quit out at 64ths
{Event Horizon} +? ending overstepped
{I dont need you anymore} +? bot overstepped, some 24/32 cause 4 framers
{The Traveller} + little bland

all discussion should go in the queue thread. all future batch updates will go here.