View Single Post
Old 01-5-2013, 10:08 AM   #12
moches
FFR Player
 
moches's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2005
Age: 29
Posts: 3,996
Default Re: FFR Compilation Pack Of Pure Awesomeness

here are reviews for the singles if anybody wants to reference them


Little Drummer Punk Droid v2 (moches)
Dstrukt (AlexDest) - yes
Boulafacet (moches)
Rottel-Da-Station (ferrari) - yes
Gun Rock v2 (ferrari) - yes
Reon (Condoct vs Detrimentalist) - yes
Training Mode (ferrari) - yes
Twirling Star (wc) - yes
Satori De Pon (Valor) - yes
Burning Body (moches)
Sorceress Elise (Kommisar) - yes
Shion (Don) - yes
Retro City (Razor) – I dunno. Very fun in some parts, kinda sloppy in others. Maybe?
Hajnal2 (Anaru) - yes
Switcharoo (Baq12) - yes
Drawcia Soul (Choofers) - yes
Ringo's Theme (Kommisar) - yes
I Wanna Give You Devotion (Arntonach) - yes
Chain Dumbin' (Detrimentalist) - yes
Robotomy (Choofers) – fuck yes
Wish (Eurobeat) (Rebirth) – good MA file. yes
Dancing Box (rog) – dope file. yes
Dirtwalker (Choofers) – very neat. yes
Hand Throw (AlexDest) - yes
Windowlicker (Mr. Tea) – kinda bland imho. Well-stepped but not too much going on. Should I throw this in?
Blackout #11 (Choofers) – dump. Would accept if it were the audience, but nope. Maybe create a supplementary pack for dumps?
Electric Butterfly (ATTang) – first half: wow, kinda cool, actually. Second half: LOL FUCK NO
Koi no Bakkin Bakkingamu! (TheSilentLord) – pretty fun, I gotta say. That said, a little generic (there’s tons of files like this) and a few errors strewn here and there. I could see myself accepting this with updates
Lost Love (iRanch) – awesome file. This is exactly why we need this pack. That said, please add a less streamy intermediate chart if possible.
Abandon (Valor) – quite cool. yes
o'er the flood (IcyWorld) – ridiculously fun. A perfect example of fun > technicality. That said, there are some very obvious errors in this file that I think could be tweaked. I’d like to go over this with you later if possible. For now, yes
Wax Crayon Sky (Valor) – enjoyed much more on second play. yes.
Bloodflow (Choofers) – sick. cut song length!! I also think you could add a TON of cool effects with mines/colors and shit in this song…if you don’t mind, could I add another chart to this?
Magical Voice Shower (iCeCuBEz v2) – cool. Yes.
FXLP (Valor) – just don’t think this song is very steppable. Huge difficulty spikes, and the rest is just 8ths. Probably not
Ghosts (Vincent De Moor Remix) (Choofers) – beginner was fun, yes
Nippon Egao Hyakkei (skorpion9x) – yes
sin (cetaka) – yes. It’s cetarker
Tsugaru Apple Mix (Choofers) – A+ scoring file. Super fun and replayable. YES
Princess Cowgirl Show (Choofers) – really fun but ending…yeah, way too difficult compared to rest of file. I still love this, so I think maybe you should split this chart: make the ending of the intermediate chart easier and make the rest of the harder chart harder. Conditional yes (you already have like 12393291 files in here, though, so lol)
Fucking Paranoid (Choofers) – a lot more fun than I expected. Kinda random patterns but really neat tricks. yes
Triple Baka (Choofers) – mp3 quality is awful haha. Fun file, maybe try to make it a bit more interesting/bombastic by adding mines or hands? Light yes
Near Dark (Choofers) – well-made but song’s pretty repetitive. Needs to progress more, maybe. I’ll have to see v2 before making any decisions
Bubble Trouble (Choofers) – fun but pretty dumpy. Also got kinda repetitive near the end. You have a lot of better files in this so I’m gonna say no
Worship The Prankster (samurai7694 vs Torrent) – tone down long freezes: they make the beginning a bit hard to read. otherwise, yes
Zyph's OP (Herogashi) – pretty fun but not rly looking for dumps in this pack lol. Maybe keep as obligatory pack dump file (although o’er the plains already kinda fulfills that role too…)
Freedom Dive (DarkBreezee) – couldn’t find this but we have 12390321 files for this song already
Madou Monogatari II Final Battle (Kommisar) – simple but fun. Some of the 16th stream/jumpstream in the first verse confused/bored me, but the rest is pretty nice. yes
Ice Cream (blindreper) – sorry
INFINITE PRAYER (AlexDest) – okay. This is WAY WAY harder than a 7. A 10 at least. Wow. I had fun, but I wonder if you could try making an intermediate chart with the mines toned down. A sort of dodgeball file for newbies if you will. yes
Chopin, Nocturne No.2 in Eb (Checked_Out) – assumed Normal is the main chart, played that. Holds were really weird, had to quit out. with holds off it’s a beautiful file, really impressive sync job and the steps capture the nuances well. A few patterns irk me a little, might tweak this a little. The last note should be a mine. Otherwise yes
Kuusou Mesorogiwi (Fantasy Mythology) (Xx{Midnight}xX) – wow, I’m impressed at how much you’ve improved. Technically proficient and fairly decent patterns throughout. That said, you limit yourself a LOT by stepping those long holds to the vocals. Jack theory/jumps would have been a better choice imho. 32nds are a bit arbitrary but fine to hit. Wouldn’t say yes, but I do want to say that you’re making good progress. Keep up the good work!
Cool Number (TheSilentLord) – not quite following all of the layering in the file, particularly the 16th triplets in the verses and the holds. Song itself is a bit too repetitive actually. Decent but not quite right for this pack. no
moches is offline   Reply With Quote