[Sa Li El]

So far, all of the game movies I have seen have been horirble. Final Fantasy Spirits Within wasn't very good, Advent Children was borderline horrible, and Doom... I didn't even watch Doom the whole way through.

I think for me maybe the thing that a game movie misses is the "game" part of it. The reason I like games is because of the gameplay, when it becomes a movie, the pieces of gameplay that fill in between the story sequences are missing, and it's not the same. Maybe some games do have good storylines, but it's also because nobody is required to act them, just maybe the voice actors. Whenever it hits the screen, for me, it seems to fail.