[Lights]

Originally Posted by hi19hi19

The identity of having well synced high quality files can't be maintained with the inclusion of dumps. They are literally defined by not being synced. That's the assertion I made to argue that dumps shouldn't be in the main song list. Read.
Unless I'm missing some sarcasm / joke here, you didn't really post anything to back up the assertion that these files should be in the main song list.

Not being synced to peaks on a waveform, sure. But, and this is the beauty of using ghost notes within the context of a dump, you're not always playing a game of "put the arrows on the waveform" in the first place. This doesnt exclude it from being synced properly provided that the arrows that are matched to distinct sounds in the song are still correctly timed and the ghost notes are still spaced coherently relative to what is being charted to the literal interpretation of the music.

for example, if you chart the sustain of a specific sound as a group of 3 24th notes starting at the peak of that sound, you can still have consistent sync in your file, despite only one of those 3 notes matching to a distinct peak on a waveform. As long as the ghost notes arent hanging out in the middle of nowhere with no direct relation to the actual structure, theres nothing unsynced about a well made dump.