Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

Definitely. A really bad song cut is very much reason then to reject a file, because it really detracts any finishing touches for a song. In other words, it's more specific than "song sucks".

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

Welp, guess I get to go through another whole resubmission process mess like I did with scavenger. Kind of sucks how 16/20 rating cant get like a light accept or something and be put in conditional especially when people get those ratings where one rating kinda throws off the other good ones given. =\

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

So would mine be considered borderline?

+ +. +. +? [16/20]

If so what happens?

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

borderline files will move to judge's vote stage.

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

Here you go:

Analyzed: 5/5+/5+/5 (20++)
A Beautiful Storm: 5/5/5/5 (20)
Finders Keepers: 5/5/5/5 (20)
Camel: 4/5/5/5 (19)
Flesvelka: 5/5/4/5 (19)
Electrical Parade: 3/5/5+/5 (18+)
Chrome Gadget Zone 8bit Mix: 4/4/5+/5 (18+)
12 Bar Bloops: 5/5/4/3 (17)
Comfortably Lost: 4/4/4/5 (17)
Experiment: 4/4/4/5 (17)
Feeling This REMIX: 4/4/5/4 (17)
Distorted God: 4/5/4/3 (16)
Frog's Theme: 4/4/5/3 (16)
Cybertron: 2/4/5/4 (15)
Baby Still Too Fat: 4/3/5/3 (15)
Corrupted Minds: 3/1/5/5 (14)
Euromorroc: 4/2/4/4 (14)
Giants in the Ocean: 4/1/4/4 (13)
Defection: 4/3/2/4 (13)
Chopsticks: 3/3/1/4 (11)
Expand Life: 2/3/4/2 (11)
Electrolosys: 3/1/3/3 (10)
Altair: 1/2/1/1 (5)

RESUBS:
Ready to Go: 5/4/5+/5 (19+)
Scavenger: 5/4/5/5 (19)
Try Harder: 4/5/3/4 (16)
Sonic 3 - Ice Cap (Remix): 4/1/2/4 (11)


====================
JULIAN: 5/5+/5/5 (20+)
Heavenly Spores: 5/5/5/5 (20)
Homosexual Love Scene: 5/4/5/5 (19)
Musicmaker RX: 4/5/5/5 (19)
JULIA: 5/5/5/4 (19)
Humoresque No. 7: 5/5/4/5 (19)
Mathsma Attack: 5/4/4/4 (17)
Gunkienen Tar Mercury: 4/4/5/4 (17)
Nothing's Gonna Stop Me: 4/4/4/5 (17)
Illumination: 4/2/5/5 (16)
NaiNai69: 4/3/5/4 (16)
Nyanyanyanyanyanyanya!: 4/3/4/5 (16)
He's a Pirate - F-777 Remix: 4/2/5/4 (15)
Lawn Wake II: 3/3/4/5 (15)
Luna Ascension: 4/3/4/4 (15)
Indignant Divinity: 3/5/2/2 (14)
Grateful Para-die-se: 2/2/5/4 (13)
Kirlian Changes: 3/4/1/5 (13)
Sun and Stars: 4/5/missing/4 (13)*
Halloweenies: 2/2/4/3 (11)
Melons: 3/[2]/4/1 (10)
Jingle Bells Hardstyle: 2/1/4/2 (9)
Grasp Reality: 2/2/2/3 (9)

RESUBS:
No Salt: 4/5/5/5 (19)
In the Wind: 4/5/5/4 (18)
Metro: 4/[4]/5/5 (18)
Glorious Morning: 3/3/3/3 (12)
=============

[iironiic] Passage D: 5>/3>/4/5> (17 >>>)
[w_c] Passage D: 3</4</4</5< (15 <<<<)

Senerade of Storms: 5/5/5+/5 (20+)
Sleet: 5/5/5/5 (20)
The Gateway: 5/4/5/5 (19)
I Remember When: 4/4/5/5+ (18+)
Pokemon GSC Elite Four: 5/5/3/5 (18)
Dance and Zeal: 4/4/5/5 (18)
System Split: 4/5/4/4 (17)
The Final Hour: 4/4/5/4 (17)
System Failure: 5/4/2/5 (16)
Fatum Anima: 3/4/4/5 (16)
Aim Burst: 4/5/4/2 (15)
Unf: 3/4/5/3 (15)
Youshou 02: 4/4/4/3 (15)
An Unwanted Magician and a Cheery Rebel: 3/4/4/4 (15)
Subconsciousness: 4/3/4/3 (14)
Thunderdome Got CRUNK: 3/4/4/3 (14)
Peculiar Pattern of Circles: 2/2/4/3 (11)
The Bird's Concrete Nosedive: 2/1/2/5+ (10+)
Powerpuff Gabberz: 3/1/3/3 (10)
Tyomutyomepu: 2/1/4/2 (9)
Pizza Butt: 2/2/2/1 (7)
Rain: 1/1/1/1 (4)

