Quote:
Originally Posted by AlexDest
Your superiority is ignominious.
Stop attempting to say there's an objective way to view simfiles. It's inexistent.
|
I never said there was an objective way to simfiling as a concept, I expressed an overly dramatized statement. If KBO was still around, I could show you a post that I made about how there is no right way to make a correct simfile with plenty of musically relevant examples that no one was able to respond to.
There's nothing ignominious about saying that a simfile should have a structure, and I'm sure a lot of higher level simfile artists would agree. Regardless of what you think,
that is an objective measurement. There's also an objective way to view simfiles in terms of correctness in rhythm and sync, so if you want to sit here and say THAT doesn't matter, then you have issues.
and Carlos: honestly, at least she goes out of her damn way to provide somewhat detailed notes. I won't sit here and say that I didn't question her being on the team at first, but she's done a ton of judging at ThirdStyle and her notes are helpful/specific. Having someone who at least provides plentiful notes to help a user is better than someone who writes one-liners that are like "yeah, file is ok [7/10]" since a user doesn't even know what they lost points for.
sorry, but if people are going to take things this way, then the judgment team needs to be restructured.