RESUBS:
Fast Asleep: 4/2/5/4/ (15)
Colibri: 4/5/3/3 (15)
A Battle for the Sky: 4/4/3/3 (14)
Cest What: 1/2/4/3 (10)

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

(Double posting in case the notes are getting copied by code)

Being that you got two + ratings, you might actually still be alright. Either way, you'll get tossed into the borderline, and being that you had two strong accepts, other judges might feel the same.

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

Thanks, Halogen.

Instantly Accepted Files (33)

Analyzed: 5/5+/5+/5 (20++)
A Beautiful Storm: 5/5/5/5 (20)
Finders Keepers: 5/5/5/5 (20)
Camel: 4/5/5/5 (19)
Flesvelka: 5/5/4/5 (19)
Electrical Parade: 3/5/5+/5 (18+)
Chrome Gadget Zone 8bit Mix: 4/4/5+/5 (18+)
12 Bar Bloops: 5/5/4/3 (17)
Comfortably Lost: 4/4/4/5 (17)
Experiment: 4/4/4/5 (17)
Feeling This REMIX: 4/4/5/4 (17)
JULIAN: 5/5+/5/5 (20+)
Heavenly Spores: 5/5/5/5 (20)
Homosexual Love Scene: 5/4/5/5 (19)
Musicmaker RX: 4/5/5/5 (19)
JULIA: 5/5/5/4 (19)
Humoresque No. 7: 5/5/4/5 (19)
Mathsma Attack: 5/4/4/4 (17)
Gunkienen Tar Mercury: 4/4/5/4 (17)
Nothing's Gonna Stop Me: 4/4/4/5 (17)
Sleet: 5/5/5/5 (20)
The Gateway: 5/4/5/5 (19)
I Remember When: 4/4/5/5+ (18+)
Pokemon GSC Elite Four: 5/5/3/5 (18)
Dance and Zeal: 4/4/5/5 (18)
System Split: 4/5/4/4 (17)
The Final Hour: 4/4/5/4 (17)
Ready to Go: 5/4/5+/5 (19+)
Scavenger: 5/4/5/5 (19)
No Salt: 4/5/5/5 (19)
In the Wind: 4/5/5/4 (18)
Metro: 4/[4]/5/5 (18)
[iironiic] Passage D: 5>/3>/4/5> (17 >>>)

Borderline Files (12)
[16pts and stronger-15pts this time]

Distorted God: 4/5/4/3 (16)
Frog's Theme: 4/4/5/3 (16)
Cybertron: 2/4/5/4 (15)
Illumination: 4/2/5/5 (16)
NaiNai69: 4/3/5/4 (16)
Nyanyanyanyanyanyanya!: 4/3/4/5 (16)
He's a Pirate - F-777 Remix: 4/2/5/4 (15)
System Failure: 5/4/2/5 (16)
Fatum Anima: 3/4/4/5 (16)
Aim Burst: 4/5/4/2 (15)
Try Harder: 4/5/3/4 (16)
Fast Asleep: 4/2/5/4/ (15)

I'll send pm about second vote system to all judges.

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

Senerade of Storms: 5/5/5+/5 (20+)

Missed that.

Also, Passage D has 17 but idk if that means accepted or not because it had two submissions.

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

....

:')

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

yay, A Beautiful Storm got a 20.

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

Apologies, it looks like Rebound just forgot to review Sun and Stars. (@rebound: just pm me your review)

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

just updated SAP list, TOP 3s are close.

It will be updated again when vote's done.

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

excellent my record remains clean hehu.


except for rain. that's unforgivable....


also i could argue about the 24ths in dance and zeal. they're there :3

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

Passage D has no unintentional missing notes. Everything was stepped as is intentionally


If you don't like that then screw you I quit!!!

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

For judges:

I just sent PM about voting.
reasons/comments aren't needed for it, send me the result ASAP.

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

already sent pm. though I wasn't too sure about he's a pirate but........

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

That's quick.. thanks.

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

Oh cool, judges liked my Chrome Gadget. Happy days.

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

btw we can send fixes for files already queued right?

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2
 

For instantly accepted files of this batch, yes.